Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Consultant question

who's talking here?

WitnessProtectionProgram 1
Rachel 2
ashml 1
Girl from the south 2
Euro Maker 1
jasmine06 5
Audrey 1
rmitchell248 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

jasmine06 --- 16 years ago -

GaryKenyon --- 11 hours ago - quote - flag comment

You pretty much hit it on the head JOFTAA, but as far as you not being sure why legal is an issue with it, rest assured it is.

German customs does come in to the post offices from time to time and opens random boxes to make sure that box holders are not receiving knock off/illegal items or, in the case of running an in home business, skirting German tax laws.

Example: a few weeks ago customs comes in and decides to open a few PartyLite boxes, and what do they find inside? The business papers showing how much this one person made selling crappy candles. The main point in that, from what the customs guy was telling is, that this person may end up having to pay over $40,000 in fines/taxes.

You can also have your APO privileges revoked or suspended; IE: nothing that weighs more than 16oz goes in to your box.



The other page was getting to long, my head was spinning with the different topics going on.

Anyway....I asked on there, how come we can't just pay the taxes and be done with the whole thing? Also, if a consultant is doing only online orders through friends stateside,they are still making income here,but selling stateside..so why bother fighting it? 

rmitchell248 --- 16 years ago -

Your question is very confusing? 

jasmine06 --- 16 years ago -

Sorry for the confusion. I want to know why its such a big deal to be a consultant over here if we just paid the German taxes. How do we go about paying the taxes so our stuff doesn't get opened up! 

rmitchell248 --- 16 years ago -

The only way to do this would be to ship the stuff to your house, not your APO pay the increased shipping cost from the US, import fees. VAT and the income tax on the products you sell. You would end up paying 40-50% more than the lady doing it illegally which would have to be reflected in the cost of your product in order for you to make a profit. You would then loose business due to your high operating costs.

That's why those people chance it and violate US and German law to sell their product. 

Girl from the south --- 16 years ago -

I thought you could get the Installation Commander's permission to operate a home-based business and it was all good. Or it is just home-based consultants?
In other words, if I order materials to make and possibly sell a craft, am I going to be in trouble??? 

jasmine06 --- 16 years ago -

Ok, my possible plan then. If I become a consultant,but only do my parties through stateside friends, I should be good,right? 

rmitchell248 --- 16 years ago -

Jasmine, does that mean you will be selling NO goods here then? 

rmitchell248 --- 16 years ago -

MommaG, I think that you could get authorization to operate a home based business but I do not think that would allow you to operate using the Military Mail system via your APO box. Keep in mind the mail is controlled by both the Americans keeping cost to a minimum on their shipping as well as the German customs office patrolling what comes via the mail in order to uphold their import laws. With that being said, I cannot see the base commander having the authority to allow you to violate German Customs regulations. He could authorize a home business being run on 'his' base. He would basically be authorizing you to operate out of your home as long as you follow all local and American law that pertains to what ever your business is.

I am going to be honest that I am obviously not an expert on German law but I can say with pretty good certainty that if you ship goods here from the US and resell them without paying the import taxes or VAT or what ever duties are due you are violating law no matter what way you go about it. If you sold the goods only to other Military members you would probably find some loopholes. The second that you sold one thing to a German Citizen I could see you getting in a TON of legal trouble if it ever came up. Essentially you brought goods through customs illegally, operated a business illegally and sold goods to a German Citizen without giving the government its required taxes. All of that equals a world of trouble if it ever came to light.


Jasmine, If you sold only to friends in the US and operated remotely you would simply be liable to pay your US income taxes on the goods. You could end up paying close to little tax because I am sure that you could balance your profits by finding close to equal deductions due to operating costs. With it being a home business and you the Sole Proprietor your deductions will be household items that you would normally be purchasing wether you had the business or not so you would be making more money off the business but you will now be able to write items off as a business owner that you would not have been able to before as a military dependent. If you get it going and need more info on all of that let me know when the time comes.

I hope that helps 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

see I didn't know any of that....well that sucks 

jasmine06 --- 16 years ago -

Great! So, the other question that I'm sure so many people want answered. If a consultant sold here,but instead of having a whole shipment go to their APO box, had it go to each customers APO box...that's ok?

We don't want any gaps in information! 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

Jasmine, it HAS to be ok. The school in RAF Lakenheath,UK is doing that school selling thing. Where your kid gets a book full of crap to sell to other people and if the kid sells enough they get a prize. Well, the school is making money off of this too. The way they are doing this is by having all the items each person buys sent to their indivual APO boxes instead of sending it to the students to pass out to the customers like they did when I was younger. All of these items are coming from the states. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

Yeah, Jasmine, that's it. Just like you can order from Target or Amazon or wherever to your own box. 

jasmine06 --- 16 years ago -

Great, so we're golden! Now that I know I wont be losing my APO box, I wont freak out. 

Girl from the south --- 16 years ago -

So if I ONLY sell to ID holders.....what then. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

I think the bottom line is that it is still illegal, but you would have less chance of getting caught. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

So if I ONLY sell to ID holders.....what then.

Then either have your distributor drop ship to your customers, or, have the merchandise shipped to your home address for you to later distribute.

You cannot have your distributor ship to your APO, nor can you ship to an APO yourself.

Just ask yourself these questions:

Is what I am shipping being shipped as a part of my business?

If the answer is YES, you may not use military mail.

Is what I am receiving for business?


If the answer is YES, you may not use military mail. 

Audrey --- 15 years ago -

I ordered Partylite candles, for myself, through my stateside consultant's connection to the PL website. Yesterday the package sheet was in my box. The line was too long, so I went back today, and found a form in a my box informing me that my package of candles had been taken by German customs. So now I have to go to the German Customs office and somehow prove that I will not resell these, which I won't. I plan to burn them. Blah! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground