Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

German Taxes

who's talking here?

angel2009 1
GEOJEDIMEISTER 6
Unclassified 1
imhere 2
Cloudless 1
a3302767uu 1
JustM4E 1
rtmitchell 4
unique 3
a1827401uu 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

a1827401uu --- 13 years ago -

Does anybody out there have problems with the German Finanzamt? Americans being taxed by the Germans? 

GEOJEDIMEISTER --- 13 years ago -

Can you give more detail. Do you have a German spouse or are you running a business?

Many times the Finanzamt will try to tax a German spouse based on their American spouses income.

My wife is German in they have asked her on many times what my income is and she always tells them if they want to know my income they need to ask me. Of course they never will ask me.

But for real answers I believe you should make an appoinment with a German attorney on base. Advice from anyone other than an attorney is most likely wrong or not complete. 

Cloudless --- 13 years ago -

I disagree there Geojaegermeister, sort of. If you are running a business as a German or American, the legal office cannot and will not give advice. It's a SOFA thing. Better to find a tax advisor on the economy. But others here do run businesses and can better explain. 

a1827401uu --- 13 years ago -

The Germans are taxing more and more Americans. My husband falls under the SOFA Agreement but the Finanzamt really doesn't care. They say You live here so you have to pay. Even tough, he is not registered here! My German Lawyer told me, that they even try to tax DOD teachers! 

rtmitchell --- 13 years ago -

If your income is all from the SOFA umbrella then you cannot face any German tax burden.

If you have any income outside of the SOFA then you will pay taxes only on your German income. Your tax bracket can be increased based on your SOFA income but you will not pay taxes on that income.

If you have no income outside of your SOFA job's pay the Finanzamt will not even know who you are. So if your husband is getting mail from the Finanzamt then he has something on the side going on, sold a house or made some profit somewhere along the lines. 

a3302767uu --- 13 years ago -

Can rental income be taxed? 

imhere --- 13 years ago -

The Finanzamt is not going to bother your husband, because he is 'stationed' in germany, not 'living' in it. As the wife you should be in tax class 1 (or 2 if you have children) - single/ single with children. You pay more taxes each month, but get it back by the end of the year. If I remember right you 'could' choose 3/5 or 4/4, then they will consider the husbands income at the end of the year as a foreign income. 

angel2009 --- 13 years ago -

I just love how people post about getting "ripped off here" by realtors, utility companies, Telekom, Tks and now the Finanzamt and God knows who else. There are always 2 sides to a story. Why would you be taxed for no reason....come on! 

JustM4E --- 13 years ago -

The Germans are taxing more and more Americans. My husband falls under the SOFA Agreement but the Finanzamt really doesn't care. They say You live here so you have to pay. Even tough, he is not registered here! My German Lawyer told me, that they even try to tax DOD teachers!

I have been here almost a decade and have never heard of that.

If you have no income outside of your SOFA job's pay the Finanzamt will not even know who you are.

^^^^THIS^^^^ 

Unclassified --- 13 years ago -

I just love how people post about getting "ripped off here" by realtors, utility companies, Telekom, Tks and now the Finanzamt and God knows who else. There are always 2 sides to a story. Why would you be taxed for no reason....come on!

Because all the Tax man cares about is getting more money.

The issue isn't just a "German" issue. I'm a Texas resident, my wife is a New York resident. When we have filed taxes before when both of us had an income, New York always attempts to tax her based on my active-duty Texas income. Same thing has happened to many friends in similar situations, and requires very carefully filing procedures to avoid New York from taxing my wife based on my Texas No Income Tax Here! wages. 

unique --- 13 years ago -

Sifting through the answers, the straightforward one would be no, the German Government cannot tax you if you are under the SOFA agreement and you are not running a buisness. Also, if you are a veteran living in Germany, they cant tax any money received from the VA or the military! So, dont let them try to tell you that either! The only way they can tax you is if you are making money from the German economy somehow.. I mean why would you pay taxes when you dont receive any money from the German Government? It just doesnt make sense.. 

a1827401uu --- 13 years ago -

We went through Court - the Germans are taxing us. I am German, have a normal job (get paid in EUR) and my husband is civilan, used to be Military - working on Base. The German Finanzamt says that we do NOT fall under the SOFA because they consider him as a resident of Germany. Somewhere the SOFA Agreement says, if there is NO intend of going back to the US - they can tax you. We fought for several years because of that and there is no way out. We want to go back to the States, but they (Finanzamt) say, there is no proof that you really go back and thats why they tax him. We heard that there are more Americans out there with that kind of problem. Kaiserslautern Finanzamt is not so bad - it's Landstuhl! If someone would have told me that a couple years ago, I would think that person is crazy and telling me BS. :-( 

GEOJEDIMEISTER --- 13 years ago -

You say he is a civilian but there are different categories of civilian employees. Civil Servants, NAF, PX Employeee, DoD Contractors. Which category does he fall in to?? If he is a DOD Contactor and has no TESA then yes, they can tax him on income.

When you say rental income do you mean income you are making by renting a house or income he is receiving from the US Government, or in the case of a DoD Contractor, from his company to rent a house? 

rtmitchell --- 13 years ago -

If you own a house here and rent it out then yes, you are supposed to be paying taxes on the rental income whether you live here or not! The property is in Germany so the first right to taxation is to the Germans. Double taxation agreements then come into play and your tax burden to the IRS will be reduced based on the taxes you paid to the Finanzamt! 

unique --- 13 years ago -

In regards to the civilian thing, the only reason why one of you is getting taxed is because one of you is registered in Germany and earns money on the German economy. My husband is German and he gets taxed since he's a LN and on the German system. Oh yeah, and its not true that DOD civilians can be taxed if under the SOFA agreement. I've never met a single DOD Civilian who has been told that they have to pay taxes to both the US and the German Gov't. There's a law that says that if you are paying taxes from your job with the US gov't, then they cant tax you also with the German Gov't for that same job.. If you arent earning money on the economy in some kind of way, they cant tax you! period! dont fall for it! If you have any problems and the legal office wont help you, call an American lawyer who has experience with the German system.. 

GEOJEDIMEISTER --- 13 years ago -

Not true. Some Finanzamts attempt to tax the US employees income by asking the the German spouse how much he or she recieves as taschengeld from the American spouse. So they are not taxing the American, they are taxing the German based on American money. Many new German spouses are ignorant regarding this and give the American income info not realizing that they do not have to. 

imhere --- 13 years ago -

I wonder how that works. They can only tax them depending on their taxclass ( usually I or II). That means according to the german government the spouses are not married, so why woukl they ask for their spouses income ? And why would the spouse give out any information ? 

GEOJEDIMEISTER --- 13 years ago -

I don't know but in Heidelberg they asked multiple times. It was never a problem in Hessen or here in RP. I have had co-workers in the past whose spouse was paying higher taxes based on the American income. I am sure it is not legal but many people don't know that and don't fight the system. 

rtmitchell --- 13 years ago -

Yes they can ask the German what the American spouse makes as it does adjust the German Tax payers tax rate.

You have to realize that the German tax brackets work similar to the Americans. And it is a sliding scale based on your income.

If the German makes 50,000€ and the American spouse makes the equivalent of 25,000€ the German spouse can be taxes only on his money but as if it were in the 25,000-75,000€ tax brackets.

This does not mean that the German spouse is actually paying taxes for the 25,000€ income of the American. It means that he is being slid into a higher tax bracket for his 50,000€ based on the American's income going underneath his. 

GEOJEDIMEISTER --- 13 years ago -

Does that include American income made under the SOFA agreement? I know that with US taxes if you file jointly you must claim WORLDWIDE income. 

rtmitchell --- 13 years ago -

Yes it counts for money made under SOFA. It falls under the same concept of 'Worldwide Income" but is taxed differently because the SOFA spouse will have already paid taxes in the US and will get a double taxation exemption here in Germany.

If the money made here was not made under SOFA then it would be taxed at the regular rates instead of just bumping up your spouses income to the higher brackets. Then taxes would not be paid in the US on that money as the double taxation protection would keep the first right to the taxation in Germany

There is no specific case for everyone as the tax code between the US and Germany is so convoluted that each case has its own stipulations. Self employed, rental incomes, pay falling under SOFA, pay thats not under SOFA it all changes slightly how the situation works. 

GEOJEDIMEISTER --- 13 years ago -

Does this only count if the German spouse files jointly like the US system? 

unique --- 13 years ago -

I think this only counts when the German spouse files jointly. However, if the US spouse makes less than 400 euros a month,then they will not tax it. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

help

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground