No, nothing to do with being 'too tough' on a particular student. I dont believe it is anything particularly 'bad' either. Just need to get some other parents and students perspectives. I dont believe in branding a teacher in any way, students have to learn if possible how to succeed in spite of teachers sometimes. You are never going to like every teacher you ever have, and our student knows and accepts that. Obviously no one on this board has had experience with her, so the point is mute.