Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Here's a fun debate topic for you

who's talking here?

M'lissa 8
Desire 1
Mojo 3
Carl 1
Fran 1
just a girl 1
GaryKenyon 6
Tessie 4
Rie Rie 2
Bob 1
Liv813 3
WitnessProtectionProgram 2
ashml 2
Melinda 1
DakotaCowgirl 1
doddlebug 2
Girl from the south 1
MissBlitz 1
jess.d 1
Barry 6
Blueser oO 1
MAD4EUROPE 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

I'll ask this, and clarify two topics prior to posting.

Should congress repeal Don't Ask, Don't Tell?

Keep in mind two things that will get you laughed at if you use it as an argument:

1) There will be no uniform changes or concessions for those flamboyant guys (ZOMG PASTEL UNIFORMS)

2) There will still be a requirement for proper decorum when at work, meaning THE GAYS aren't going to run around holding hands and slapping each others arses.

Annnnnnnddddddd GO. 

Carl --- 16 years ago -

Hmmmmmmmmmmmm!! Not a very fun debate. 

Liv813 --- 16 years ago -

My husband and I disagree. (he's military) He believes that it would be too dangerous for the homosexuals. I feel like we're all adults and should respect each others personal decisions....also, I feel like it's no one's business. Yes, I sound naive or better yet -- too faithful in humankind.

And no, we're not homophobic. 

Girl from the south --- 16 years ago -

I see BIG issues with some of the foreign bases....for instance, when my hubby was down range there was absolutely NO contact between males and females who were not married. At no time was a male allowed to even darken the door of a female's room, and vice-versa. It was a rule set because of the customs and views of the host nation. If we allow homosexual individuals to serve openly, I can see rules being made where everyone has a private room and you have no admission into anyone else's room. Can you imagine what it would take to house everyone in an individual room???
I see serious diplomatic issues ahead.
Call me whatever you want....I just think it's wrong and has no place in the military. 

Liv813 --- 16 years ago -

Yea, I see your point MommaG. I just re-read my comment and it's pretty vague. There are many things to consider here. 

M'lissa --- 16 years ago -

My husband and I disagree. (he's military) He believes that it would be too dangerous for the homosexuals. I feel like we're all adults and should respect each others personal decisions....also, I feel like it's no one's business. Yes, I sound naive or better yet -- too faithful in humankind.

You do know that there are already gay people in the military, right? And most people can point out which people are.

I don't think the flaming gays everyone seems to think of when they think of homosexuals would join the military. 

M'lissa --- 16 years ago -

I'm sorry I misread your comment I thought you both agreed it would be dangerous. I agree with you that it is no one's business and they should respect their personal decision. 

Liv813 --- 16 years ago -

I've met a "flaming" gay man in the military before and yes, everyone knew. I can't speak for my husband, but I think he worries that if it were allowed for everyone to be open and honest -- that a lot of guys (and girls, I'm sure) would feel more threatened. Make sense? It's so tough to explain yourself over the internet. That is why I rarely participate in these debates 

M'lissa --- 16 years ago -

I understand where he's coming from. I think we have come a lot further than that as far as acceptance of things though. I'm sure there are some homophobics in the military but I doubt they'd ever be alone with them to hurt them or want to ruin their career by doing that. I'm sure there are racist and sexist people in the military too. If anyone should be stopped from joining the military it should be them.

I know of many openly gay lesbians. There is 1 couple I knew of that everyone knew they were dating in the workplace and no one said anything to them. 

Tessie --- 16 years ago -

I don't care about people's sexual orientation I only care about if they can do their job...this should be the only concern. 

MAD4EUROPE --- 16 years ago -

Tessie, I agree with you. i think too many people are TOO concerned with people's sex/personal/dating lives. There are way too many problems that we need to straighten out before worrying about someone's sexual orientation. What about children going hungry? AIDS? Poverty? Lack of education in the free world? Lack of WATER? Racism? Sexism? Sorry for the rant... 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

Its not about letting gays in the military or having to worry about them molesting people afterwards. Its all about being kicked out of the military because you are gay. Even being caught with homosexual porn with NO partner can get you in trouble. You don't even have to act on the issue.

If its dangerous for gays to be in the military its only because of everyone else who doesn't like gay people. Its all about everyone elses comfort issue NOT the gay person's. I find it highly amazing that its way more dangerous for straight people to be in the military. Rapes, molestation... Granted it could be a ratio issue but still. People could blame it on the womens fault, that it happens because they let women in the military.

Off topic yet not:

My husbands aunt is a lesbian who is married to a women. Recently when we went back home, my husbands immediate family (sister and mom) made comments about how "Walt Disney would be rolling over in his grave if he could see what happens at disney land now". I put up my hands and wiggled them saying "OMG the gays! Boo-ga boo-ga!" Long story short, my husbands aunt finally felt like if I could stand up to that side of the family about the gay issue, why shouldn't she call her wife "honey" around them or hold her hand around them? So she did for the first time in 20 years. It broke my heart thinking about how it would feel like I shouldn't hold my husband's hand or show any affection because of my own family's disgust about who I am and who I love.

BTW, I watch the Real L Word...awesome show! 

DakotaCowgirl --- 16 years ago -

I'm mixed on this one. I don't care for the most part, as long as they do their job.

I think it comes to play with safety right now. People aren't mature and there are still hate crimes. I could see it here easily. Everything is so hush hush now.

I also see if this is opened, they will be restructuring how BAH and BAS works. Especially if gay marriage is allowed now. Because that will open up for more $$ to either go in for gay couples or they will be discontinuing the dependant rates and just doing single.

This isn't as cut and dry as we think. There are many variables in this equation.

Sorry for the typos. I'm tired and at the wrong computer for catching them that quickly. 

Tessie --- 16 years ago -

How is this not cut and dry? Who people get hitched too is none of my concern. Not only that but the same thing was probably said about allowing black people in the military and then other minorities. This is silly we can expect attitudes about this to change unless big steps are taken. Racism still exists I lived on a military base as a child and there was a man down the street they made it known he hated black people. Should we have kept black people out because of that?

No there is no actual reason that change should not be occurring on this front...just excuses 

M'lissa --- 16 years ago -

What would be so wrong with money going to gay couples? 

MAD4EUROPE --- 16 years ago -

Very funny, very true! 

Barry --- 16 years ago -

Great arguments, I would also like to add this: How would random urinalysis observers work? Would a gay man be allowed to observe a straight man peeing in a cup? That is the same thing as having a straight guy watching a straight girl pee in a cup.

I do believe that every American should have the right to serve their country. However the American Military IS NOT an Equal Opportunity Employer!!! If you are fat, too skinny, severe health problems, handicapped, Mentally Challenged, etc you can not join the Military. HOWEVER you can serve in some civilian role. The gays could be in a civilian position if they want to serve their country so bad. 

doddlebug --- 16 years ago -

I believe if someone wants to join the military and make the commitment and sacrifice it involves, then they should be applauded regardless of gender, race, religion, sexual orientation etc...
I would imagine if you are homosexual you have thought long and hard about making this commitment and all that it involves, these people will face prejudice and ignorance, so it would take a pretty dedicated and strong individual to join regardless....whom I would think would make a more committed solider than some guy/girl who signed as an easy way out.
I am sure most people will see a few soldiers who seem obvious but for everyone there are ten dedicated, hardworking individuals who handle the issues with integrity and poise.
If they pledge allegiance, are willing to sacrifice their lives and want to serve i'd be proud to serve alongside.

My opinion is that Tessie above is right, we need to move forwards to make progress.... 

M'lissa --- 16 years ago -

lol it cracks me up when people call them 'the gays'. IDK why. 

GaryKenyon --- 16 years ago -

Just because someone is gay does not mean that they want to f*ck you.

Are we really no better than Iran, Saudi Arabia and China?

0

Blue = Gays allowed to serve openly

Red = Gays not allowed ot serve at all

Yellow = DATD

Gray = No data available 

GaryKenyon --- 16 years ago -

Barry, being gay is not the same as being too fat, or handicapped.

If they can do the same thing you do at work with out any problem why should they be barred from service? 

Barry --- 16 years ago -

lol it cracks me up when people call them 'the gays'. IDK why.

Oh, that is an easy one. Gays are a group of people. When someone is speaking about a certain group, they will say, "The (fill in the blank) are...". 

Tessie --- 16 years ago -

What Barry just said was super special. In no way when I was peeing in a cup was I worried about the person watching me thinking my squatting and aiming in a little cup was hot.

There are REASONS for people who are overweight or underweight not being allowed in the military...health issues. What health issues does being gay present to those around them?

There are other things to be concerned about and really last thing I worried about was who someone on my flight was attracted too during training I worried if they couldn't fire the damn weapons we were firing at the time. 

Barry --- 16 years ago -

Gary,

Due to our current standards, a male can be kicked out of the Air Force for having a 40.5 inch waist. Even is he is really tall! They can still do the same thing other people that pass their PT test can do, but after a few failed attempts, they will be discharged.

They can still do everything, but will be barred from service. Life isn't fair. Like wise, the Military isn't fair. That is why. 

GaryKenyon --- 16 years ago -

You fail Barry, he is kicked out of the military because his waist is too big. He did not meet a standard.

If a homosexual person can meet all the standards required of military service why can they not serve openly? 

M'lissa --- 16 years ago -

Just because someone is gay does not mean that they want to f*ck you.

Totally agree with you. 

Barry --- 16 years ago -

Tessie, I'm not saying that is the biggest reason, I was adding an argument to the great list of arguments already mentioned. You would think that nothing would happen in the bathroom, but there are a lot of stuff that happens that you don't think would happen. For example a General in JAG with all the sexual assaults against women in his command. The pimping scandal in the 45th Security Forces Sq at Patrick AFB. Male USAF recruiters telling female recruits he had to personally do breast exams.

ALSO, I didn't say there were any health issues by being Gay. 

GaryKenyon --- 16 years ago -

I never brought up health issues with being gay Barry. Pull your head out of your @ss.

I asked you if a gay person can meet all the standards of being in the military why can they not serve openly? 

Barry --- 16 years ago -

Gary...Right! He failed to meet the standards set forth to protect the Good order and Discipline of the military! That argument fits too. 

GaryKenyon --- 16 years ago -

And how is being gay prejudicial to good order and discipline? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground