Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Can Anyone Smell The B.S. from AAFES?

who's talking here?

Bahet 2
Cheeky Monkey 3
Euro Maker 5
Abe 2
Blueser oO 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

“The Tillman Story,” a documentary exploring the U.S. government’s coverup after the death of former NFL football player Pat Tillman, will not be shown at Reel Time Theaters, Army and Air Force Exchange Service officials said Tuesday.

The film, which had a limited release on Aug. 20, opens to a wider audience on Friday.

But, troops serving in places such as Afghanistan, where the former Army ranger was killed by friendly fire April 22, 2004, won’t get a chance to see it.

AAFES is not shying away from the film because it paints the U.S. government and the Defense Department in a bad light, according to Judd Anstey, an AAFES spokesman. It’s not showing the film because exchange officials feel it would not appeal to a large audience of viewers.

“During the first week, the Tillman documentary was only featured at four U.S. theaters in the continental U.S., while “The Expendables” was shown at 3,270 theaters,” Anstey said. “Based on this fact, AAFES decides which movies are to be played based on which movies will appeal to the largest audience possible.”

“The Expendables” — a Sylvester Stallone action movie — appealed to the larger audience, he said.

Anstey noted that things like trade reviews, distributor availability and customer appeal were all factors in how AAFES decides which films to carry. Movies scheduled for limited release or rollouts by independent distributors are not considered, Anstey said.

On average, one film is selected a week and is offered in theaters beginning two weeks after the U.S. commercial release date. The movie is then circulated in Reel Time Theaters in Germany, Italy, England, Kuwait, Iraq, Korea and Japan, he said.

It’s not the first time AAFES has decided not to carry controversial films.

In 2004, the exchange did not show Michael Moore’s “Fahrenheit 9/11,” which lambasted former President George W. Bush and his administration for their policies after the Sept. 11, 2001, terror attacks.

Nor did it show “Brokeback Mountain” the 2006 movie about a gay cowboy love affair.

Smells like bullshizzle to me.

SOURCE

Copied from here, after the source. 

Blueser oO --- 16 years ago -

:o bastards! 

Cheeky Monkey --- 16 years ago -

It's gets better...today's Stars and Stripes...

Stores located on Army and Air Force bases will no longer be allowed to sell Electronic Arts’ upcoming military shooter "Medal of Honor" because an aspect of the game includes playable Taliban characters. The ban applies to on-post GameStop stores and exchanges worldwide. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Censorship at its best!

Do they really think that they are stopping people from buying the game? We'll just have to buy it cheaper from The Net, instead.

Another reason why I try like hell not to support AAFES.

Here is a link to the story if anyone wants to read it.

http://www.kotaku.com.au/2010/09/video-game-pulled-globally-from-military-stores-over-taliban-inclusion/

Or, from Stripes.
http://www.stripes.com/#top-story-tabs-1 

Bahet --- 16 years ago -

So our troops fight to keep freedom and in return the military (AAFES, AFN, etc) censors everything. *cough*hypocrites*cough* 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

So our troops fight to keep freedom and in return the military (AAFES, AFN, etc) censors everything.

That sums it up nicely. 

Abe --- 16 years ago -

Wait, wait, wait..."censorship?" Really? Maybe AFN you have a case, but even then, the government is NOT banning the release of these items, these entities "quasi-government" entangled entities are not showing it.

A person could make a case that since every book written by Al Gore or every crappy movie made by the at fat dude Michael Moore is not put in a prominent position in the store is censorship, but really?

Your access to these things is certainly available elsewhere.

Trust me I AM NOT the defender of AAFES I rarely EVER shop there, but to throw that term around devalues its meaning when it really needs to be used. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

What word would you use, Abe?

There is a game.

The game has what is considered objectionable to AAFES

AAFES will not sell it to us

Just because AAFES cannot keep us from buying it elsewhere does not mean that AAFES is not censoring it themselves.

In your example of Gore and Moore the books may not have been in a prominent place, but they were available.

In the case of this video game, not only is it not in a prominent place, but it is also not available at all.

Not trying to pick an argument here, but I am wondering what it would be called if not censorship? 

Cheeky Monkey --- 16 years ago -

Ahhh...we the sheeple.... 

Abe --- 16 years ago -

Censorship is something that is done by the government to quell anything they choose ala the idiot in Venezuela. In other words it is available NOWHERE.

These items are available elsewhere so that is not censorship. If AAFES was forced to play movies no one watches we would never get ones we actually want.

Maybe it is just a difference in definition but I would call it selective marketing.

Using your logic the Commissary is censoring all kinds of products I wish they would carry.

I do however agree with the video argument anyway having lost 16 of my boys 06-07 rotation!! 

Cheeky Monkey --- 16 years ago -

Umm...let's see...the Stars and Stripes will not print an article which may be detrimental to the army however it's front page news in the NY Times. It's available if you look around...is that not censorship? And besides, if you want something the commissary doesn't carry, you can special order and they will fill it. AAFES will NOT fill an order for the game.... 

Bahet --- 16 years ago -

If the commissary doesn't sell sushi because there is no demand for it that's one thing. If they don't sell it because of political reasons regardless of the demand for it then it's censorship. In the case of the video game, movies, etc it is most definitely censorship. People in China can buy a Bible online but their government won't allow stores to sell them. I don't think anyone would even question whether or not that's censorship. This is the same thing with the only difference being that the government is not censoring it from private businesses only from government controlled enterprises. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Censorship does not have to be worldwide, or even statewide to be censorship. For that matter, it can be very isolated.

A principal of a school who will not allow a book in the school that he/she feels is controversial is censorship by the principal. Just because the book is available elsewhere does not mean the principal is not censoring. The principal is clearly censoring.

AAFES is clearly censoring by not allowing the game. AAFES even stated that they are not allowing it because of the ability to play the game as a Taliban member. It is very clearly censorship.

This is hardly worth arguing over. If you think that AAFES is not censoring, then feel free to think that. We'll just agree to disagree. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground