Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Military Star Card, club card, blah blah blah

who's talking here?

anne 2
GaryKenyon 2
tonya 2
Melinda 1
Kristen 12
CMS 2
Jen04 4
Atticus Finch 2
smack4u 1
Falfurrias 1
Buckeye2go 1
EuroMaker 2
a3394358uu 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

annoyed by this

you get a discount for being a club member

you now can only use SOME coupons on the AAFES flyers if you use your star card

BOTH involve MANDATORY credit card.......

so, we tell folks get rid of credit cards, yet you should keep not ONE but TWO open so you qualify for discounts..........WTH?

TICKS ME OFF

why can't we just pay for club membership annually if we want to? NO CREDIT CARD, I don't WANT YOUR CREDIT CARD darn it........it is not a great idea to have a boatload of credit cards anyhow, seriously, this is going against any good financial advice........ 

smack4u --- 15 years ago -

Heaven forbid give the exchange advice... they might get a wild hair up their ..... and decide to raise prices because their not getting enough pigeons to bite on the offer. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

two things, the coupons, if anything, should say something like for example

$15.99 normal price

$13.99 this week for non STAR card purchases

$11.99 for Star card purchase, but, instead NO DISCOUNT AT ALL for 'specials' that are running for everyone else

way to discriminate against people who don't like to run up credit cards

and the club, well, they are not even AAFES and you can only get discounts if you belong, that is FINE, fair too, but if I want to be a member I should not have to have you on my credit status report

THIS is a blessing in disguise anyhow, nothing that they serve at any of these damned places is good for me, but, is still unfair and kinda jacked up 

Jen04 --- 15 years ago -

I don't see the big deal because lots of stores do this. Target gives you an automatic 5% discount on your purchase if you use your card 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

but they are a business, they are trying to make money OFF OF US by us using their card and excluding those that don't drink the kool aid...........they always tell us that AAFES is there as a service, whatever..........and no discount AT ALL is just messed up......... 

GaryKenyon --- 15 years ago -

You just posted that they were giving people a discount, albeit not as large of one if you were using your Star Card.....

And for the club, they cannot make you get a credit card. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

no, they are NOT giving everyone a discount, you cannot even USE the stupid coupon without charging your purchase on a Star Card

the club told me that you cannot be a member without their credit card=period

to get discounts or the freebies at the club you must be a member 

tonya --- 15 years ago -

Im with u service really wth?! 

tonya --- 15 years ago -

Im with u!!
service really wth?! 

Buckeye2go --- 15 years ago -

Okay...so the whole deal with the credit card requirements is that companies hope people will rack up charges, and in turn interest charges, adding to their profits. However, this is very easy to eliminate by only purchasing what you would purchase with cash on the card. Then as soon as the purchase is posted to the credit card, the full amount is paid off. Hence, you get the discount without the finance charges; you out smart the credit card company so to speak.

Of course having a ton of open credit cards or credit card debt can be damaging and lead to bad financial issues. However, credit scores, in some cases, can be helped by keeping a card and paying balances off monthly. This proves to creditors, such as those who offer mortgages, that you are a trustworthy borrower and you will do all in your power to pay back borrowed money. Whereas someone without any credit standing could be seen as a liability as there is no proof that the person is responsible enough to handle credit. Plus, those that are responsible with credit can benefit because they will be more trustworthy and could be given lower interest rates with items that require credit; houses, cars, education.

It all depends on self control and making smart decisions. If a person can't control their spending, then clearly credit cards are not a good idea. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

It is not only about self control..........we NEVER carry a balance but your credit score will look worse if you have MANY open lines of credit. If I am going to have an open line of credit it will be one that EARNS me something like points/miles/cash back not some lame O card like these

I know, I know, if I want the discount get the card

and I KNOW they make tons of bux on people who don't pay them off, but so sad that when it comes to 'specials' and promos they exclude people................ 

anne --- 15 years ago -

we have had a star card forever and i just dont use it. i harly ever go to the bx so the special offers and stuff really dont bother me that much. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

see, if i did not use it, it would be canceled, no point in having it 

EuroMaker --- 15 years ago -

Places like Target that offer a discount for using their card don't just do it because they want you to rack up charges. Target does this because they have a deal with the credit card processor that allows them not not pay the processing fees. This allows Target to look like they are doing you a favor, when what they are really doing is passing on their savings to you. Which is a favor in of itself. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

AAFES could still give me the same coupon discount if I paid cash for my pizza as they give a Military Star Card user 

Jen04 --- 15 years ago -

I still don't see the problem. If you want the coupon so bad, get the damn card. Otherwise get over it. It's no different than your cards giving you cash back or points towards hotels or flights. They are allowed to give incentives to their cardholders. 

Atticus Finch --- 15 years ago -

If you want the coupon so bad, get the damn card. Otherwise get over it.

Hisssssss.....Hiss........

(Sorry, couldn't resist!) 

a3394358uu --- 15 years ago -

My advice for the Star Card is do NOT get one! I used to work AAFES customer service and I have seen how they mess with people. AAFES in general messes with people, but the people in Dallas at the star card customer service center are a bunch of idiots. I've seen them take people's tax return money on an account that was already paid off and closed. Then when they call to get their money back it's a total pain in the butt. So they get frustrated and come to the store and we have to get it fixed for them. Besides that it just puts more money in AAFES pocket because most people carry a balance and have to pay them interest. They want people to sign up for the star card and the star card mastercard so badly that they actually give a $10 bonus to the associates for every person that they get to sign up for the master card or star card. It's a racket. At least in the states you can price challange at aafes if it is cheaper somewhere else, here they know that you are stuck if you want American products. One day I wanted a 6 pack of tonic water and when I went to take it off the shelf I noticed the price was $8. Really!!?? Went and got it at the commissary instead and it was only like $2.50. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

They are allowed to give incentives to their cardholders.

pretty soon the discounts IN AAFES on things on sale will only be available to Star Card Holders.............

the flyer won't apply to everyone, only people using that charge card 

GaryKenyon --- 15 years ago -

I don't get what you are compalining about. A few posts up you mentioned that an item was on sale already.

You are still getting the item on sale, just not at as a big of a discount if you used your Star Card.

Apples and oranges. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

I agree with Jen... if you want the discount, get the card. If it is not worth it to you to have the card in order to get the discount, then don't get it.

We have one. It has a zero balance. There have been a few times when there has been a really good deal, so we used it, then paid it off at the end of the month. 

Melinda --- 15 years ago -

I'll use it for gas occasionally. When they do those 20 cents off promos etc. 

EuroMaker --- 15 years ago -

I think the point being made is that AAFES is supposed to be here to help us. Instead of helping us, they help themselves. Using the MS card gives AAFES bigger profit. They offer a bit more discount for people using MS because it costs AAFES less to process it instead of one of the other major cards.

That being said if AAFES were really out to help people instead of profit at every opportunity they can they would give everyone the same discount.

Why give 5 cents or more off per gallon of gas only to people with MS card? How about lowering the price of gas for everyone. Especially since gas is going up in price so quickly. If AAFES can afford to give people the discount, which they obviously can, why don't they? One word: profit

AAFES is in business to make profit at our expense. Like it or not. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

Yeah, but you know they are going to say "blah, blah, we give back to the community, blah blah". The bottom line is that AAFES is still a corporation. They are still going to have the coporate view of the world, meaning that profit and the bottom line are the big picture. 

Falfurrias --- 15 years ago -

we NEVER carry a balance but your credit score will look worse if you have MANY open lines of credit.

Kristen, kudos on not carrying a balance! Having a large amount of available credit in relation to your debt balance is actually good for your credit score. See Myth 3 

Atticus Finch --- 15 years ago -

Debt is dumb and cash is king! Be weird!! 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

Gary, I typed -

e coupons, if anything, should say something

they SHOULD say this.......but they don't.........

but, instead NO DISCOUNT AT ALL

That being said if AAFES were really out to help people instead of profit at every opportunity they can they would give everyone the same discount.

*clap clap* thank you

How about lowering the price of gas for everyone. Especially since gas is going up in price so quickly.

yeah, let's just say there is a young airman who does not have good credit, does he need a gas discount any less?

Having a large amount of available credit in relation to your debt balance is actually good for your credit score.


MM USAA themselves told me it is NOT, actually their financial advisers told us especially when it comes to a home loan since having 4 cards open to spend 10k each on after the purchase of a home increases the risk of you being BEHIND on your mortgage.......

now, it has been several years since we bought a house but when we bought #2 they told us 6 months prior (we knew we were going to well in advance) to close ALL accounts with a zero balance and to continue to do so-- only keep 1 or 2 open and actually voluntarily reduce (by phone/writing) the limit amounts.......we had several open with 20-30k limits so we cut it down to 2 cards each and 'self reduced' our limits to much lower and our credit score climbed fast! 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

I did just read that article and it looks like reducing the available limit is only 'bad' if you reduce it and then use too much of it..........or if you have never been granted big available credit amounts. I think they probably told us to close and reduce because we had a lot of cards sitting around that had not been used in YEARS and had 30K and up limits 

Jen04 --- 15 years ago -

Ikea does the same thing with their family card. I have seen things a few times that were priced a few euro lower if you used your family card. I wasn't bothered by it at all, as I still think it's the same thing as a card giving 5% off a total purchase or giving you points/miles towards something else.

The way I see it, when you get points or whatever on the CCs that you use, you're only getting them because of the card you used or the hotel you stayed at. Not everyone is privy to that sale or incentive. If I wanted to earn the points, I would open up a card myself and then start to use the benefits. How is that any different than AAFES offering a promotional price on an item to star card holders? Both are offering a discount or other types of compensation for using your card. 

Jen04 --- 15 years ago -

If I am going to have an open line of credit it will be one that EARNS me something like points/miles/cash back not some lame O card like these

Or earns your a discount on a product? It's the same thing. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground