Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: what would you do?

who's talking here?

Mojo 7
HuskerFan 3
angel2009 2
Rachel 2
ashml 10
Kristen 3
Abe 2
Blueser oO 1
oszbbk 2
daisy 1
MAD4EUROPE 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: what would you do?

Just a hypothetical situation, You have a mom/sister (family member) that is in a bad relationship with an abuser. He goes off one day and hits her. You help her to move out, get a place and get her life started back over. She lets him move in with her after this happens. Even though this is the first abusive relationship and she doesn't know if she "loves him". What would you do if he hit her again?

Feel sorry for her but not help her. Vote
 
 5.3% (1)
Help her, regardless of how many times this happens. Vote
 
 89.5% (17)
Say forget about it you tried but obviously she isn't listening. Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Just ignore it Vote
 
 5.3% (1)
ashml --- 16 years ago -

Just a hypothetical situation,
You have a mom/sister (family member) that is in a bad relationship with an abuser. He goes off one day and hits her. You help her to move out, get a place and get her life started back over. She lets him move in with her after this happens. Even though this is the first abusive relationship and she doesn't know if she "loves him". What would you do if he hit her again? 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

was just curious what someone would do. I see this happen a lot and was just curious. 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

It's hard to watch, but all you can do is be there. Abusive relationships are rarely cut and dry, and it can take years for somebody to get out of the cycle of abuse and not fall back into it.

I'm sure lots of people will say "Cut her out its not your problem" or something, but I've seen this approach and all it really does is take away any support systems she may have available. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

It is very hard for those of us who have never been in an abusive situation to understand what the h*ll someone is thinking, why they stay, go back, etc. I used to work with rape victims, and went through some really good domestic violence training as part of it. If you deny your help, the woman isn't going to realize she's losing those close to her and finally break off the bad relationship. It isn't like an intervention with a drug addiction in that way. She will instead just end up with no one to turn to, and might end up feeling like she has no options when/if she finally does decide to leave.

Real help that you can provide would be helping her come up with escape plans, codes to use on the phone, stash her ID, extra money, child's birth certificates, etc. for her, extra clothes. Often a victim has to leave in a hurry and can't gather what she needs, or her abuser hides these things from her to keep her from leaving. 

Abe --- 16 years ago -

No one has addressed the obvious. She is family, there are no options, you help!! 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

Well in a "usual" case, this would be differant but in this case...

This woman (that I know) was never in an abusive relationship. Tends to date men that "take care of her financially" and she doesn't have kids.

It baffals me that she knows what he is doing is wrong. She doesn't even know if she loves him but yet is willing to deal with his drug addicted ways. When he was asking her to quit her job and move out...I knew that was bad...and I told her not too. But of course she did. After I spoke with her after it happened (and I was the one that had to call police for help) she told me it took her a month to get used to society since he never let her go anywhere....

so its kinda like yeah well you are an idiot but you don't deserve it...Its kind of differant from other abuse scenarios. I mean I heard people staying with their abusers because they love him but never for money 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

Well, I'd disagree with you there Abe, but in this particular situation, friend or family, I'd still offer to be there and help if needed. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

PS I would help too just to say..no matter what I think 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

Ash, I have heard of people staying with abusers because of money. It's a classic abuser tactic, to get the woman completely reliant upon THEM for everything. They will make the woman feel like she has NOTHING without him, that she will never amount to anything without him, you get the idea.

That is a big red flag for abuse in a lot of situations; cutting the woman off from family/friends and getting her to be financially dependent upon him, makes it harder for her to get away. 

Abe --- 16 years ago -

Mojo not sure I understand your disagreement with me, as you seem to be agreeing with me, friend or family, I'd still offer to be there and help if needed.

I am confused. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

makes it harder for her to get away.


he though that until he met me. Funny thing is he is absolutely terrified of me and he HAS to see me when I come home in December. Possibly because if a man ever hit me I sure as he!! would kick his a$$..who knows...I just think its pathetic that he can beat on her but is absolutely terrified of me. Still don't understand it..Still astounished that the place she is staying allowed him to move in since i asked them to go get her for me so I could make sure she was safe...so I was like ummmm you save her from the abuser then let him move in? Stupid on their part 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

No one has addressed the obvious. She is family, there are no options, you help!!

Family doesn't get an automatic pass just for being family. In this situation, absolutely I'd help no matter how exasperated I was. But, there are other situations that I would not help.

Ash, it's hard to watch somebody go through an abusive relationship. But I would be really careful about provoking him or threatening him, because he'll just likely turn around and take it out on her. It's really just best to kind of act like he doesn't exist, and be temperate when you do have to deal with him. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

It's really just best to kind of act like he doesn't exist, and be temperate when you do have to deal with him
he is avoiding me so more and likely won't have to deal with him. Just saying. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

I have been in a situation where a family member keeps going back. Then they say they are leaving-we get everything lined up, including a place to go, get the legalities rolling. Spend tons of $$ to get them all 'set up' and they don't leave, or leave and go back in months. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

 

daisy --- 16 years ago -

I have helped my sister and a friend from an abusive relationship.I didn't ask them to leave their abusive husband or boyfriend as it would be their decision,but i would offer my help and be a friend in need. 

oszbbk --- 16 years ago -

No one has addressed the obvious. She is family, there are no options, you help!!

I wish that were always the case. When I was in this situation, family would only help me if I let them have full control of my life.

ashml, from being on the other side of this senario...do not bad mouth your friends abuser to your friend. If she continues to be with him, that will only put a short life to your friendship. I started dropping my friends, not because he wanted me to, but because I didn't want to her them talk crap about him. It didn't matter that what they said was true. I knew it was.

And I took mine back for financial reasons, I didn't love him, I felt stuck with him. He made sure every dang bill (except for the cars) were in my name and we had the biggest packeages possible (like cable n cell phones). We rented a big house that my income alone could not pay for it and the utilities let alone all our extras. He'd treat me like crap, I'd kick him out, and he'd take all the cars. All 3 of em, and I couldn't do a thing leagally about it. Well come time for bills due again and I'd have to sweet talk him back. He knew exactly what he was doing. It took years to get away. I had to stash money every chance I got. Close out accounts and not renew plans when the time came. It changed my lifestyle but it was worth it. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

It is hard, I had to sneak out too. IT was not fun. I ended up with nothing, not even a car. I took the one I was paying on and he came and took it in the middle of the night. Cops would do nothing about it. It stunk. That is for sure. I left and lived with friends, family would have done the same --wanted to completely run my life--

Thankfully I had set myself up with a decent job. 

HuskerFan --- 16 years ago -

Just a hypothetical situation, You have a mom/sister (family member) that is in a bad relationship with an abuser. He goes off one day and hits her. You help her to move out, get a place and get her life started back over. She lets him move in with her after this happens. Even though this is the first abusive relationship and she doesn't know if she "loves him". What would you do if he hit her again?

There are ways of making someone "dissapear"...and I am not saying this as a joke and tryingot make light of the situation.... 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

OMG lol. He'll sleep with the fishes. 

HuskerFan --- 16 years ago -

OMG lol. He'll sleep with the fishes.

Yes and no....the abuser could dissapear or the abusee....ANYONE could dissapear and never be found again....BUT if its the abusee, they have to be willing to totally "dissapear"...it will mean sacrifices....sorta like the witness protection program!!!! 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

I don't bad mouth him to her even though I want to punch him in the face...I don't. Just kind of astounishes me that she hands over her apt her car everything when she KNEW how he was. (sometimes never came home etc) hadn't even "abused" her mentally or physically yet. I am just kind of sick of her looking for someone that has money and not that is a good person....I think a good part of the reason he is back because no one could give her the amount of money she wanted...so I feel bad for her but at the same time want to slap her too LOL There is more to the story but I just wanted to share the generalization of it 

angel2009 --- 16 years ago -

Family doesn't get an automatic pass just for being family

Well they do in my book...no matter what! 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

Husker, that rarely happens IRL without massive repercussions. There are programs that will relocate a woman if she's being abused, but it's not as simple as a lifetime movie or something. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

Well they do in my book...no matter what!


even if they abuse you and use you for years? (just wondering cause I sure as heck won't help some people in my family because how they are...but I would help their children) 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

I have family that I won't touch with a 10-ft pole because they will abuse and take and take and take and it's really not worth it. I won't have it around my son, I won't give and give and give just to give some more when they continue to make bad decisions, and I'm not going to allow certain family members anywhere in my life.

No matter what usually means "I have a fairly normal family with no major issues" lol. 

angel2009 --- 16 years ago -

I guess I do, I thought this threat was about a fam. member being abused..
let me go back and read again. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

I guess I do, I thought this threat was about a fam. member being abused..
let me go back and read again



well yes I would help the abused victim...but some family members I wouldn't help with other problems...guess I had to restate that 

MAD4EUROPE --- 16 years ago -

No one has addressed the obvious. She is family, there are no options, you help!!

Yes, I agree to a certain extent. BUT, at what point do YOU (as the helper) say enough is enough. We went through this with my cousin. We went through many changes through that whole ordeal. We kept helping, she kept going back "I love him and you don't understand" BS. Then it's "help me, he just gave me ANOTHER black eye" BS. This has went on about 11 times so far. I'm done. Call me a bit$h if you will but I have spent a great deal of money out of my pocket and so has my family with trying to help her. We have made her budgets, got an apartment in a different state, made plans for her and with her. Why should we continue to help someone that won't help themselves. That is a tiring and never-ending cycle.

BUT, I will always be there to help if they have kids. My door will always be open for those kids but NOT the person who's not willing to make life changes. I will not stand by and see a child suffer (physically or emotionally).

Just my 2 cents though! 

HuskerFan --- 16 years ago -

Husker, that rarely happens IRL without massive repercussions. There are programs that will relocate a woman if she's being abused, but it's not as simple as a lifetime movie or something

Never said it was easy...didnt say it would be all gumdrops and pink clouds like on tv...of course it would be tough..common sense says it would be hard....doing things UNDER the radar are ALWAYS hard 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground