Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Breastfeeding in public..

who's talking here?

Mojo 4
anne 1
angel2009 1
Bob 1
BEAUTYLICIOUS 1
Rachel 4
WOW! 5
ashml 2
Brittney 3
CMS 5
cindyrella 1
Blueser oO 1
daisy 1
MAD4EUROPE 9
ellecee 1
lovnmyboys 1
covan 2
a2900765uu 1
Motherof2 6
Twinmama 1
DOGTRAINER 1
a2824059uu 1
American Citizen 2
Mittongal 1
Mom23OctBoys 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Motherof2 --- 15 years ago -

I don't mean to bring up any past arguements regarding this issue. I really just want to know people's feelings. I am currently breastfeeding my newborn, and have this sort of mental block about doing it in public. I was just wondering if women breastfeeding their children in public made you uncomfortable? Or what are you views on it? Of course, if I were to have to do it, I would be completely covered and off to the side of the store. Somewhere besides the middle of the food court of on the couches in the Exchange.. 

a2900765uu --- 15 years ago -

Nice, have you really seen people in the BX furniture department feeding on the sofa? I have actually seen people asleep there so it does not surprise me. I feel that if you choose to breast feed, feeding in public is just fine. The only thing that bothers me is when they do not cover up...if it were an adult setting covering up or not would not bother me either. I have a small son and although I know it is completely natural to breast feed I would prefer to not have to explain why he is seeing a womans boob until I am ready to explain that. 

MAD4EUROPE --- 15 years ago -

I just read a similar thread on the RAB Facebook page. Apparently a mother was told that she could not feed near the poolside of the aquatic center because it was considered food....

But to answer your question; it is completely natural and a part of life. I see nothing wrong with breast feeding anywhere. If your baby is hungry then they need to be fed, point blank, end of discussion! If someone is disgusted by this act then THEY have issues and you should not feel guilty for that. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

I have actually seen it on the furniture, too. I feel the same... feel free to do so in public, but I'd prefer if a woman covers up to do it. Heck, most moms get to the point where you often can't tell that they are feeding. 

Motherof2 --- 15 years ago -

Thank you all for your posts! Yes, I have seen women sitting on the furniture feeding lol. Not really sure how I feel about that.. But thank you all! I will feel much better now if a moment comes where I have to feed in public :) 

anne --- 15 years ago -

personally it has never bothered me but i do feel that moms should be covered. i rember my friend back in the states sat at mt dining room table feeding her baby in front of my folks and was not covered. each to theire own i think it would be nice if they were covered up . 

American Citizen --- 15 years ago -

If your baby is hungry then they need to be fed, point blank, end of discussion! If someone is disgusted by this act then THEY have issues and you should not feel guilty for that.

I am a new mother, i tried the crappy covering up but my baby suffocates under, so i leave the cover for the one who does not want to see us feed. I mean, I am not covering up and we breastfeed anywhere, everywhere and that is how it is and I do not recommend anyone to come near me and give nasty comments coz I will call the cops on you, and don't try me, I have done it, and i will do it again in a heart beat.

If your baby is hungry then they need to be fed, point blank, end of discussion! If someone is disgusted by this act then THEY have issues and you should not feel guilty for that.

Thank you M4E. 

covan --- 15 years ago -

Not sure what this is about. Do you have any photos? 

MAD4EUROPE --- 15 years ago -

@ Covan: Enjoy and you're welcome!

0 

MAD4EUROPE --- 15 years ago -

 

MAD4EUROPE --- 15 years ago -

0 

MAD4EUROPE --- 15 years ago -

Hmmm...not sure why this one isn't posting.

Quick, click me! 

angel2009 --- 15 years ago -

 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Doesn't make me uncomfortable, but then I did it so I am kind of more interested in the teeny baby feet that always stick out when the are nursing. So freaking nommable.

But, you should stay within your comfort zone either way, and not feel obligated to do it if you don't want to. 

covan --- 15 years ago -

WOW, did I post that? Seems during momentary blackouts, I channel JOFTAA. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

I swear that aquatic center thing is an urban legend, but the fact of the matter is nursing is feeding, and it's also bodily fluids, and I agree that you shouldn't do it in or next to the pool. It's not like they asked her to leave the whole facility, just not nurse in an area where no food or drink are allowed. FWIW, I really hate when people throw out the whole nursing mom thing like it's a free pass to do whatever they want.

There was a court case a few years back for the exact same thing, I think, and the court favored the pool facility, not the nursing mom. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

C'mon, no food or drink are allowed because of messes. She's not gonna squirt everywhere :)

I really hate when people throw out the whole nursing mom thing like it's a free pass to do whatever they want.

Do whatever they want? Like, nurse? LOL 

American Citizen --- 15 years ago -

Good job Rachel,you kill me :P
0 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Hey, I understand where the pool is coming from. It's food and it's bodily fluids. The eating area has couches and chairs, why couldn't she have just gone there?

I have seen (not here ) people spouting off about
how they should be able to do anything they want because they are nursing; ie "I broke the
law but I shouldn't be arrested because I am a
nursing mom!"

I mean, the mom wasn't discriminated against,
she was asked to go to the food area or the locker room. Not leave the facility, not stop nursing at all, just go to an appropriate place to nurse.

I could see the indignation if she had been told to leave the facility or nurse in the restroom or cover up, just move somewhere else. Just because you are breastfeeding doesn't mean you get to whip it out wherever you are, rules still apply to you and your bountiful food giving boobs. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

I'm just saying, I used to take my son swimming at the pool here (Bitburg). Occasionally, I would have to get out to breastfeed my daughter. I couldn't go anywhere else, cuz I had to watch him at the same time. My husband was deployed, so I was by myself, meaning no one else to keep an eye on him. Luckily this was off-base, since Germans do not care about such things. BTW, there were also women giving bottles to their babies there (maybe formula, maybe breastmilk, IDK). Not "bodily fluids", but still "eating" by the pool.

Can you blow your nose into a tissue by the pool? Can you drink water, thus possibly exposing your saliva to the area- this is about as much exposure as might happen with breastfeeding. Silly. Basically, someone got uncomfortable with the idea, and tried to find a rationale to support their own personal feelings. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

Sorry motherof2, not trying to get off subject on your thread. My experience was no one gave me a hard time anywhere I breastfed, here or in the states. If it was convenient for me to go to the car or somewhere else, I would. But often that didn't work, as I was in Arizona in the summer with my first.

Here, people were especially helpful. I once went outside of a museum cafe to feed my daughter. It was a bit cold but we had a blanket so no biggie. The guy working there made a point to come out and tell me to come inside, that it was fine, and too cold to be outside. I have heard many people here in Europe having similar stories, but that's off-base.

I had a friend here with older children. When her kids were home, I offered to go in the other room to feed the baby. She said no, she wanted them to understand that that's what breasts were actually for: feeding a baby, not just for men to ogle at, LOL. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Well then it needs to be an issue of one parent dealing with two kids, not a breastfeeding mom being discriminated against. Discrimination would be "stop doing that or leave", not "Feed your kid in the food and drink area, please". 

WOW! --- 15 years ago -

So... Im one that nurses everywhere i go. I do use a cover. I will always use a cover. I do recommend the lady on RYS. Mod Momma stuff. Ive never given it much thought about others nursing in public EXCEPT the ones who didnt cover up. I did not need to see all her goods. Now as a nursing mother, i see why she did it. I wouldnt and wont, but whatever. I had a hard time with it too. My first time i did it, i did it in the bathroom. I wont ever stoop to that level again. The first time i did it in public, at the bx, i lost nerve and almost started crying. I go over by the Cafe where the hotel is. Its nice and quiet. Also in the big chairs in the book store. As long as you are supposed to be there, you can nurse anywhere on Federal property. 

Twinmama --- 15 years ago -

I think nursing in public is fine. I'd prefer it if I can't see major boobage though. A cover is great. Or I've known ladies that can nurse without one and not show anything.

I was friends with a lady whose husband is Security Forces. I ran into them one day at the BX when I bought a nursing cover. He told me the other day ( this was in May) he wrote someone up on indecent exposure because she was walking around the BX with both boobs out, nursing her infant. He said that on base, a mother has to be sitting and covered up. I never heard this rule, does anyone else know anything about it? 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

Never heard of it, but I'm not surprised... we once had to put up a privacy fence at a base stable because the general's wife was driving by and saw a horse pee.

Also, I'd like to say that moms nursing on the furniture in the BX don't generally bother me nearly as much as the roving bands of teenagers hanging all over everything!

And lastly, if she was feeding, then why were BOTH of her breasts out? That's just begging for attention, not fulfilling a need for the baby. 

Brittney --- 15 years ago -

I know whom your referring to I have seen her in the baby section feeding without a cover. There is a rule signed by General Dillion that you can breastfeed in public on base but you must be covered.

As for me I nurse with a cover in the furniture department, the food court etc. My feeling is that they should have a room somewhere for breastfeeding at the BX. I mean as much as they promote and encourage breastfeeding over here.

I do know that there are several organizations trying to get a room but the BX has said that they can't build something for a specific group. So I think it got put on hold go figure.

Another trick is to wear 2 shirts. What I do is wear a camisole or tank top underneath my regular top. Then I put on my cover to nurse, pull up my regular top, pull the tank top down and nurse. Voila you can't see no skin in the back or anywhere :) 

ashml --- 15 years ago -

i don't mind public breastfeeding and I respect the life it brings a baby. BUT be mindful of other people cover at least the breast showing because I perfer to not have my two year old point and say ohhhh wat that LOL . Just me though (but I won't say nasty comments to you I just hope someone would respect that if they are in a family oreinted place with kids) 

a2824059uu --- 15 years ago -

I swear that aquatic center thing is an urban legend,

It is. This was going around (at a different base) when my daughter was a newborn, she's now 16.

For people that say they don't want to have to "explain" it to their children...it's a breast! You're not explaining why a couple is having sex for crying out loud! And as others have said, it's perfectly natural. Americans need to stop sexualizing everything! I truly don't see what is so difficult to explain to a child. You tell them there are bottle fed & breast fed babies and explain the difference. Your child should not be gawking at anyone...breastfeeding or not. Good grief!

BTW, mine were both bottle fed. I have just NEVER understood the debate on breastfeeding in public. 

MAD4EUROPE --- 15 years ago -

C'mon, no food or drink are allowed because of messes. She's not gonna squirt everywhere :)

OMG...I was trying to read the rest of the posts but for some reason I can't.........LMAO! 

MAD4EUROPE --- 15 years ago -


For people that say they don't want to have to "explain" it to their children...it's a breast! You're not explaining why a couple is having sex for crying out loud! And as others have said, it's perfectly natural. Americans need to stop sexualizing everything! I truly don't see what is so difficult to explain to a child. You tell them there are bottle fed & breast fed babies and explain the difference. Your child should not be gawking at anyone...breastfeeding or not. Good grief!


YES! It's "mommy's sippy cup"! And like I stated earlier, it's completely natural. It is quite amazing at the things we do tolerate in public and see as normal but BREASTFEEDING...OMG....OMG! Not a boob! lol 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children
help
kmc

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground