Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Girl Throwing puppies update

who's talking here?

M'lissa 2
ashml 4
Melinda 3
doddlebug 4
MissBlitz 1
Euro Maker 2
jasmine06 1
Blueser oO 3
daisy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Melinda --- 16 years ago -

5 of the 6 puppies were saved! HOORAY!

I'd copy and paste the article but it's mostly pictures. GOOD PUPPY!!

And the girl who threw them was found by Bosnian authorities.

it's a very short article. "Bosnian police say they've identified the teen filmed throwing puppies in a river. (She now faces a $6,400 fine for animal cruelty.)" Bad Girl!


Just thought you guys might be interested. 

Blueser oO --- 16 years ago -

That is false actually.

The puppies don't look the same, and there is no way they all washed to shore on the same spot and were still alive being only 3 days old. 

daisy --- 16 years ago -

..apparently Granny rescued the puppies..i don't think so...i can smell a rat here...the puppies don't even look the same,i just hope the girl gets punished that fits the crime. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

well did they ever mention when she did it what kind of dogs they where? Just like children, dogs even a week old can take on differant colors and differant looks....I don't remember what color they where so who knows? I don't think they where saved either but maybe?!! 

doddlebug --- 16 years ago -

Well heres being hopeful. Sadly my mind is thinking they have made this story as a cover to protect the girl from being tracked down and attacked by all the angry people out there.
BUT i do hope the dogs did survive and I do hope they get homes that will look after them after such a sad start to life. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

yeah there is always that hope!! poor things, I think they tried to save her butt with the dogs being sick story but lawd knows they are probably lying 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

And, the story from the girl is that the dogs were sick. If the dogs are sick, why would they be up for adoption? 

jasmine06 --- 16 years ago -

If the dogs were sick, that's an excuse to video tape someone throwing them in a river?? I'm sure they could have been brought to a shelter where they would have gotten medical help. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

If the dogs were sick, that's an excuse to video tape someone throwing them in a river?? I'm sure they could have been brought to a shelter where they would have gotten medical help.

I did not mean to imply that the pups should have been tossed. I was pointing out a discrepancy in the stories. One story said the girl admitted throwing the pups in the river because her grandmother told her they were sick and she did not know what do to. The next story says the pups were saved and up for adoption.

I am stating that if the original story were true, that if the dogs were really rescued, they would still be sick. Sick pups would not be put up for adoption like the second story states. 

doddlebug --- 16 years ago -

 

doddlebug --- 16 years ago -

never mind :) 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

well laws are laws, there are easier ways to put dogs down without suffering. Trust me we've had to put a kitten down because he fell off the porch and the way he landed broke his neck, he couldn't do anything and we lived 2 hours away from a vet so thankfully my MIL and mom where vet techs and my MIL had the drugs on her to put the animal to sleep (not dead sleep like asleep to put stitches and surgeries etc) and yeah....but still after that fact she was smiling and video taping....if they live in "rural" area where they can get a video tape they have to have a vet LOL plus there is atleast one vet somewhere. How do you think they take care of farm animals? Oh lets spend hundreds of dollars on farm animals and then when they get sick kill them...nope not how farmers etc think they try to save their "money"..but doodlebug I can see your point 

Blueser oO --- 16 years ago -

Doddlebug had a good point :P
Which was supported by the article I linked above:
Vujadinovic said locals were protective of the girl and did not understand the media attention because they live in a region where stray cats and dogs are regularly killed. "On many internet pages you find lot of comments like, 'what is all that fuss about a few dogs?'," Vujadinovic said.

People eat dogs and cats in China, because in that area it is a normal thing. Really when you think about it, pigs aren't much different than dogs/cats. Some people have pet pigs and claim they are very intelligent. So one could arguably claim that eating pigs is so horrific and disgusting as if it were dogs/cats. It is all about cultural norms. I don't like seeing any animals suffering, so I chose not to eat any of them, but in our culture pigs make the cut!

If the pups were sick and going to die (not many people in a poor town will/can pay for medical care for 6 unwanted puppies), dying in the river may have been less horrific than other ways the girl may have done it. They either drowned quickly or were knocked out on the rocks from the swift current. I am in no way supporting the murderer, I would like one on one time with the little slu*t, just trying to rationalize it in my mind as a coping mechanism.

I also don't think the 'pups being saved' story would save the girl any heat. She didn't have anything to do with saving them except placing them in the situation they would eventually be saved from. So I don't understand why everyone says it is to make people less angry at her. If someone attempts to kill a person, but is stopped by a passerby, that attempted murder isn't dismissed or looked at in a lighter manner. I personally think someone will be crazy enough to try and hurt her after that stunt, no damage control can reverse what millions of people saw. :( 

M'lissa --- 16 years ago -

People eat dogs and cats in China, because in that area it is a normal thing. Really when you think about it, pigs aren't much different than dogs/cats. Some people have pet pigs and claim they are very intelligent. So one could arguably claim that eating pigs is so horrific and disgusting as if it were dogs/cats. It is all about cultural norms. I don't like seeing any animals suffering, so I chose not to eat any of them, but in our culture pigs make the cut!

That's exactly what I think! Why is it ok to slaughter cows, pigs, chickens, etc but it's cruel to adopt dogs out to different owners and/or put to sleep in shelters when no one adopts them. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

too true too true, everyone makes a valid point! :P I think all animals should have the respect of being treated well, despite if their main purpose to some of them is to get killed and eaten, my whole thing I had an issue with is her video taping it and smiling about it...that made me sick..if she TRUELY was trying to get rid of sick dogs she wouldn't have had video taped plain and simple.... 

doddlebug --- 16 years ago -

see everyone is valid there, and thats why I deleted it. I didn't want to cause controversy or seem like I am condoning it. I am not, it was cruel.
BUT yes its a matter of where you are and what your cultural norm is. Horse meat for instance, I hate the thought of eating it...but why when I happily eat beef and pigs and calves and lamb? isn't it all to do with where you are?
Farm animals are a valuable commodity and probably would be seen by a vet, puppies and kittens probably are a nuisance rather than a commodity there, and are often seen as disease ridden or unnecessary.
BUT i do agree see showed a degree of pleasure and a complete lack or remorse and it's a crying shame. 

MissBlitz --- 16 years ago -

Ok, people do NOT eat dogs and cats in China. I'm Chinese-American, I've been to China and never have I seen dogs or cats on any menu. I've never met ANY Chinese person who thought of dogs and cats as food, so it's just totally ignorant for people to say stuff like that.

Anyway, back to the story: even if the killing of stray animals is prevalent and normal in Bosnia, that girl took it to another level. She obviously took pleasure in hurting the puppies, so she definitely did not put them out of their misery. And I don't think Bosnian people are stupid enough to think that drowning animals is a humane way to kill them. I read that her punishment is just 5,000 Euro, because she's a minor, and Bosnia has a terrible criminal justice system. I just hope that she comes from a very poor family that they'll struggle to pay that fine, so she'll learn her lesson. 

Melinda --- 16 years ago -

Human consumption of dog meat has been recorded in many parts of the world including China, ancient Mexico, and ancient Rome.[2] Dog meat is currently consumed in a variety of countries such as China, Vietnam, the Philippines, and Korea. Link

also in that it states that China is just now pushing legislation to outlaw the consumption of dog meat. So it's not ignorant to say that. 

Melinda --- 16 years ago -

Oh and I didn't think that the original link i posted about the saved dogs was false. I never confirmed it i just assumed. Live and learn. I wouldn't have caught it because i didn't watch the puppy throwing video long enough or often enough to remember what the pups looked like. 

Blueser oO --- 16 years ago -

Thank you Melinda, and here is another link about it also mentioning the legislation to outlaw it.

Will you deny this happens as well?

I have family from China, I'm not picking on that country. These are facts with supporting pictures and videos. CNN is not one to make up false stories. There is no need to get offended, its a cultural thing. Like I said before, people in the states eat other animals that don't differ much from cats and dogs. And I'm sure this is not every place in China. 

M'lissa --- 16 years ago -

I just hope that she comes from a very poor family that they'll struggle to pay that fine, so she'll learn her lesson.

So you hope her family suffers and struggles to pay, how will that teach HER a lesson? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground