Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

To steal or not to steal?

who's talking here?

paulaaaaaa 22
HuskerFan 1
Fran 3
MandaR 1
Bob 3
RoxAnne 1
WitnessProtectionProgram 2
Rachel 1
ashml 9
Bahet 6
Steph 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

So this is a two part question...Background information... So A long while backat walmart I saw a mother with a toddler throw a shoe box into a clothing rack, and on the baby's feet were these pearl white brand new looking shoes. I said nothing...So question one is if you had seen the same thing what would you have done? Question two: It got me thinking about if it came right down to it and I had no money to buy the necessities for my child would I steal? My Answer: I would do everything in my power to avoid stealing, but if I had to, yes I would. What is yours? 

Steph --- 16 years ago -

If I had seen that occur, I would probably have offered to buy them for the woman. You can go to jail for shoplifting. If her child really needed the shoes, and I had the money. I would just help them both out. A pair of shoes at Walmart for toddlers probably wouldn't be more than $20. If I had no money and my child needed something, I would probably also steal it. There are organizations out there to help, but I also understand there are dire circumstances. I too would do everything to avoid stealing, but I would not let my child go without something the NEEDED. 

MandaR --- 16 years ago -

I think that by the time you found somebody to tell that a person is stealing, especially in a place like Wal-Mart, the person stealing would be long gone. I used to work at a dept. store and theives have a tendency to disappear into thin air. But... I don't know about clothing nessecities, I've got a large family that will help out with that kind of stuff, they send stuff to my kids all the time. But as for food and that type of necessity, I would in a heart beat steal to feed my kids if I couldn't find an alternative. I'll do anything to keep my kids from suffering in any way. 

Bahet --- 16 years ago -

I'd report her. Most shoplifters can afford things, they just don't want to pay for it. I'm not about to accept that I have to pay more so they can steal. If their child literally has no shoes go to a garage sale or Goodwill or a church or ask a friend, neighbor, or relative. If we were in such dire straits I still don't see where theft would be an option. Get a job. Get a 2nd or 3rd job. And above all don't breed them if you can't feed them. 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

I'd report her. Most shoplifters can afford things, they just don't want to pay for it. I'm not about to accept that I have to pay more so they can steal. If their child literally has no shoes go to a garage sale or Goodwill or a church or ask a friend, neighbor, or relative. Wow A bit harsh. Some people have too much pride. Maybe they had money when they had their children and this economy changed all of that, then WHAT????? 

Steph --- 16 years ago -

I would say you were a bit harsh Bahet, not knowing someone's situation and assuming they have money and just like to steal... There are other options, but sometimes you've tried everything else and your back is against a wall... What if her house burned down, her husband died, she had no money, no job, but was trying as hard as she could... No one is perfect, but without knowing someone's situation I can't just condemn them as easily as you. Stealing is wrong; I am not saying its not... But if your child were going to die, would you not steal in order for them to live? Going as step above food, lets say your child needed a drug to live, and your insurance wouldn't pay for it. And he needed this drug to live, would you just let him die? Or would you steal it (after trying other ways to get it)? 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

Wait wait, you can't go on a compare a DYING child to stealing shoes! And if it was about stealing to get medicine your child needed to survive... more than likely you'd be stealing from a pharmacy or straight from a hospital. Close to impossible without getting caught. I don' think its harsh. Salvation army...free. Almost every place has them. Garage sales are obviously cheap. People pride is their own doing and shouldn't be a burden to the rest of society. There is a lot of help out there for our American people that a lot of countries out there don't have. Programs and whatnot that are there for people like this. I agree Bahet. There are always alternatives to stealing. Whats gonna happen if she gets caught? Baby without a mom or baby without shoes? That said, I wouldn't turn the mom in IF for sure I knew she was poor as dirt. But how would you know that? A lot of cleptos are using their kids too. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

I agree with Cassandra. There are plenty of places to get help in America without stealing. Besides Salvation Army with free stuff, there are a crazy amount of thrift stores now with the economy, not to mention how much/often Americans throw away perfectly good stuff. I cannot really see a situation where I would have to steal to take care of my child, at least, not in America. If you are willing to work, and/or ask for help, you can get by. Not have four flat screens and a new SUV maybe, but you can get by. 

RoxAnne --- 16 years ago -

I would become a stripper before I stole things... And let me say, I may start out as the worst stripper ever but I would become the BEST stripper ever to make sure my kids have what they need!! 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

well what people don't realize unless you been in a situation where you needed something (no money or food etc) you don't know how things work. Yes grant shoes per say etc you can get at a thrift store or garage sale or something of some sort. But I have seen a persons house burn down (and mind you this woman made barely $300 after taxes a week and had 3 kids) they had nothing and they went to salvation army and was told they could not help them. Same with food if people don't donate to the organizations can't give people things they don't have. Alot of churches try helping but even then they are also limited. Has a teenager I have been in situations where we had to do everything possible to eat thank god we never had to steal but we always find a way to eat, if the local churches/organiztions couldn't help us out. (i had a very sweet coach that knew a pastor who took a liking to me and my brother) 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

My mom stole before when i was with her. We got a lot of free food from the food bank and stuff. We once went without water for 2 weeks. No toilet or anything. Damn, I was DIRT poor until i was 8. So i know what u mean ashley. Until youve BEEN THERE you do not know what you'd do. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

but i have to agree though not knowing a person situation I would still turn them in..there are many people that steal for the thrill. I have seen shows where people are clearly capable of paying for what they steal but its the rush or possibly an addiction..now if to find out she is lets say a single mother of a couple of children then I would try to help her out..in this day in age its hard to get by on what my husband makes couldn't imagine making less .... 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

Well you can a lot of the time tell by how they look and what they're wearing... 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

well my situation was a little differant it was either live with a man that let his wife beat us or live with an alcoholic mother that DID work but we only saw her everyonce in a while to hand us money to pay for bills and that was it..i lived off those 25 cents cookies and chips from the gas station for quite some time..thats why I am also a stay at home mom I don't want my kids to ever think I never am there for them since the hubby makes a ok amount of money. We can't buy everything but I surely can provide the necessities and they always come first..and trust me if my babies where starving and there was no other way to get food or whatever then I would be a stipper or steal..sad to say 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

I know what you mean. I have been on both sides. I grew up dirt poor then at 8 years old moved into a wealthy home and was raised there. So I know how it is...Most people dont so theyre quick to say "oh i would never!" 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

Don't assume that just because a person wouldn't do it, doesn't mean they have never been in that situation. That they have always had it good. Maybe they just aren't willing to tell everyone how hard they had it. Its no problem if you do but some people just don't want to get that personal with everyone. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

well you can't change peoples veiws, but thats why i can't stand certain organizations...and I will always donate (canned food clothes etc) because I know how it is to ask for help as a kid and them look at me and say no...even soup kitchens have to turn people away. Yes these organizations exist but THEY get to choose who is worthy to get stuff and thats IF they have any of it...I like smaller organizations they tend to get more personal and at least try. Too many times have I seen salvation army turn really poor people away...my mom made 12,500 a year and they still thought she made too much money to receive food stamps isn't that some sh*t? (6.50) and I have seen people walk in with nice clothes on their backs and nice cars and they can walk in and get food stamps..one woman even had the nerve when they thought I had cancer (when i was 16) that since my parents where white they had more of an oppurtunity to find a better job..yeah LOL obviously they didn't know who my parents where LOL 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

Eh, i dont care if I tell people of how I grew up. Its really not personal when it was all public years ago. hah 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

well no one is saying that just saying i would never let my babies starve and grant it yes I could find them food etc but if it came to it I would never let them go hungry..would I steal possibly..but I doubt I will have to do that personally as an adult...people just jump to conclusions saying stuff like "don't have kids" (which some parents should lol) or do this and this and this...not saying no one here saying that didn't have it rough just saying its not as easy as you think in some places 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

"don't have kids" thats what got me. you never know what their situation was when they conceived the children. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

shold say shouldn't*..and sometimes btw people have to tell stories of their "hard times" to make people realize some things are easier said than done...and to me its really not anything knew what I am saying you wouldn't know how many people I have met in my life that had to deal with same stuff if not worse things than I did..and its very common these days sadly 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

Yep. I have no shame in it. And it does sometimes help people realize reality. 

Bahet --- 16 years ago -

LOL Believe me, I well know how situations can change. Hubby was a reservist. We went from a 6 figure income to being on WIC when he was activated. After 14 months like that he came home with no job. He was laid off because there was a risk of him being activated. Then we moved to AZ because there was no work in MI. Hubby got home in early May. We moved across the country, bought another house, had 3 mortgages, 2 houses, and no jobs until the Nov. All our savings was used up. We weren't eligible for any assistance because we had too many assets. Except we were trying to sell the other house but the market was already stagnating in MI. We survived for 14 months on a 75% pay cut then managed another nearly 6 months with only unemployment income. I looked into selling my plasma. I sold half my wardrobe. I kept the AC at 84 (in July in AZ) I used pasta to stretch nearly every meal. I never stole. I never sold drugs and made excuses that I had to feed my kids. I never robbed anyone and tried to justify it. I never broke into someone's home to help pay for our groceries. I never carjacked anyone. My saying they shouldn't have kids may have irked you but justifying theft irks me. If it's ok if she steals shoes is it ok if she steals a car? Hey, maybe there is no public transportation near her. So it's ok right? Not even a little bit. I am a financial advisor. Part of what I do is help people create budgets. I can tell you from experience and research that there are VERY few people in the states who cannot afford a pair of shoes for their child. I'm truly sorry for those of you who were in that situation. It is most definitely not the norm. There are more millionaires in the states than there are people living in true squalor. Most of the people in that situation would just rather spend their money on cigarettes or cable or alcohol and then try to justify that they have to steal because they have no money. It's immoral, illegal, and just plain disgusting. 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

Um ,we are on wic and my husband is a SRA... Your situation doesnt seem like it would even EVER call for any sort of theft if you had a plasma tv; to me it seems like you were doing some major budgeting but still had it better than a lot of people :/ Most of the people in that situation would just rather spend their money on cigarettes or cable or alcohol and then try to justify that they have to steal because they have no money. It's immoral, illegal, and just plain disgusting. This seems really judgmental to me...Although a LOT of them do live this way I wouldnt say most. My Dad was a vietnam vet with PTSD. he couldnt get a job anywhere because of it and we had to live off of his disability...So thats why we had no money. Ever. we didnt waste. We paid rent on our trailer and bought essentials. 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

I never sold drugs and made excuses that I had to feed my kids. I never robbed anyone and tried to justify it. I never broke into someone's home to help pay for our groceries. I never carjacked anyone. We;re talking about stealing a pair of shoes. Not jacking a car :/ 

Bahet --- 16 years ago -

I figured if stealing shoes could be compared to stealing medicine then it could also be compared to stealing a car. So, what is the dollar limit on what would be acceptable theft? $10 Wal Mart shoes are ok but a $5000 car isn't. What about a $150 bike? Oh, and FTR, we've never owned a plasma TV. Not sure where you got that one from. We did budget. That is why we made it through. Most people can do a much better job of budgeting than they do. Ok, so no income for 6 months and 3 mortgages doesn't cut it as poor. What about the situation we very nearly found ourselves in? Hubby is a contractor. His job got converted to GS and they all went spousal preference. Our house is rented out for another year. All of our belongings are here. If something hadn't come through for us we could have been in a position where we were homeless (can't afford these rents with no income), jobless, in Europe, and have to get back to the states on our own dime. We figure it would cost about $25,000 to move us and all our stuff back to the states. Of course, we have no jobs there and no home there either. Would it be ok with you if I stole to get shoes for my son? 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

I looked into selling my plasma I guess you didnt specify... ? 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

Would it be ok with you if I stole to get shoes for my son? If you truly needed to and I could tell, then I would not turn you in if I saw you , no. I guess that makes me a bad citizen. oh well. 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

I figured if stealing shoes could be compared to stealing medicine then it could also be compared to stealing a car. So, what is the dollar limit on what would be acceptable theft? $10 Wal Mart shoes are ok but a $5000 car isn't. What about a $150 bike? these are all totally different situations. Stealing someones vehicle that belongs to them is different. these shoes didn't belong to anyone but walmart. Like I said if I could tell someone really needed it [which you almost always can i would not say anything. That is all. 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

I would do everything in my power to avoid stealing, but if I had to, yes I would.  

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground