Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

to circumcise or not to circumcise

who's talking here?

Rebecca L 1
StayingHere 2
Mojo 10
paulaaaaaa 6
*Robin* 5
Tonya 3
Emily 1
Tessie 3
Liea 3
PapaSmurf 3
WitnessProtectionProgram 3
Robyn 8
ashml 5
Lori 1
Melinda 7
Bahet 4
Paris 2
Santa 1
Steph 2
doddlebug 2
Inge69 6
mckenzie 1
Chikadi 1
Jody 1
kristy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Melinda --- 16 years ago -

that is the question. I am trying to answer that question. In the research I've done I've found no medical reason why you should circumcise, so I guess I'm trying to get a poll of what people have done. If you've had a boy in the last 10 years or so, what did you decide to do? 

*Robin* --- 16 years ago -

neither of my boys are circumcised i did not see much of a point in doing it 

Robyn --- 16 years ago -

I have two boys 5 & 3 and they are circumsiced. our reason is so they look the same as their dad, and, for us, we really didnt have to think about it, we were just gonna do it. if that makes sense. either way is fine, just flip a coin lol. the only thing with non circumcised is it is a bit harder for the little boys to clean. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

it is harder for the boys to clean..also i've actually spoken to someone that isn't circumsized but I won't go into detail why he hates it LOL...but that won't come into question until your child is older...other than that I really don't see why it really matters. I did get my son circumsized because his father asked me too 

PapaSmurf --- 16 years ago -

Some studies suggest that having your child circumcised may: * Reduce the risk of penile cancer. * Reduce the risk of urinary tract infections and consequent renal complications. * Provide greater protection against sexually transmitted diseases. * Eliminate the risk of phimosis. * Reduce the risk of prostate cancer. 

Melinda --- 16 years ago -

i read that papasmurf but it also stated that but new research suggests that reduction is so so tiny that it's not really worth mentioning 

Chikadi --- 16 years ago -

Hopefully you won't take this in a wrong way, but I am sure someone will not like it. Why would you not? Is his father clipped (don't have to answer, something to think about)? Also, like ashml said, think about when he gets older. I know a lot of women who really have problems with that and that can be kind of traumatizing for a man I would think. Not to mention when he is in school and has to shower in gym or something. I hope this makes sense and I really am not trying to be rude with it. 

PapaSmurf --- 16 years ago -

I have known men who for one reason or another were circumcised in adulthood. Needless to say they wished it had been done when they were days old instead of years old. And if you're really into the cultural aspects of the procedure, check out the procedure/celebration in Turkey! Very different from the US for sure! 

mckenzie --- 16 years ago -

my youngest brother was born almost three months premature so they wouldnt do his right away, well because of that he had a few infections and my mother was a nurse too so she knows how to clean them. but after he got it done hasent had another one. 

StayingHere --- 16 years ago -

My son is almost 2 and he isn't. There was no question about it, we were not going to do because of his dad. It is not hard to care for and you teach them as they get older. I was worried at first because of infection, etc but we had no issues. My husband isn't and well he is well into his 30s and never had an issue. Be prepared for the American drs to question you over and over again if you decide not to. The German drs will question you to because it is so common for Americans to have it done. 

StayingHere --- 16 years ago -

Oh and if it is not done right there can be problems, i.e my nephew was had more problems with infections. My SIL and brother had to have it redone. 

kristy --- 16 years ago -

I have a 6 year old boy and he is. i was just under the impression it was easier to keep them clean. 

Robyn --- 16 years ago -

i agree with victoria6red you gotta consider lockerroom situations. most americans do so he might get picked on. ask the soon to be baby boys dad what he thinks, would the dad rather have it done or not, and go with that :) 

Lori --- 16 years ago -

I have a very close friend who is not and he REALLY REALLY wishes that he was.... teenagers can be mean and since most boys have it done... well, there can be a lot of teasing. 

doddlebug --- 16 years ago -

I think it is a cultrual preference...from my research I took it to be that medically there really is no real difference, as you say the recent studies would suggest it is negligable ...many European countries do not practice it and they dont get lots of problems due to it...it is after all the way we are born...however I can see how having it may make cleaning easier, as you do have to retract once the child gets older....I'm from the UK where its not done, my husband is from the US and is....we tried to decided the best for our son emotionally as well as medically. While we think it would be good for him to look like Daddy, he will in all likelyhood end up going to a British school, and so we finally based it on the showers at school situation. We just wanted him not to feel vunerable or different at a sensitive age... it will be your choice and which ever one you make will be the right one...as you have considered it so openly and approached it so wisely what ever you choose will be correct. 

PapaSmurf --- 16 years ago -

doddlebug....so right you are! 

Bahet --- 16 years ago -

Most of the "medical" reasons to get circumcised are myths or old wives tales or skewed numbers. There is no medical reason to circumcise a perfectly healthy baby. Yes, sometimes, for some reason, it may need to be done in adulthood. But that is rare. Sometimes women need to have their breasts removed when they are adults but we don't go around lopping off newborn girl breast tissue. The "looking like the dad" theory is silly too. Sorry but it is. How often is a boy going to see his father naked after he is old enough to notice the difference? Dad has hair there too so there is already a difference from a child. Plus, is it really that difficult to tell him the truth? The locker room theory also holds no water as more and more boys are uncircumcised. Besides, kids will pick on each other for having hair early, not having hair late, being fat, being skinny, etc. Any boy who comments on circumcision is just asking to be made fun of for staring at another boy's genitals anyhow. The cleanliness issue isn't a factor either. The foreskin is akin to the vulva lips of a girl. You simply move the skin to clean, you don't cut it off. That all said, both my boys are circumcised. They are older and I wasn't as well educated back then. If I could do it all over I would not circumcise them. 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

I have two boys 5 & 3 and they are circumsiced. our reason is so they look the same as their dad, and, for us, we really didnt have to think about it, we were just gonna do it. if that makes sense. either way is fine, just flip a coin lol. the only thing with non circumcised is it is a bit harder for the little boys to clean. My reasoning is the same. My son is also. 

Santa --- 16 years ago -

I agree with Ms. Bahet. Also, please do a research how is done. Has anybody seen how is done? I have, I was traumatized by it. All I can say if you do decide your son to be cirmcumsized-take a look at the doctor doing it-I bet you won't do it to your next son. 

Robyn --- 16 years ago -

surgery is never pretty 

doddlebug --- 16 years ago -

Funnily, that's why my husband (who is) was the one who actually made the decision not too circumcize our son, he did see it peformed and it obviously made an impression on him, that being said...I stress again this is your personal decision...it's one of those matters where a lot of us will possibly have strong views one way or another....and as a loving mother you alone will know whats best for your son. 

Paris --- 16 years ago -

I have 2 boys. The first was circumcised the routine way, but my second son (2008) had the plastibell procedure- we loved this way so much better and it healed perfectly. Just saying there's more than one way to circumcise. 

Paris --- 16 years ago -

Good luck with whatever you decide :) 

Rebecca L --- 16 years ago -

My 4 year old is not, and when I give birth in June, this baby won't be either. The way I see it- that skin is there for a reason. Why take it off? KWIM? 

Jody --- 16 years ago -

This is just my opinion... I am a Pediatric nure and mother of 2 boys that have been circumcized ( although not very well) First there are 2 different procedures. Gomco and Plastibell....I perfer the plastibell although there are very skilled Dr's that do the Gomco.You can ask the Dr to completely numb the area before the proceedure and I have seen many babies sleep thru it. Now everything that everyone has said is good info and I agree with most.....But please look at increased std rates in uncirc areas of the world..also there are infections and if the young man wants or needs it later it can be a very very painful proceedure. If I had to do it again I would still do it even though my boys look uncirc'd now. I have taught them how to clen it but it does get hard now that they are older to make sure it is clean enough... Good luck and congratulations! 

Steph --- 16 years ago -

Test. 

Steph --- 16 years ago -

Ok weird, it wouldn't let me post before... Like everyone else is saying, its really a personal choice for the parent. I've done some research, and I guess it goes both ways, pros and cons for each... 

Tonya --- 16 years ago -

All 3 of my boys are.As soon as each one was born my husband insisted we have it done immediately.I didnt question him until the youngest boy was born.Come to find out he had had a very tramatic experience,he was circumcized at 12,yes 12years old and remembers everything.He went with each one of the boys to watch the surgery to. 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

There is no actual medical reason to circumcise. The STD rate is mostly in relation to AIDS, and is mainly pushed in areas with a high AIDS occurence. I don't really know what "Looking like his dad" has to do with anything, is it like they're going to compare later? There are several sites you can go to and read a lot of information about circumcision. www.mothering.com/discussions (this one is pretty extreme in some ways, but buried in the crazy there's a lot of good info out there) www.sybermoms.com also has a lot of info if you look in the parenting sections. Infection rates are not that high, and if they are taught to properly care for it. Both my brothers aren't circ'ed and they never had an infection or anything, and they are adults now. It also didn't cause them to be teased more, nor has it affected their ability to get a girlfriend. In the end it's a personal choice, but all I can say is that it's really not a medically necessary procedure, more of a personal choice and it's a procedure that is mainly done in the US, outside of the US it's not common at all. 

Inge69 --- 16 years ago -

My son is circumcised. I really don't think it's that big of a deal, especially with the plastibell procedure available. I let my husband make the choice. There are always going to be pros and cons to everything. I agree with everyone else that this is definitely a personal choice. However, I know men that hated being uncircumcised and had the procedure done as adults, which is much more painful along with a much longer recovery. I'm curious of those who didn't circumcise their boys, did you or would you have your girls ears pierced? 

page 1 2 3
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground