The full term abortion Dr. who was murdered?
How ironic.
How could you kill a baby after its been born. thats just sick. Abortion period is sick. I think he deserved it.
I hope this doesn't draw too much criticism, but a full term abortion is performed before the baby is born. Anything after is considered murder. In no means am I saying I am a supporter of abortion BTW.
no matter what term we use killing a human being with a heartbeat is murder!
what do you call when women get rid of their babies before the fetus forms a heart?
I don't think he deserved to die. I don't understand how you can condone the taking of someone's life in the name of "pro life". It makes no sense to me.
Tim is right. Late term abortion happens prior to the birth of the child and is not considered murder by Kansas state law. This particular doctor was investigated and deemed not guilty of breaking any laws prior to this incident. I have to say that if a person believes abortion to be murder, he/she needs to take steps to change the laws in their community instead of resorting to murder themselves- especially in a place of worship.
No offense to anybody who is pro life, but what about women whos life would be in danger because they are pregnant? Some womens bodies cannot handle a pregnancy and it can cause preeclampsia and toximia. Some women do have to abort their babies. So, I do not think in that case that it is murder. There are many situations that a woman may need an abortion and to judge her for that is wrong.
No offense to anybody who is pro life, but what about women whos life would be in danger because they are pregnant. Some womens bodies cannot handle a pregnancy and it can cause preeclampsia and toximia. Some women do have to abort their babies. So, I do not think in that case that it is murder. there are many situations that a woman may need an abortion and to judge her for that is wrong.
Agreed.
right, and I am not talking about those em, thats a whole different story. But if you look at statistics, majority of abortions are performed because of age or "its just not the right time".
And I would not have killed the man, because I think its only fair everyone has a chance to repent. But he was constantly having threats to his family and himself made, why continue doing such a thing??
this is how late term abortions are generally performed. So yes, I would say it is straight up MURDER.
--D&X" (dilation and extraction) The woman's cervix is dilated. If necessary, the fetus is rotated until it is facing feet downwards. The surgeon reaches into the uterus and pulls the fetus' body, with the exception of its head, out of the woman's body. Surgical scissors are inserted into the base of the fetal skull, and withdrawn. A suction tube is inserted and the fetus' brains are removed through aspiration. This partially collapses the fetal skull. The fetus is then fully removed from the woman's body. 2
---Induced labor: Medication is administered to the pregnant woman which triggers labor. The woman eventually gives birth to the partly developed fetus.
No, nobody really came out and said "Hey I'm judging you", but I think people should look at these situations both ways and then determine where they stand, ya know?
Paula- I am going to try to provide insight to your question, but please don't take it as me wanting to start an argument because that is not how it is meant.
He has had many threats, including a bombing of his abortion clinic and being shot in the arm (because the gunman missed). I studied this particular case a lot in my terrorism class. Anyway- I think he didn't stop because he does not feel what he does is wrong. That is his belief and his opinion that is obviously supported by those in his community (state). There are always a few extremists in every group who take matters in their own hands, and I think he was willing to risk that or perhaps not be bullied by that.
I would also like to point out that in my research on the subject for class, I found that only 1.4% of abortions are late-term. And almost all of those are because of fetal abnormalities or risk of death to the mothers. If you think of it that way, he was helping to save some lives as well. And maybe that is why he continued. Who knows? But, that is just my food for thought.
they do abortions at landstuhl if the woman's life is in danger. i think they should legalize abortion for women whose babies have trisomy 18 too.
Like, I said, different story. But Just because the child isn't perfect in your eyes? because of trisomy 18? I totally disagree.
I am sure his family supported his decision since they decided to stay with him. I cannot speak for them of course, but I would imagine they would have left after the first two attacks on his life, one of which happened over twenty years ago, or after the hundreds of threats he's received since then. I wouldn't call that unfair.
Also, of those 1.4%, almost all are due to health issues with the fetus or the mother that are life threatening. I think that is a whole new way of viewing late term abortion. Those that you mentioned earlier who obtain abortions because they are not ready for a child do so within the first term in almost all cases. It is VERY rare for someone to attempt to obtain a late term abortion for reasons other than I mentioned above. And, correct me if I am wrong, I believe late-term abortions in that sense are illegal in almost all states if not all currently.
But, I know we're not going to agree on this issue. I am pro-choice and definitely can't be convinced otherwise, but I respect your viewpoint completely.
its not because of the childs appearance. trisomy 18 babies dont live very long, basically you're just waiting for them to die. would you rather have them born but in pain? its like euthanasia
I am pro-choice and definitely can't be convinced otherwise, but I respect your viewpoint completely.
right back at ya'. Well pro-life.
and in some of the articles i read, majority of the abortions he performed were because of a defect or life endangerment, but not all. And I still believe that just because a baby is going to have a deformity is not a just reason to kill it.
its not because of the childs appearance. trisomy 18 babies dont live very long, basically you're just waiting for them to die. would you rather have them born but in pain? its like euthanasia
I would not want them to be in pain but, who are we to decide if he/she lives or dies?
Trisomy 18 I dont know if you know this but a baby with trisomy 18 usually does not make it past a year so if I were in that situation I would NEVER put a child through that. So, I don't think it has anything to do with " not seeing them as perfect" it's about their well being and I couldnt see a child suffer like that.
I would certainly not condemn a woman for making the decision to terminate a pregnancy in which the fetus had a condition that was incompatible with life. I don't think that any of us can honestly say what we would do uless we were faced with the situation, ourselves. I would like to believe that I would carry the baby as long as possible and deliver; holding it in my arms until it took it's final breath...but who's to say what my heart could really handle, you know??
As a side note, I know a woman who battled infertility and finally conceived twins through IVF. Right at the cusp of her 3rd trimester she developed severe eclampsia. One baby died in utero and she and her husband had to make the heartwrenching decision to terminate the remaining (dying) twin to save her life. Her doctor performed an INTACT D&E. I think it is tragic that legislators value the lives of unborn babies over those of WOMEN.
I dont value either life more than the other. I just know that I am 7 weeks from delivery, and if the doctor came to me right now and told me ethan had trisomy 18, and may not live a week, there is no way I would terminate this pregnancy. No way.
Paula- I completely understand where you are coming from and honestly, I would probably be the same way. I personally would not choose abortion as an option for myself (unless my life was in danger), but I still do not want to remove that right from other women. I think that when such tragedy occurs, all we can do is allow the family to make a decision and support that decision. I would not want them to force me to have an abortion, so I wouldn't want to force them not to, especially if that were the case (the child would be in pain and not live very long).