I am not sure what your point is. Beck asked that people not bring signs ect... What 500,000+ people do themselves I don't think is indicative of what the "whole" was about. Did you watch it?
BTW, where you aware the the rally raised 5.5 million plus for the Special Operations Warrior Foundation? And none of the rally was paid for by fox or any large corporations? To include political parties. Oh and no us tax payers had to foot this one either. So if a group of people wanted to get together to show solidarity with there opinions about how they feel our country is being driven away from Faith, Hope and Charity, the key things that built our country to begin with, why do progressives have such heartburn with this?
FTR, the US was built on the principles of religious freedom, including separation of church and state. We weren't built on any principles of any particular faith, simply the freedom to practice any faith one saw fit.
By your post and your comment in the "fox" post I am pretty sure where you lean. And that is fine, you have that right. I was just curious what your point is? Obviously this is a sore point in our lives right now, so what are you trying to do? Do you think it a great idea to bring this up? Especially with military families?
When I think of Faith, Hope, and Charity, I don't necessarily feel it needs to be done in a church. I think it is something we need to feel in ourselves, that we care about others... That is how I see it. And I agree Marissa!
I don't know which direction you think I lean in. I lean in the direction that doesn't believe in being uneducated and regurgitating bullet points from Fox, Limbaugh, and Beck.
I lean in the direction that likes to think about what is happening and make a decision based on being educated and not just vomiting what I am told by a media outlet that wants to divide.
I lean toward being smart enough not to say something stupid such as "I have lost my rights." I cannot think of a single right that I have lost. When I hear people saying they have lost their rights, and then asked which rights they have lost, they cannot answer. Why do they think they lost their rights? Because they were told so. People will believe just about anything they are told blindly. I am not saying this is true for everyone, but it is true for the people in the video. Just watch it.
It scares me that these people can be led so easily.
Oh, I forgot to ask before. What does 500,000 people that cannot follow Beck's instructions have to do with this?
In the past, when I posted jokes with disclaimers and warnings, people told me that I was purposely looking for a response by doing that. What do you think Beck was doing by telling people not to bring signs? It worked.
I find it interesting that when people here post things that "like minded" people can rally around, it is fine. But, try to have an intelligent conversation about current events with people that may not be so "like minded" and you'd better watch out.
BTW, where you aware the the rally raised 5.5 million plus for the Special Operations Warrior Foundation? And none of the rally was paid for by fox or any large corporations?
Another answer that avoids the original question. What does money raised, or how the event was paid for, have anything to do with this being a political rally or not? The question at hand is if this was a political rally or not based on the information presented at the website linked to?
So far, I see the question being dodged, and no answer.
Lol! I am still not sure what your point is. I am not talking about the people interviewed in your other post. Out of the amount of people that showed for the rally there is bound to be people that don't understand totally what is going on, but understand what IS happening is wrong. If you are as educated as you sometimes seem to be then I am sure you are aware of what is going on. I will not get into a debate with you regarding my beliefs. But just so you know, I am a military wife, have been for 20 years, educated, read at least 6 different news pages a day (from BOTH sides to include The Huffington Post and The Blaze) not to mention the news I watch on tv from Sky to AFN. I have a very good understanding of what is going on, (I do not take everything at face value but look more into issues if it catches my attention) and I will tell you, I WILL be voting in November, I am sure with the LARGE amount of military families that were at the rally on 8-28. But what I am curious STILL about, is why have you brought this up?
Obviously this is a sore point in our lives right now, so what are you trying to do? Do you think it a great idea to bring this up? Especially with military families?
Is it a great idea to bring it up? Would it be best to just keep our heads in the sand? This is all around us. It is current events. Should I not discuss current events because some people may not agree?
Being a military family does not justify not discussing current events. If anything, you should have more insightful information. At least that is what I thought. I was hoping to hear informed, enlightening responses.
See the problem with that JOFTAA is, because we are military, we are more bound by restrictions then others. We must be more careful with what we say in a public areana. But you would already know this, wouldn't you? (Not meant with attitude)
Oh and JOFTAA, normally I would not enter into a political discussion at all, but for some reason, this bothered me. It seems that a lot of people have been real quick to point out any negative aspects of the rally as opposed to the inspiring moments. (There where a lot) I wonder why that is?
Honestly, I did not know you were having to censor yourselves because you are in the military. If anything, I would think that since you are fighting for freedom, that you would be allowed to have the very thing you fight for.
Are you saying that you have to censor yourself? Are you saying that if you don't say what you are expected to say that you can get into trouble? Are you saying that having an opposing opinion and expressing it is a bad thing?
I want to clarify, just to be sure I understand. This is not meant to be sarcastic or condescending in any manner. I have not been here nearly long enough to know all of the ropes that military families must comply with.
Oh and JOFTAA, normally I would not enter into a political discussion at all, but for some reason, this bothered me. It seems that a lot of people have been real quick to point out any negative aspects of the rally as opposed to the inspiring moments. (There where a lot) I wonder why that is?
I think we both know that answer. It is because rather than everyone working together for a common goal, the nation is being fed crap to divide us. As long as we stay focused on being divided, we cannot work together for a common goal.
It seems that everyone is saying the same thing. We all want a better economy and a better way of living. But, depending on who you listen to, there are going to be several ways of doing it. And, depending on who you listen to, you will be fed information about leaders who are not helping.
I think people need to wake up and stop the constant bickering and work on a solution. This, unfortunately, is a fairy tale.
Further, instead of listening to talking heads with strong opinions, how about just looking at the raw facts without the b.s. narration?
This is why I rarely (I do a little bit) listen/watch U.S. "news." The U.S. networks do not report news. They mold it and present it in a way to meet their agenda.
I find BBC very informative, as well as other non-U.S. news sources. I am not saying they are not bias at all, but not even close to the extent of our mainstream media.
Are you saying that you have to censor yourself? Are you saying that if you don't say what you are expected to say that you can get into trouble? Are you saying that having an opposing opinion and expressing it is a bad thing?
That is exaclly what I am saying...
I think people need to wake up and stop the constant bickering and work on a solution.
Truly sad. And, to an outsider such as myself, even more disturbing than the original post.
What on earth are you fighting for? Freedom? Certainly not your own. Again, truly sad.
An interesting read. I say read because you can't safely comment. http://theview.abc.go.com/forum/cost-becks-rally
Laudable that SOF gets a lot of money. Not so laudable that a third of every donation goes to pay Beck's expenses.
Having trouble joining the site. Awaiting email from them.
It was not a political rally from the point of view of the podium. If it were, those donations would not have qualified for 501(c) in the eyes of the IRs. The crowd didn't realize it and were political.
Remember when Beck stated during the rally about wondering how it was to be paid? A 'miracle' happened and while he was on the plane (I believe he said). Don't have the exact quote. He was told they got a $600,000 donation. Well, before Special Operations Warrior Foundation accepts any donations, your expenses have to be paid in full. The rally cost approx. two million. Prior to the rally, when asked how he was going to pay for it, Beck stated he wasn't sure. Then he said the expenses will be deducted from all donations. Total donations collected at last count...close to six million. Therefore, SOWF did not receive what is reported as donated by the media. It was two million or so less. Many people who knew this beforehand pulled their donations and gave to SOWF directly. My point being..why plan the event if you don't have an inkling how it will be financed. Then you take from those attending? Kind of pulling the wool over their eyes. I would have felt better if there were an entry fee upfront. Then I know for sure what I donate goes to whom I want it to.
But what I am curious STILL about, is why have you brought this up?
Because it was emailed to me by a friend who is a retired Naval commander. I was very curious to see what people who are currently still in the military would have to say. Since my friend was in the military, I found his point of view very interesting, especially since it is different from some people still in the military.
I am not posting to inflame. I am posting because this is current events, and it should be discussed. But, as I am more aware of now, not everyone can speak freely.
I've been hanging out here too long. I am very in touch with my feminine side. I may even be growing boobs. I may be asking advice soon about where to buy a Manzere.
Bro, The - term for a bra like device that Frank Costanza (George's Dad) and Kramer come up with to help the heavier man deal with support issues for the chest area. (Also called the Manzere)
Edit: I quoted "The View" because it was good information, regardless of who said it.
For starters, yes people in the Military absolutely have to watch what they say about the President for one simple reason. He is their boss. I am sure we are all aware of what happened to General McChrystal, he was canned over bad mouthing the president. Sure he turned in a letter of resignation but really he had no choice.
This requirement to respect the Commander in Chief goes from the top ranking General down to the newest recruit in Basic Training. The punishment can be as light and easy as it was for McChrystal or they could make sure you never get a real job again in your life.
Now if they support what the administration is doing they can just go right on ahead and talk it up:)
As for the original 'question' that this post seems to be eluding to....
Yes, this was a political rally. There is no way that one could say that it was not. When somebody such as Glenn Beck puts on a rally with the intent to gather this many people what does anybody think will happen?
Glenn Beck knew what he was doing, he is the largest mouthpiece of the resistance to Obama and the Liberals.... Anything and everything this guy does is political. Why would somebody as outspoken as Beck organize hundreds of thousands of people if there was no motive behind it? It certainly was not a little BBQ with some old friends no matter what his little "disclaimer" about not being a rally and leaving your signs at home said....
Thank you for the honest answer. So many people are such sheep that they think that if Beck says it is not a political rally, then it isn't.
If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, and looks like a duck....
And, thank you for the further clarification on the 'freedom of speech' thing. That clarifies it a lot more. I suppose the rule to follow when speaking is to be respectful.
What gets me is that so many people these days are joining the military because they cannot get any other job. These people must feel that things in this country are going down the crapper. After all, they are joining the military as a last resort. It will be interesting to see how these people behave themselves when it comes to discussing their opinions on matters.
I have read over many of the posts in this thread and I feel that a lot of people take the Constitution and translate it how they see fit. If you follow history you will see that the men that founded this country were in fact Christian. They founded the US on Christianity and when they said that the people had freedom of religion, you are correct. They were tired of the government controlling religion and they recognized the need to keep the government out of controlling how Church was conducted. The idea behind separating Church and State was to keep the State out of Church, it has now been twisted around and people act like it was intended to keep religious views out of the Government.
If you do your research you will see that the United States of America financed the publication and distribution of hundreds of thousands of Holy Bibles to schools throughout the country to be used as the only textbook they had. They mention their trust in God on their currency they recite his name in the star spangled banner, they even go as far as to say that He was the Power that created the nation and Now the Government of the United States has taken the Pledge of Allegiance out of schools because it says "God" , they are not allowed to teach certain lessons that are solid in HISTORY because it may put emphasis on religious views and they want to take the name off the currency. Why? Separation of Church and State? Opposition by other religions?.... I assure you this was not the intent of the writers of the Constitution.
With that being said, it is very difficult to run a country 200 plus years later on the same ideals that were lived by when it was founded when the morals of the people in the country have differed from those that were held at that time. What is even more difficult is when the people translating and ordering the direction of our nation based of the Constitution use their own beliefs to influence its 'meaning'. If you read the Constitution with the mind set that a group of wealthy protestant men would have written it you will come out with a much different view than that of what you see when you look around today. If you took a group of people that were all Christians and wrote the Constitution do you really think their religion had no influence in its intent? Could you not read the Constitution and see Biblical teachings being represented throughout it?
Now read the Constitution with the mindset that a bunch of homosexuals or muslims or prostitutes or atheists, or Mormons wrote it and you will get 5 other complete meanings of the document.....
Do not read this as me telling anybody what should be done in the Government, I am simply trying to help some people understand where the origins of this country truly came from. It is not what many people today think it is. Reading some news papers will not educate you on much and sadly education in schools is so washed out today that you will not get a good education there either. We have to be careful not to upset the Muslims, the Jews, Islamist or the Christians so we have to tip toe around some events that shaped this world.
If somebody wants to complain that they are a military family and not Christian, I do not know what to say. It is just the way that it is. Right now the US is fighting a war and no matter how you want to look at it, it is a religious war. While the US may be fighting terrorism, the terrorists are fighting the West which in their view is a Christian based civilization that also supports Israel. If you are not sure what the motive behind Iran and the rest of the Arabs, Persians and other Islamists desire to destroy Israel is, I will tell you....its Religion and absolutely nothing more than that.
Our President while many Americans believe he is a Muslim has had his cabinet make specific announcements stating his belief in Christianity and was sure to let the public know that he prays daily. That will certainly stir up some extreme Islamists. Right now Europe is considered a part of the West along with the US all of which are Christian based Countries. Some may be Protestant, some Catholic or whatever they want to call themselves. They are banning muslim head wraps, minarets, mosques ect. If you think this is world is not motivated by religion or that we are not in a religious war or that the US was not founded on Christianity or that multiple religions can exist in peace to the extent that you think you read in the Constitution, you need to educate yourself.
Keep an eye out for the next religious conflict we may enter into. We will say its to prevent a nuclear power rising up but the ISLAMIC Republic of Iran will see it as an invasion based on religious motivations and a desire to eliminate Islam. Interestingly enough the 'invading' coalition will be an army made up of all 'Christian' countries.
Sorry if I got off in any other directions, I tried to stay within things I see here in this thread:)