Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Schools ‘spy’ on fat kids

who's talking here?

Mojo 2
Bob 1
Dani 1
dipthong 2
rtmitchell 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

dipthong --- 14 years ago -

I wonder if these are the same schools that feed the kids horrible food?
-----

By MARY KAY LINGE

Last Updated: 7:12 AM, January 15, 2012

Posted: 3:56 AM, January 15, 2012

Big Brother is joining the battle of the bulge.

A group of Long Island students will soon be wearing controversial electronic monitors that allow school officials to track their physical activity around the clock.

The athletics chair for the Bay Shore schools ordered 10 Polar Active monitors, at $90 a pop, for use starting this spring. The wristwatchlike devices count heartbeats, detect motion and even track students’ sleeping habits in a bid to combat obesity.

The information is displayed on a color-coded screen and gets transmitted to a password-protected Web site that students and educators can access.

The devices are already in use in school districts in St. Louis and South Orange, NJ — and have raised privacy concerns among some parents and observers.

But Ted Nagengast, the Bay Shore athletics chair, said, “It’s a great reinforcement in fighting the obesity epidemic. It tells kids, in real time, ‘Am I active? Am I not active?’ We want to give kids the opportunity to become active.”

The monitors are distributed by Polar Electro, of Lake Success, LI, the US division of a Finland firm.

In the South Orange-Maplewood School District, where earlier versions of the devices have been used for two years, upper-grade students’ marks in phys ed are based in part on heart-rate monitors and activity sensors.

Teachers use hand-held computers to collect data from each student’s wrist monitor during class, then upload the information to the school computer system for storage and long-term tracking.

But privacy advocates and parents worry that schools are using electronic monitors in phys ed without families’ knowledge or consent.

“I didn’t even know it was going on, and I’m active in the school,” said Beth Huebner, of St. Louis.

Her son, a fourth-grader, wore a Polar Active monitor in class without her OK last fall at Ross Elementary School.

“We have gotten no information about the Web-site security or where the data will go,” Huebner said.

“When you get into monitoring people’s biological vital signs, that’s a pretty intrusive measurement,” said Jay Stanley, of the American Civil Liberties Union. “There are key privacy interests at play.”

At the very least, says Stanley, parents must have a say in how long the data will be stored and who will have access to it and schools must obtain parents’ consent.

“A program like this should only be voluntary. Nobody should be forced to reveal biological indicators,” he said.

“It’s all about secondary use,” said Virginia Rezmierski, an expert on information technology and privacy at the University of Michigan.

“Does the data pass along with the child from school to school? When will insurance companies want to get access to it? Will a school want to medicate a child that the monitor identifies as hyperactive? It’s potentially very dangerous ground.” 

Mojo --- 14 years ago -

Sounds like one giant HIPAA violation. I applaud the schools for trying to do something about childhood obesity, but that is very misguided. 

Dani --- 14 years ago -

Look at thisthis... How horrible does this make us look? I would rather eat food from any of those other countries then our own... 

Bob --- 14 years ago -

if the device doesn't allow the school to track where the students are i can't see a problem...as long as the parents know. the last part of that statement is the key. school official should be required to notify the parents and get a signed letter of permission before having the student wear a device like this.

dani, some of the stuff on that page doesn't look very healthy to me but it's still better than most of the places talked about on the underground.

mojo, i don't agree that it's misguided but it does need a lot of tweaking before it does any good. besides parental permission this should only be done for children who look for help. making children who don't want to participate wear one of those things could actually do more harm than good. peer pressure on overweight kids is terrible, i know from experience. 

rtmitchell --- 14 years ago -

Why is this a HIPPA violation? Its a study to see how much exercise kids get. Its not a venture to share confidential health information. The results won't be published by name at the school pep rally on friday nights.

As Bob said it needs work, I agree that parents need to be able to opt their kids out or in.

The thing is that I don't know why you really need to do this research. I see kids all the time and know they barely ever exercise. The most many get is to and from the bus stop. PE has become a joke in most schools. At the end of the study they will just know how little exercise they really get and be in shock that this coupled with horrid eating habits is the reason for such poor health in young Americans. 

dipthong --- 14 years ago -

I point my fingers at parents. It is parents that are supposed to teach kids proper eating habits. Having said that, just because a parent does their job at home, does not mean the kids will not be subject to peer pressure at school. We've discussed this before. In Miami schools, for example, they allow places such as Papa John's and Burger King to sell food at the school because the school is unable to accommodate all of the students with a hot lunch during the short time allotted to do so. A kid who is taught proper eating habits at home is not necessarily going to turn down the fast food at school. Sure, they can pack a lunch. I know that argument is coming. But, packing a lunch is not always going to stop kids with a few bucks in their pocket from eating poorly. Kids are going to be kids.

Schools in Miami don't even have P.E. any longer. It was eliminated with some of the budget cuts.

How many calories are burned by lifting ones hand from the fast food wrapper to the mouth, or walking from the Xbox to the refrigerator?

From the story:
But Ted Nagengast, the Bay Shore athletics chair, said, “It’s a great reinforcement in fighting the obesity epidemic. It tells kids, in real time, ‘Am I active? Am I not active?’ We want to give kids the opportunity to become active.”

It is sad that these kids need to be told when they are not active. If they don't know when they are/aren't active, we have more to worry about than these kids getting fat. 

Mojo --- 14 years ago -

If it is tracking and storing heart rate, activity level, and sleeping habits as the article suggests, it could indeed be crossing into protected health information, and therefore subject to a whole slough of regulations on use. Not saying the school isn't already in line with that, just saying it sounds like HIPAA to me.

Like I said, I understand the purpose behind it, I just think maybe there should be more focus on phys ed, because it seems to me that schools are losing funding and cutting that first. Slapping a heart rate monitor on the fat kid doesn't help much if they aren't giving them ample opportunity to exercise and be active. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground