Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Survey reveals troubling numbers of military personnel in debt

who's talking here?

VeggieGirl 1
Mojo 6
HuskerFan 2
anne 1
WitnessProtectionProgram 2
ashml 9
Melinda 1
Kristen 2
Euro Maker 3
jess.d 1
Abe 5
oszbbk 2
Jen04 4
Atticus Finch 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Whenever I'm traveling and I see uniformed military personnel, I can't help but become a little teary-eyed.

I worry that the service members may be shipping out to Afghanistan or Iraq. I appreciate the sacrifice those in the military make, especially the many who are in combat zones.

So it's with no less concern that I'm troubled about the percentage of servicemen and women who are struggling financially. A new survey focusing on the financial capability of military personnel has found that while many in the armed forces are handling their finances fine, an alarming number aren't doing so well.

MORE FROM THE SOURCE 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

There are a lot of underlying reasons for the debt. The majority of people come into the military straight out of high school (I did) and may or may not have a solid education in money management. They see a steady paycheck, and want to spend the money living a good life.

Unfortunately, I think it's a reflection on the american concept of "Why can't I have what I want?" and the mindset of huge debt and living well above their means, which caused the current recession. "I don't really make enough to afford this house, but if they'll give me a loan, why buy a house for $125k when I am pre-approved for $500k?"

However, I don't have as much sympathy for military members, because they have TONS of resources available to help with financial planning and management. My roommate and I used to use the Family Support Center's financial advisor to help us learn how to balance our checkbooks.

I firmly believe that High Schoolers should have a required course in financial planning; setting a budget, smart shopping for groceries and/or bigger items like vehicles, properly using credit to ones advantage, instead of getting into massive debt and only paying the minimum, shopping around for good deals on things, buying used/secondhand when possible, stuff like that. I don't even remember doing that when I was in high school.

But when you get a lot of young people coming into the military, probably making more money than they are used to, with little/no budgeting skills, it's a recipe for disaster. 

Abe --- 16 years ago -

JOFTAA indeed the statistics are bad. I think there are several contributing factors.

1. Young soldiers away from home without parental guidance on how they spend money.

2. Lenders, furniture/electronic/mechanical stores all offering "low" financing to soldiers, who are uneducated about the useof credit.

3. Simple fiscal irresponsibility, in other words many have also not been taught budgeting.

4. They hide their issue until some one calls the Company/Battery/Troop/Squadron looking for payment.

5. Lack of family planning. I fear some see free health care and obviously maternity care and think it is a great idea to have kids while serving. It is, provided your budget can allow for it. I fear many do not bother to even look at it from this aspect.

The one thing I can assure you it is NOT, is pay. An E-3 makes $1923 base pay before taxes. That does not include BAH, BAS and any other entitlements he may recieve.

It also does not include enlistment or re-enlistment bonueses which up to recently were ranging from $15,000 to 30,000 for 4-6 years. Avergae that over the years and add to the pay and it is pretty substantial.

With that said, it is still obviously an issue and we can do a better job of addressing it. 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

I'm not sure how much more it can be addressed, Abe. The message is everywhere to be responsible with your money, and where to go if you need help.

But I agree with you. The family planning thing is a particular thorn in my side, babies are expensive and only get more expensive the older they get lol. 

HuskerFan --- 16 years ago -

I cannot tell you how many military young families who are on WIC and or Food Stamps. It IS very sad...it has been going on since I was in (late 80s early 90s) and sad to say...it has not gotten any better. I was stationed with a guy who was my age (early 20s at the time...he was married with 3 kids below the age of 6...HE had no choice but to get on assistance...he was literally struggling and living paycheck to paycheck. HERE...at Ramstein...I worked with a girl at my first job who had 2 kids, had to live OFF base for whatever reason (probably cause base housing is for married people) and often did not eat because that would be taking food out of her kids mouths and what not, she would tear her car inside out to find money for lunch.

I DO agree that Financial Management should be a MUST to take in high school...they don't even have Home Ec (which did all of that...at least when I went to H.S.) anymore in allot of schools....
While the Family Support IS there...allot of people wont go to them for feaar of word geting back to their units and supervisors....it DOES happen. 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

Yeah, see, that's a common idea that word will get back that you went to Family support. I have sent numerous people to the financial planner, and it NEVER got back to commanders or supervisors unless they wanted it to.

What people don't understand is that they can put their security clearance, and therefore their job, at risk, by utilizing poor financial planning/decisions. The Family support center can't notify a commander that XYZ person went in for budgeting help, but other agencies are required to when the same person is heavily in debt and not meeting their obligations. 

VeggieGirl --- 16 years ago -

It also does not include enlistment or re-enlistment bonueses which up to recently were ranging from $15,000 to 30,000 for 4-6 years. Avergae that over the years and add to the pay and it is pretty substantial.

I'd love to see one of those reenlistment bonuses. My husbands been in for 11 yrs and we sure haven't seen one. 

Melinda --- 16 years ago -

I think army and marines are more prone to giving bonuses. Noone i know in AF has gotten one. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

Just to add two cents but not every "young military member" will spend their money left and right. My husband and I (i am 21 and my husband 23) have 3 bills (car, insurance, and internet/phone) and we manage weekly on food and we still struggle. Yes I won't deny some young members do not spend their money right...but you also have to think pay grade, children ...years in service...

and abe my husband is an E4 and doesn't get paid NEARLY the amount you mentioned....... 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

I didn't say all, Ash. I said most. There are a lot of irresponsible decisions made, some of which have to do with family planning and trying to live above their means.

Melinda, Air Force used to get bonuses, but recently (in the last 5 or so years) all but stopped doing them. I was one of the last to get the big bonus in my field. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

didn't say all, Ash. I said most.
i know, just putting my two cents out there LOL

my husband got a bonus, but only because he went from reserve to active, and that was 4 years ago. I have heard they do bonuses on how high the demand is etc..right now demand isn't high to recruit 

oszbbk --- 16 years ago -

Army here and we've gotten $0 for enlistment. 

Abe --- 16 years ago -

Ash, you are right, your husband earns $1889.70 before taxes. Not less but MORE.

people anything below E-4 is considered an entry level position. Good lord do you expect to running IBM in your first 2 years of working there?

The funny thing is this is the one job where the pay is posted BEFORE you sign up so there is no excuse.

Yes some people enlist who are already in financial trouble, thinking it will help, or they have been out fo work forever, but that's the exception not the rule.

Again using my example with ashml as an example...(not to pick on you but since you mentioned your specific situation) assuming your husband is at least an E-3 with 2 years and takes home a minimum of $1500 a month (not counting COLA, BAS, etc) a reasonable car paymenr of $300 plus $100 for insurance plus another $150 for phone/internet/cable...that means you have $550 of set bills. Please tell me how THAT is a struggle having nearly $1000 left over for food, gas etc?

My prediction is you are not on a budget. If so I would be more than happy to help you set one up so you can feel good about the small amount you have left instead of beating yourself up for being down to your last $10 before payday.

Trust I make a lot more than that and I still use a budget, why? Because they work and help me save for the future.

By the way Marissa, did we actually agree on something?

Oh yeah for your AF folks I do not feel bad for one second that you do not get bonuses. Rather I am jealous of YOU, lol. 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

Abe, I had to do a double take, too lol. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

Ash, you are right, your husband earns $1889.70 before taxes. Not less but MORE.
abe I know my finacial situation, we don't get paid that amount, even if finance didn't screw up his pay (which its been 14 months and still not fixed) my husband gets MAYBE paid 100 dollars extra than a factory job he used to have before going active, his mom who gets paid $13 an hour at Moen (working on the line) gets paid more than military does...yes factor in pay grade etc...thats not me complaining. Things I LOVE about the military and everyone would be totally screwed without it, is heath care, money for housing and utilities...and other things. Thats why my husband wanted to join....trust me its not because of the money...and I will give you benefit of the doubt..over in EUROPE ...you have to factor how much you get paid in the states also...and abe if my husband should really be getting that amount...then me and finance are going to have a little chat because I haven't seen that amount of money (before taxes)since my husband was in iraq.... 

HuskerFan --- 16 years ago -

All in all....military pay is not what people on the outside think it is. I know folks that think because we are military....we are rich...HA! 

Abe --- 16 years ago -

Ash, his pay is clearly posted on a variety of websites simply by looking at the charts. Once you see his grade and years of service that amount SHOULD be the one on his LES, if it is not then YES have HIM go and roll some heads. If you need help doing this let me know, I am in a position to help!!

Your hubby's mom makes $2236 per hour. I assume she is at least 20 years older than her son. I would say your husband, judging by his family, is well on his way to doing MUCH better than his mom. Good for you guys, that is every parents' wish!! 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

ty sent you PM 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Your hubby's mom makes $2236 per hour.

Where can I apply for this job? 

Abe --- 16 years ago -

LOL@myself. Thanks for pointing that out Dork.

I think I will leave it unedited, that way people can see what an idiot I truly am. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

LOL@myself. Thanks for pointing that out Dork.

I think I will leave it unedited, that way people can see what an idiot I truly am.


Maybe you can hire a proofreader for $2236 per hour? 

Abe --- 16 years ago -

The sad thing is it is thinking before the fingers catch up syndrome.

Further, I have a Master's Degree, with all the papers that involved typing, and yet I still hunt and peck. I can do it at over 40 WPM but as you can clearly see w/o and easy spell check I make a "few" errors. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

well I am a dork LOL 

oszbbk --- 16 years ago -

have HIM go and roll some heads

Do you really think the ppl in finance would notice if their head were rolling?

Both times I have been there, has been a joke. They actually told us the other day to stop our car and insurance allotments and then we would have more money...????? Wow! You think that's a good idea really? Which that wasn't even what we were trying to address that day. Needless to say they provided zero insight to the problem at hand.

To anyone who has to go to finance here...goooood luck!

*steps down from soap box*

...carry on... 

jess.d --- 16 years ago -

I'd love to see one of those reenlistment bonuses. My husbands been in for 11 yrs and we sure haven't seen one. 
I think army and marines are more prone to giving bonuses. Noone i know in AF has gotten one. 
my husband got a bonus, but only because he went from reserve to active, and that was 4 years ago. I have heard they do bonuses on how high the demand is etc..right now demand isn't high to recruit 
Army here and we've gotten $0 for enlistment. 


i know i quoted like a zillion different people lol but we are army and hubby has never gotten a bonus for enlistment or reenlistment and he was national guard before being active..i make more than his base pay for a month and im not even working a job that my degree is in..hubby loves what he does so its ok!

ash you REALLY need to see finance cause if your not seeing those numbers then something is REALLY wrong!! 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

ash you REALLY need to see finance cause if your not seeing those numbers then something is REALLY wrong!!
thanks but like Ozbkk said they are idiots and it has been 14 months, and to top it off, when they where paying us too much when he first started. He had to pay it back...not even letting us know, just had a baby and they where taking money out left and right, now this year, they aren't paying us enough...its like really is it that hard to fix? I think they just don't want to have to admit their mistake and back pay us. but abe here said he can help so lets pray he works some freaking magic LOL..and abe I would like to say sorry for above post...you obviously know what you are talking about. 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

 

Jen04 --- 16 years ago -

ashml - the amount Abe posted is the amount an E4 should be making right now in 2010. You can go to the DFAS website and see exactly how much an E4 with x amount of years should be getting as base pay monthly.

You say you are "paying back" the military. On your LES, under the deductions section, is there a deduction entitled "debt"? And under your LES where they put announcements and all that stuff, does it have a running balance of your debt? My husband was overpaid and once the error was caught, we worked it out with finance to where we paid a set amount monthly for a certain period of time. Our monthly payment was deducted each month, the same amount, and it was reflected on our LES. We also knew our current balance every month because it would be updated. If you owe the military and have this on your LES, you should be able to see how much longer you have to pay them. If you don't, and they're just docking your pay, I'd go to finance asap. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

[i]It also does not include enlistment or re-enlistment bonueses which up to recently were ranging from $15,000 to 30,000 for 4-6 years. Avergae that over the years and add to the pay and it is pretty substantial.

I'd love to see one of those reenlistment bonuses. My husbands been in for 11 yrs and we sure haven't seen one.
[/i]


We did not either, not in 20 years. Still, no one should 'bank on' enlistment bonuses anyhow, since they can change and vary. Regardless, the few that I recall bragging about them in the past were some that were in terrible debt too. Sad 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground