I can't even begin to share my thoughts on this, but I shall. I am not against them building there mosque in NYC what bothers me the most is that they are so disrespectful to the American people and wanting to put it so close to the site where there fellow country men took the lives of numerous Americans. Its just plain disrespectful and being from NY myself I really am having a hard time seeing anything good coming from this being built. Ok so that is my two cents on the matter, go ahead and tear me apart if you must but this is my opinion and nothing will change it.
It's an interesting issue. Considering the claimed intent of the new building, my first question is, will this help bridge the cultural gaps we have? Or, make them worse? New York is an incredibly culturally diverse city. I personally think that this one of it's greatest assets. I've been there 3 or 4 times and despite all the wonderful attractions, it's the combination of peoples mixed throughout the city that I enjoy most. I love Middle East cab drivers even though they scare the sh!t out of me as they do battle in the traffic. The notion that we'd now like to restrict some portions of this cultural free-for-all doesn't sit well. On the other side of the coin, I do think it's bit vainglorious of the Muslim community to assume a highly visible role so close to ground zero...kind of like opening a McDonald's next door to the Japanese memorial in Hiroshima...it's just not kosher.
I'm content to hope for the best though (like I have many choices).
Apparently, as reported, a great deal of Muslims pray regularly at ground zero. They pray for those who lost their lives and I'm not talking about the terrorists. Is this an offensive gesture? Maybe to some, but is it really any different than Americans praying over the lives lost at Hiroshima?
The "Muslims" that blew up the World Trade Towers were fanatical, religious zealots.
Unfortunately, all the fanatical religious zealots didn't die in planes on 9-11-01.
Fortunately, I believe that the large majority of Muslims don't hold the same values as the zealots, and shouldn't be penalized just because they are Muslim.
I saw "prayer room".....will other denominations be able to use it as well, or is it specifically for Muslims?
There are two properties which are to be used to build this Mosque. One they own, the other is owned by Con Edison (energy service provider) they still need to acquire this building. With all of the negative connotations regarding this particular Mosque, I doubt that they (Con Ed) would sell. To compound the difficulties which Cordoba House (the Mosque group) is sure to find, is that in NYC only union workers are allowed to work in pretty much all phases of building construction, from the iron workers, all the way to the glass people. I've heard that all unions will refuse to work at the site.
Regardless of what happens, this is going to be interesting to watch.
So, how many people did I piss off with my comments?
My issue with this is simple. Christians, Jews, Muslims and Buddist died in the attactk on 9-11. Atheists, Agnostics, Catholics, good people and bad, all died in that attack. Who gives a rats a$$ if they want to put a mosque up. The people responsible for this attack are not more recognized by Muslims than most of claim Christains who kill doctors and blow up clinics. They do not recognize those cowards as crusaders for their cause, but rather extremists who much made their lives that much harder. Anyway, that is just me.
While I respect the office that he holds, I do NOT respect or agree with this choice. I think that President Obama is wrong and it is insensitive and uncaring for the Muslim community to build a mosque in the shadow of ground zero. I guess THIS was the ONLY place for them to build this. Next step..inviting the families of the actual hijackers to come worship there. I am not saying that I hate Muslimes....I hate the extremists that did that....what MY question is...WHY cant they build a Mosque elsewhere...NOT on a spot that brings so much pain to American memories. I understand what all is going there....I have read the story on exactly what the building will hold. I do not agree with WHERE they are building it...put a memorial there, put a small park and a fountain there. I also KNOW that while it is... NOT AT ground zero, it is close enough TO where tragedy struck where I would not have something there that would constantly remind me of the fanatics that did this....before you say I am contradicting myself...I dont feel that a memorial is the same. Is there NO other place that they can build this? I am sure there is...WHY that spot? I tell you what...heres what we'll do. The 16th street Baptist Church in Birmingham Alabama where that horrific bombing took place in 1963 where 4 little african american girls were killed and others were injured, lets make that church a meeting place for the folks that were responsible...I am sure that folks would welcome the Klan there with open arms and say lets let bygones be bygones, we all need to live together in peace. Why does eveyone want to hold hands and sing kumbyah with this one? There ARE other places to do this...THEY dont want to go someplace else...THEY want THAT spot...they were offered another place and refused? I just want to know WHY? What is it about THAT spot? Is it the dirty money that they are getting for it, is it the message that I am SURE THEY know that will be sent throught the Muslim world INCLUDING the radicals...hey...look what happens, kill a bunch of innocents and a few years later, get an open arm welcome. I have nothing against tolerance...but if you blow something up that kills thousands of innocent people and you (as a group/people) have been heard spouting hate against a nation of people...I for one dont want anything to do with you. WHY should I...you dont like me so why am I gonna open my doors and invite you to dinner? Perhaps I'm wrong but before I invite a fanatical American hating person to my house for dinner, that spot will be held by a follower of David Duke (and YA'LL KNOW that will not happen...at least in MY house...perhaps the white house since he loves everybody)
The message is that they aren't all jihadist fanatics and that they are american, too, and they felt the loss and the pain, too.
If you want to use that argument, how many people have died at the hands of christians? Should we be offended by every christian church we see? I think it's a far cry from accepting Klan members, they are a bona fide hate group, and espouse discrimination and racism. Very different from a Muslim Mosque, in my opinion.
Timothy McVeigh was a christian; should we be offended and up in arms over a christian church/monument near the site of the Oklahoma city bombings?
Exuse me Marissa...I dont get out of my little cave much so I may be mistaken...I thought that the people responsible for the hijakings and terrorists events of September 11 2001...I think they are OFFICIALLY known as al-Qaeda have been known to say that they DO NOT LIKE AMERICANS...they have also been known to go as far as saying that they HATE Americans...would someone who is KNOWN to hate Americans be also called a bona fide hate group?? Not trying to stir up anything but you see...Im a poor country girl from Nebraska and where I come from we would call them a hate group. Where you come from..what do they call them?? They HATE and discriminate Americans...or have you seen something where they have said differently? PLEASE let me know and I will be the first to say...WOW...I am totally wrong about them...let me find one so that I can apologize to them for slandering them.
Tomithy McVeigh a Christian...mmmmmm...again...dis here po black chile from Nebraska is yet agin confused...not wanting to discuss religion but in da BIBLE my poor mammy left me before she passed away...there is a passage that tells me that I SHALL NOT KILL...now I know it has been done in the past and its wrong...Timothy was a disturbed young man...who thought that HIS way was the ONLY way...and anyone who thought differently...well...they needed to die...even if that meant killin babies. PLEASE educate this po po individual cause now Im a hella confused...I mean...I put him with the likes of Jim Jones, David Koresh, The Haley Comet guy and all the fanatics out there who kill innocents in the name of religion.... what IS a bonafide hate group?
I am already feeling the acid reflux here from agreeing with Marissa on her points.
You simply cannot put everyone in the same group just because of their background.
We put memorials at sites all of the time. This is not really any different. The Muslims in question here are not radical nut jobs. Their intentions are not to anger anyone, but rather to honor those who lost their lives. To group these Muslims with the religious nut bags of 9/11 is pretty short sighted.
Marissa's comparisons aside, I am very close friends with a Muslim. Muslims are very peaceful. But, like with any large group of people, there are going to be a fraction of them that are wacko fanatics and make the rest look bad.
You have to be able to separate the good from the bad. Separate the wheat from the chaff, so to speak.
Don't let your blind hatred for one group of rotten eggs make you hate the entire group.
Okay....then will someone PLEASE answer me this..... why not build this at another location? WHY THIS one??? I have NOTHING against Muslims OR their wanting to build the mosque.... just want to know WHAT and WHY is so special about THIS spot that it HAS to be built here....will building on THIS spot give you ALL the virgins you want? (not really trying to be funny...I REALLY and HONESTLY dont understand). Im not putting them all in one group because of a few that didnt know how to fly a plane and ran it into an American Skyline that has been around for YEARS and a symbol of the Big Apple...would you feel the same if it were on the spot of the Statue of Liberty? Would you feel the same if you had a loved one that perished that day? I HAVE separated the good from the bad and I KNOW that not all Muslims are the same... D-UH...just like all of my race is not the same...can you imagine if every race was the cookie cutout image of everyone within that race...THAT would be NOT interesting....all Al Sharptons runnin around... LET ME STRESS (hence the all caps) I, HUSKERFAN DO NOT HATE ALL MUSLIMS, I DONT HATE WHITES, I DONT HATE BLACKS, I DONT HATE INDIANS, I DONT HATE LATINOS, I DONT HATE JEWS...I DONT HATE ANY RACE...I HATE IGNORANCE AND HATRED ....and I hate that its 46 minutes past my bedtime and I am gonna be a BEAR in the morning...
What a lot of people tend to forget is that radical Muslims kill many more Muslims than they do anyone else. Just ask your average Iraqi. I understand about the controversy around building a mosque at the 9/11 site and there's a part of me that agrees that it shouldn't be allowed.
... on the otherhand, wasn't increasing hatred between muslims and "the infidels" one of the major goals of the attack to begin with?
Partial List of Muslim 9/11 Victims:
Note: This list is as yet incomplete and unconfirmed. It has been compiled from the Islamic Circle of North America, the Newsday victims database, and reports from other major news organizations. The victims' ages, employers, or other personal information is included when available, along with links to further information or photos.
Samad Afridi Ashraf Ahmad Shabbir Ahmad (45 years old; Windows on the World; leaves wife and 3 children) Umar Ahmad Azam Ahsan Ahmed Ali Tariq Amanullah (40 years old; Fiduciary Trust Co.; ICNA website team member; leaves wife and 2 children) Touri Bolourchi (69 years old; United Airlines #175; a retired nurse from Tehran) Salauddin Ahmad Chaudhury Abdul K. Chowdhury (30 years old; Cantor Fitzgerald) Mohammad S. Chowdhury (39 years old; Windows on the World; leaves wife and child born 2 days after the attack) Jamal Legesse Desantis Ramzi Attallah Douani (35 years old; Marsh & McLennan) SaleemUllah Farooqi Syed Fatha (54 years old; Pitney Bowes) Osman Gani Mohammad Hamdani (50 years old) Salman Hamdani (NYPD Cadet) Aisha Harris (21 years old; General Telecom) Shakila Hoque (Marsh & McLennan) Nabid Hossain Shahzad Hussain Talat Hussain Mohammad Shah Jahan (Marsh & McLennan) Yasmeen Jamal Mohammed Jawarta (MAS security) Arslan Khan Khakwani Asim Khan Ataullah Khan Ayub Khan Qasim Ali Khan Sarah Khan (32 years old; Cantor Fitzgerald) Taimour Khan (29 years old; Karr Futures) Yasmeen Khan Zahida Khan Badruddin Lakhani Omar Malick Nurul Hoque Miah (36 years old) Mubarak Mohammad (23 years old) Boyie Mohammed (Carr Futures) Raza Mujtaba Omar Namoos Mujeb Qazi Tarranum Rahim Ehtesham U. Raja (28 years old) Ameenia Rasool (33 years old) Naveed Rehman Yusuf Saad Rahma Salie & unborn child (28 years old; American Airlines #11; wife of Michael Theodoridis; 7 months pregnant) Shoman Samad Asad Samir Khalid Shahid (25 years old; Cantor Fitzgerald; engaged to be married in November) Mohammed Shajahan (44 years old; Marsh & McLennan) Naseema Simjee (Franklin Resources Inc.'s Fiduciary Trust) Jamil Swaati Sanober Syed Robert Elias Talhami (40 years old; Cantor Fitzgerald) Michael Theodoridis (32 years old; American Airlines #11; husband of Rahma Salie) W. Wahid
dis here po black chile from Nebraska is yet agin confused...not wanting to discuss religion but in da BIBLE my poor mammy left me before she passed away
i love husker and i had to LOL at this!!
i dont want to go into my "reasoning" for my opinion but i dont think it should be built there period..lets build a memorial or something but not this..
I don't have the answer(i leave it to the politicians)lol,but you should go to bed or you will be grumpy in the morning and will be no good to anybody.lol
...Daisy...yes ma'am...Im going ot bed now...I felt a small growl escape from me already...LOL
JOFTAA...THATS what they call non Muslims...INFEDELS...WOOT WOOT...thats better than SOME names Ive been called...sorry...I HAD LOL at this word...thats to Jeff Dunham and Achmed...LOLOLOL http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1uwOL4rB-go
Don't let your blind hatred for one group of rotten eggs make you hate the entire group. If I buy a carton of eggs and find that one of them are rotten, I'm going to throw the whole carton of eggs away without trying them. And you better believe, I'm going to be very picky when I go back to the store to get another carton of eggs. I am going to check every single one of them out. I'm going to smell them and I'm checking the Sell By date and the Expiration Date and who makes them.
I'm from a medium size town in Kentucky. This one business owner came to town and wanted to open up a Strip Club and met all the requirements for a business permit. All the realtors got together and not a single one of them sold this guy a property. Even though our City Management system gave them permission, it was The People that would not let the guy buy anything. Now is this wrong? That guy needs money. The strippers he would employ need money. Well they didn't get anything but a closed door slammed in their face out of Owensboro, KY!!! And I'm proud of it!
Yeah of course! A strip club not allowed in my city is just like a Mosque not allowed near Ground Zero. Strippers can be great even though some are really nasty. Either way we didn't want any strippers there. I think Mosques are great. I wouldn't want to stop anyone from praying. I just do not think Ground Zero is the best place. Everytime families go to grieve and remember the fallen victims of 9/11, they would be staring at the Mosque and hatred would overcome their heart when they should be mourning their loss.
Owensboro also told Casinos they couldn't move in either. No gambling or strippers. Most of the adjoining towns are "dry". It is a little boring there, but we have two Super Wal-marts so everything is great!!!
Everytime families go to grieve and remember the fallen victims of 9/11, they would be staring at the Mosque and hatred would overcome their heart when they should be mourning their loss.
You sure are leaping to conclusions. At best this is pure conjecture on your part. If I were to be grieving there, I might see a mosque as a symbol of peace and prayer.
Did you even read either of the articles that I linked to? Apparently not. The mosque is blocks away from ground zero. The mosque can't even be seen from ground zero. So, how can mourners be so overcome by hatred during their mourning when they can't even see it?
If we are going to have an intelligent debate here, people need to have the facts. You can't just fly off the seat of your pants with emotion as your guide.
I'm going to ignore the whole stripper/mosque comparison because I just can't wrap my mind around the logic of that.
Why does it matter? If we said, lets build a christian church two blocks away, would that be pleasing, and if so, why? Separate Mosque from terrorist and you will find you have people who live in peace, and are deeply convicted by their religion. Is it location, location, location, or is about the fact the the 9-11 plotters are extremists? I do not understand. They are not suggesting a memorial for the people who committed these crimes. This is not a memorial this is a church. You all have to remember what this country that we love so much and have our loved ones risking life and limb for, is based on FREEDOM of religion. Why would we want to go backwards. Can we not separate the people who commited these acts and the religion they claim to follow?
The mosque is going to be 2 blocks away in downtown NYC. It won't be seen by anyone at ground zero because it will be blocked by the 30 other buildings between GZ and the mosque.
JOFTAA, I clicked on the links as I pretty much always check out the links you post because they are usually informative OR really funny. I'm not leaping to conclusions as 42% of people polled thinks the Mosque would be provoking.
I haven't seen the Building plans but I assumed (I know bad on me) that the Mosque would be pretty tall and would be seen past the 2 buildings between the location in question and Ground Zero. See, I have been deployed to the Middle East 5 times already and would say I have never seen a small Mosque.
If people have the right to never feel remotely religiously intimidated or uncomfortable because of someone else's religion someone better inform Fred Phelps and that Focus on the Family dipwad that they need to pack up and leave.