Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Pet Peeve

who's talking here?

Mojo 1
Bob 2
Atticus Finch 1
Cloudless 1
dipthong 1
rtmitchell 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Bob --- 15 years ago -

i was just reading a review for a book about wwi and came across one of my pet peeves. the review mentioned that one of the people in the unit "won" the medal of honor. this is not a compititon!!! you do not "win" a medal of honor!!!! you are awarded, receive, or are presented the medal. i know there are some of you who will not understand why this upsets me so much but i feel, along with many others, that the term "win" belittles the award. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

I think a lot of people who weren't in the military don't understand the distinction. I get where you're coming from, it's not exactly a competition and most people are awarded the Medal of Honor posthumously. 

rtmitchell --- 15 years ago -

Where I agree with you that the sound of winning the Medal of Honor does not sound right I do have to let you know that the following is taken from the definition of Win or Won.

1. To achieve victory or finish first in.
2. To receive as a prize or reward for performance.
3. To achieve or attain by effort.
4. To obtain or earn


I do not like the term "he won the Medal of Honor" but I can assure you that based on the definition of the word, it can be said this way and be correct. 

Cloudless --- 15 years ago -

Actually I think it's simply a euphemism that the general public understands. I think the American people honestly understand that a MOH recipent did not compete for the award. In much the same way as you would "Paint the town red" vs "Celebrated". So it's like saying, "They did not 'paint the town red', they celebrated. We know the difference and can navigate the semantics, yes? 

rtmitchell --- 15 years ago -

In the end, I am with you Cloudless. Time for me to catch some shut eye... ( although i don't really intend to catch anything ) 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

i don't get he idea of the euphemism explanation. these people willingly placed their life in danger for their friends. to say a person "won" the medal of honor is nothing like saying a person "painted the town red" this is more like a misunderstanding of the situation.

rtmitchell, your definition may be correct for a person who is trying to optain, earn, be awarded, or receive a prize. medal of honor recipients do not try to get the medal.

the change if viewpoints about awards is probably the reason that silver stars and bronze stars are being passed out like halloween candy. i'm still confused how a person who sits in the pentagon or a rear position can be awarded a combat award.

go to this web site:

http://www.cmohs.org/

this is the official page for the award and the people how received the award. notice the use of the word recipient and not winner. good enough for me. no semantics involved. 

rtmitchell --- 15 years ago -

I don't think it is as much of a change in view points as it is a lack of understanding of how complex meanings for a word work in a sentence. Here is an example.

Quote from Bob"rtmitchell, your definition may be correct for a person who is trying to optain, earn, be awarded, or receive a prize. medal of honor recipients do not try to get the medal."

From the website that you linked "In the week following Lee's surrender 8 more Medals of Honor were earned, 7 of them at...."

Now were they trying to earn that? Or did they just happen to earn it? Its too complex to get tripped up on the meaning of words.


The problem here is that simply I do not like to hear about winning such an award either. But I will not go on a rant about it because the basic definitions of the words work. I agree that the word "won" or "win" could be argued as belittling the perception of it but you are getting a bit overboard with it.

I only say this as there is not a person alive that knows what the Medal of Honor actually is and thinks that it is something you win.

I promise you that if somebody thinks that its something you win as a competition they will think it is the same thing wether you say that it was won or awarded.

Therefor your frustrations are a waste as you will not say awarded to somebody who is ignorant of the truth and have it mean anything different from won as to most people you are awarded a medal for winning. 

dipthong --- 15 years ago -

0 

Atticus Finch --- 15 years ago -

My pet (dog) peeved on the floor!

Atticus the Grinch 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground