Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Husky that killed baby will not be put down

who's talking here?

Mojo 2
paulaaaaaa 1
Fran 6
*Robin* 1
Bob 2
RoxAnne 3
yeah yeah 1
ashml 1
Inge69 1
Nicksdad 1
Euro Maker 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Fran --- 16 years ago -

http://www.bz-berlin.de/aktuell/deutschland/baby-toetung-husky-nicht-eingeschlaefert-article830494.html He passed the character test for dogs, didn´t show any signs of aggression towards people, and the shelter he is currently in will now try to adopt him out to another family, with the approval of the family. 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

ridiculous. 

Nicksdad --- 16 years ago -

There was a segment on German TV the other night that showed that even supposedly friendly dogs could attack a baby - the smell of a dirty diaper is apparently something that can set some dogs off. 

Inge69 --- 16 years ago -

I was just going to post about that. Can't say that I'm surprised. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

this proves that even a dog that doesn't show signs of agression and is trained can attack....i am sorry that the family has to go through a loss of their baby and I hope to god that they do not give that dog to a family that has children. I am surprised that the dog wasn't put down if it killed a human being dispite not showing aggression... 

Fran --- 16 years ago -

Seriously, what´s the point in even making the damn thing take that test? I mean, it´s like doing an "Is he a terror threat?" check on a guy that already blew up a car in the middle of times square... 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Seriously, what´s the point in even making the damn thing take that test? I mean, it´s like doing an "Is he a terror threat?" check on a guy that already blew up a car in the middle of times square... That is not even a reasonable comparison. Blowing up a car is a deliberate act of violence. You have no idea what that dog was thinking. Yes, it was violent, and it caused the death of a baby. But, was the dog intending to be vicious? Not necessarily. There could have been any number of triggers that made the dog do what it did. That dog may not even know that what it did was vicious. I am not some animal rights activist, but I am not so quick to point a finger, either. If a kid gets caught cheating on a test in 3rd grade, should he be labeled a cheater for life? If a kid throws a rock at another kid's head and knocks him unconscious, should that kid be labeled a threat for the rest of his life? Sometimes, accidents happen. Even if, as humans, we perceive the act as vicious, it may not have been. Unless you can get into the mind of that dog, you just don't know. We're never going to know the entire story. The family of the dead child will tell the story one way, the media will tell it another. I do agree that the dog should not be given to a family with kids. Not because the dog is vicious, but on the side of caution it is best to avoid another possible accident. 

RoxAnne --- 16 years ago -

Joftaa, would you feel the same if it was a "pitbull" breed? 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Joftaa, would you feel the same if it was a "pitbull" breed? Absolutely. Pitbulls get a very bad wrap because people do stupid things. In Miami Pitbulls are not even legal to own. Why? IGNORANCE! 100% IGNORANCE! I personally know three pitbulls that would lick you to death before even thinking about biting. It is all in the upbringing. Raise the dog to be vicious, and guess what! It will be vicious. Pitbulls can be the biggest babies. Same with Rottweilers. I can raise a poodle to be just as vicious as a pitbull that is raised to be vicious. When people start to figure out that dogs behave as they are trained, and stop blaming poorly behaved dogs for behaving the way they are taught to behave, we'll have better behaved dogs. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Joftaa, would you feel the same if it was a "pitbull" breed? Absolutely. Pitbulls get a very bad wrap because people do stupid things. In Miami Pitbulls are not even legal to own. Why? IGNORANCE! 100% IGNORANCE! I personally know three pitbulls that would lick you to death before even thinking about biting. It is all in the upbringing. Raise the dog to be vicious, and guess what! It will be vicious. Pitbulls can be the biggest babies. Same with Rottweilers. I can raise a poodle to be just as vicious as a pitbull that is raised to be vicious. When people start to figure out that dogs behave as they are trained, and stop blaming poorly behaved dogs for behaving the way they are taught to behave, we'll have better behaved dogs. 

RoxAnne --- 16 years ago -

Thanks for answering Joftaa, I was just wondering. Don't get me started on BSL (Breed Specific Legislation). I just did a bunch of research on it for a speech. 

Fran --- 16 years ago -

JOFTAA, you didn´t get my point. A dog that has killed a baby has proved that it is unpredictable, the test is there to be able to predict a dog´s future behaviour. I don´t think the intention of the dog should be more of a factor than the end result of his action, which is a dead baby. I can raise a poodle to be just as vicious as a pitbull that is raised to be vicious. I don´t doubt that, but what would YOU say is the kind of breed people raise for dog fighting? And why? Pittbulls, because pittbulls are known to lick their opponents to death? Every vet will tell you certain breeds have certain tendencies. Statistics are there for a reason. Sure, I know friendly Rottweilers too, but they are also guard dogs for a reason. 

Fran --- 16 years ago -

From this link, and I could provide you a gazillion other like it. http://www.edgarsnyder.com/dog-bite/statistics.html Some sources claim that the six types of dogs commonly identified as the most dangerous or vicious dog breeds are Akitas, Chow-Chows, Doberman Pinschers, Pit Bulls, Rottweilers, and Wolf-Dog Hybrids. Another study looked at a selection of 88 dog attacks from 2006-2008 in the United States, with results ranging from recoverable injuries to death. Of those incidents, it was found that: * Pit Bulls, Rottweilers, and American Bulldogs were responsible for 77% of all deaths. * Pit Bulls were responsible for 59% of all deaths. * Pit Bulls killed more adults than children. 

*Robin* --- 16 years ago -

all i have to say about the whole thing is this no matter what happens to this dog, someone will be unhappy. PETA members would be pissed if it would be put down, angry mamas and papas all over the place will be angry if it is NOT put down. No one wins............ I am slowly learning to not freak out over things that do not directly affect me. "You say you wanna revolution, well you know, we all wanna change the world"!! 

Fran --- 16 years ago -

Apparently, especially to PETA, animals tend to have more rights than humans. If a human kills another human, it will face consequences. Also, I do agree it´s the parents´fault and that not all pitbulls are vicious, I just think that it´s nonsense to deny the fact that certain dogs were bred to fight. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

it´s nonsense to deny the fact that certain dogs were bred to fight. Let me rephrase that for a little more accuracy, if you don't mind. It's nonsense to deny the fact that certain dogs are better suited to be bred to fight. The same dog that is bred to fight, knew nothing about fighting at birth. The dog's training could go either way. So, just because a dog is better suited to be bred to fight does not mean that it will be bred to fight. That is why legislation on breeds is something I do not agree with. If you want to pass useful legislation, stop allowing dogs to be taught to fight. Being from a place of many cultures (Miami), I see it all. If the dogs are not fighting, it is the chickens. What are we going to do next? Ban chickens? Note: The following is said tongue in cheek. Sort of. If we were to ban chickens, it might do us all some good. AAFES would be forced to put something else in place of Popeye's Fried Crap. Note to readers: No animals were harmed in the writing of this post. 

Bob --- 16 years ago -

fran, you make a good point about what is publicized about pit bulls BUT. the breeds you mentioned, when bred properly, are not any worse than other breeds. the blame still has to be placed on the people who breed the animal and the novice owners who don't know how to raise the dog properly. the breeds you mentioned have all been tainted by bad breeding. even though the breeder is negligent the purchaser is also negligent because he/she doesn't research the breeder well enough. if you get away from the sites that like to highlight what man's stupidity is doing to these breeds you will find out that a well bred, well raised member of any of these breeds is a well balanced, loving animal. in fact, many sites i've visited stated that dobermans are one of the best family dogs you can get. it seems you only visit the sites that emphasize the negative aspects of poorly bred and poorly raised dogs. while i agree that what happened is a horrible thing not all of the blame can be put on the dog. the parent(s) who left this young child alone with the dog should be held responsible as well. just the size of the dog should be enough for parents to know this. if anything at all startled the dog it could knock the stroller over and harm the child. i guess i simply don't understand parents that will leave children that young alone at any time, except when they are sleeping at night. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Bob - I agree 100%. Well said. I also agree with JOFTAA, but I may be biased just a little bit. 

yeah yeah --- 16 years ago -

Okay, maybe its a dominate issue? I had a pug that was dominate towards my english bulldog, (both males) We got a female bulldog puppy. The usually very loving bulldog started attacking the pug. Obviously, we we concerned with this, we have kids and what happened if they were cought in the middle?? Anyways...as they get older,what came down to it, anyone smaller than them or eye level, they will try to have dominance over them which could of happened. Its the wild pack theory, one alpha to rule them all. A fight to be on top. Just a guess....all animals have the "animal instinct" in them to survive. I am in NO WAY condoning the attack...just a theory...and what I learned 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Here is a similar story. We got a kitten. Six months later we got a Yorkie. The kitten was at least three times bigger than the Yorkie. The kitten would attack the puppy. I mean vicious, fangs in the neck, attack. We could not leave the two alone together because the kitten would absolutely have killed the puppy. Now, three years later, the cat cries at the door until the dog comes back home when I take the dog for a walk. The two cannot be separated. The cat actually cleans the dog, head to toe, twice a day. Funny how this kind of thing happens. 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

Fran, you won't find accurate statistics on dog bites by breeds anymore for quite a few reasons: 1) Most people look at certain dogs as dangerous, and others as friendly breeds, and while both may/will bite, only the dangerous one gets reported because of the bias. 2) People often can't correctly identify the type of dog that bit them, and incorrectly identify them as one of the known "Dangerous" breeds. 3) The CDC and Veterinarian's Association both agree that it's better to focus on educating people about dogs overall, instead of focusing on specific breeds. Any link that tries to give dog bite statistics by breed is using very old data, or incorrect anecdotal evidence, not true numbers that correlate to anything used today. Certain dogs were not "Bred to fight", certain dogs have a specific look or set of traits that people who fight look for, and they are the ones who are trained to fight. It really frustrates me when I see those kinds of statements, too. It's fearmongering and it's the same as blaming guns for killing people, and not the people holding the gun. 

RoxAnne --- 16 years ago -

I think everyone should check this out I think it is pretty interesting!! Can You Guess the Breed!? 

Fran --- 16 years ago -

Marissa, when it comes to fatal dog attacks, I´m very certain there is a vet determining the breed of the dog, so I wouldn´t necessarily doubt all statistics. Certain dogs were not "Bred to fight", certain dogs have a specific look or set of traits that people who fight look for, and they are the ones who are trained to fight. I disagree. Even if some "already had" some specific features, people tried to even enforce them some more. This goes for other breeds as well, not just "fighting dogs". Do you really think mother nature would have created a sausage on legs (certain hunting dogs), I don´t think so, but they had to be able to crawl into that rabbit tunnel.... Just think of the name. PIT BULL. Says it all. 

Bob --- 16 years ago -

fran: you have a typical closed minded view of a very loving type of dog. what would you say about an american staffordshire terrier? here's a few sites you should check out: http://www.pbrc.net/breedinfo.html http://localrescue.org/pitbulls.htm http://www.apbtconformation.com/ukcstandard.htm http://www.pitbullsontheweb.com/petbull/breedinfo.html the key to a sound pit bull is like any other breed and it is stressed on the last site referenced: responsible ownership. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

http://www.dontbullymybreed.org/ http://www.thriftyfun.com/tf268481.tip.html http://www.dontbullymybreed.org/StopCourtRuling.php 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

Fran, you're pretty certain about this information and it seems there is no way to sway you. I'll just say this: Opinions and ideas like yours are what fosters and furthers the ideas about "Dangerous breeds", and keeps the focus on the dogs instead of the owners. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground