Whew, sorry bout the other thread, just had a lot of anger in me and needed to let it out. :P
Anyways, I'm probably opening another big can of worms here, but I've never been one to hold back what i think.
So! I was buying groceries today and while standing in line, I started a conversation with the lady in front of me. Has the conversation proceeded we eventually got to talking about our children and babysitters. At one point I said "he does a good job" And suddenly her face changed and it looked like I just shot her kitten. After a couple questions from her on the fact she proceeded to lecture me on the dangers of having male look after your children and that I should think more about the safety of my children.
I was in such awe that I couldn't even think of a thing to say has she lectured me. I didn't think that this kind of gender bashing still existed in this day. After I gathered my self, I started to explain to her what the media chooses not to tell her. The REAL statistics of abuse. That females are just has likely to harm your children has males, and that in the babysitter settings, females were actually more likely to harm a child them males. I lectured her for about 5 minutes, till I ran out of words to say, and then she surprised me by apologizing.
I'm still actually kind of pissed, but I wanted to know what you girls thought about the subject. Am i the only one "crazy" enough to use one? I promise you I wont lecture you about statistics unless you start spouting out incorrect ones. Then i might, :P. But What do you girls think, would you ever higher a male babysitter? If so, why? If not, why? If there are any male babysitter's out there that have an opinion on this I'd like to hear it. I'll ask my babysitter to post his opinion, but i wanna hear yours!
Has for me, I admit, i was kind of wary at first, so I ended up doing a lot of research and after i spent hours searching the internet, I was equally scared of getting a female babysitter. So I decided to give him a try, he worked with my husband and my husband trusted him, so why couldn't i? Ended up being one of the best sitters I've ever had.
Yes I would ! Does this woman not leave her kids alone with their Dad ? Yes, it's not as common as a girl babysitter but I know a lot of men that loves kids and there is nothing disturbing about it ?
I wouldn't...but that's just because my 9 year old is boy-crazy, and it would drive me up the wall to hear her talking about him for the next few months.
I actually prefer boy teachers...they put up with a lot less nonsense. But same problem with my daughter...the hormones have hit her pretty early. I prefer her to crush on boys her own age.
All that being said, I dont think a babysitter should be judged on their gender, but on the quality of their work. :)
I think that as long as I know the teen (whichever gender they may be) I wouldn't have a problem with it. Now if I was looking for a babysitter on a last minute basis I might be kind of iffy. It's all about your comfort level and I'm actually not comfortable leaving my kids with anyone I don't know well.
well male babysitters are rare in fact, but from what i was told by my father they where more reliable than females and my dad after so many female babysitters doing aweful things to us said screw it and hired a nanny who social services contacted 24/7 due to past issues with the female babysitters on base
I had never used a male sitter before we came here. For hubby's Christmas party last year we didn't know any sitters because we hadn't been here long. Our friends offered to let us bring our kids to their house to stay with their sitter. I trusted their judgement, they had used him many times in the past and he was a good kids. My son loved it, he thought it was the coolest thing ever to have a guy babysitter.
Just to stir the pot...You know that there are more cases of abuse (physical, mental, and sexual) from one's own family male or female. There is no right answer just a personal preference. For myself I have never had a babysitter or family member watch my child for where I wasn't within a yelling distance. That is my preference, I, as the father, have been watching our son for the last 6 years. I have even worked the graveyard shift for 5 of those 6 years so I could be there to watch him. Yes, I have taken jobs that I'm over qualified for, but my son was safe. I'll make up for it later when I feel that he can take care of himself, or at least defend himself.
To sum things up, know the background of your sitter. Don't jump into a last minute decision do your homework, and plan ahead. If something would happen to my wife and me at the same time, we have already done our homework and have 2 last minute sitters in mind. (adults)
I personally would have a hard time letting a male teenager watch my son, being one myself at one time (long ago) I know how mischievous they can be.
wow, it is amaizing to me to see that there are still so many stupit ignorant
people out there.If one does not want a man to watch there children then this is up to them
but to acuse male babysitters of abuse or anything else simply because there male, that is to me discriminating to the fullest extent.i hope she has no sons.she is insulting every male babysitter and there parents.
just my opinion
An old (x-friend) told me once that she would take her child out of the class if the teacher was gay. I was shocked and told her so to which she said "Would you be comfortable with your daughter going to a lesbian teacher?" I said "Yes, because they could very well be straight but like my little boy!" That shut her up...seriously... people are so ignorant.
Let's try not to attack eachother now...this is all a matter of opinion and personal comfort levels. Everyone is allowed to share and shouldn't have to worry about being judged by others who respond!
The only person I trust as much as myself and my husband with our 3 children is my brother in law. He came to help out when I was pregnant with our 3rd child, helped my husband get the 2 older ones ready for school for the first trimester while I was sick in bed, (including doing a 6 year old's hair in ponytails, lol) He helped with snacks, homework, knew their schedules to a T, how to keep them following our family rules and still have fun with them. After our youngest daughter was born, he came for another visit to help out and she took to him instantly. He is a kind generous person and I think kids can get a feeling for a caretaker and that comfortable sense is what makes them a good babysitter. I would never make a choice based on gender, that just makes no sense as to who a person really is on the inside.
Well Yvonne, I said I'd give my opinion so here I am.
Well has a male in the child care industry I will tell you that I do face a lot of discrimination. Most of it isn't open like the women you met at the store though. Most of it generally comes when I have been talking to a person through e-mail for a little bit and the second they find out I'm a male, they stop e-mailing me. Some are "nice" enough to tell me that they would rather not have a guy watching their kids, I respect that, at least they let me know. Most just don't answer.
Its kind of frustrating at time, but I like to look at the positive side of things. So for me its been kind of a blessing in disguise. Because of the stereotypical image, I find that I have to do everything perfectly. From cleaning the house after the kids go to bed, making up bedtime stories, playing silly games like sword fights with boys and tea parties with girls, even singing a grumpy kid to sleep sometimes. Stuff that most babysitters wouldn't do, I find that I have to do (not that I mind doing it at all) to keep my job and my customers. So if anything, I think its made me better at what I do.
One thing that I do want to point out to all parents out their, is that ANYONE could be a possible abuser, not just males or strangers. I'll tell you a story that kind of stuck in my heart.
About a year ago, I was sitting for a family's six year old son. Everything went well, he was fussy when I made him brush his teeth and clean his room before he went to bed, but other then that he was a nice kid. So the parents come home around 11 and ask me how everything went, I told them everything was Ok and that he was sleeping in his room. A few minutes later the boy comes out of his room, he woke up from us talking, so his parents asked him how he like me babysitting. The boy answered in the half tired, half whimpering voice that people find so adorable and said "He make me do stuff I didn't want to do.". I literally saw the father's expression change in seconds and I really though I was gonna get punched. So I told them to wait a sec and ask him what I made him do, so they did and the boy said that I made him brush his teeth and clean his room. They quickly apologized to me and gave me a little extra for the misunderstanding.
I wasn't mad about it, but It got me thinking about it. If I were a female, it wouldn't of been anything for the boy to say that. HECK, even if I did abuse the kid and I was female, the parents probably wouldn't of been any wiser. But because I was male, it sparked instantly in there mind that I was doing something wrong.
The gender bias doesn't bother me has much has the fact that if I was female, I probably could have kept abusing the child and the parents would of never known because they didn't listen to the child.
So, the point of the story is, PLEASE, parents for the sake of your child, listen to them and ask questions. Believe me, I've worked with children long enough to know that if you talk to them, they will talk to you all day long. It doesn't mater WHO you have babysitting. A male, female, grandmother, grandfather, friend, whoever, doesn't matter. LISTEN to your child, they will tell you if anything is wrong. And follow that wonderful motherly instinct that you all have, If something feels wrong, its possible that it is and you should probably look into it.
Wow, that was a lot longer then I expected it to be! I hope you all understand a little more about male babysitters and what we deal with. If you have any questions feel free to ask, I worked in the CDC at Offutt AFB for 2 years and I've taught proper parenting classes. Yvonne, say hi to the girls for me, and tell Mike he's to getting old to be playing ball, though he's a lot faster then he looks for a guy in his 30's!
I have no issues with a male watching my kids... as long as I know the person, feel I can trust the person, I will let them watch my kids... but I ALWAYS have my kids meet the person too because if they aren't comfortable around them, I will not leave them with that person, male or female...
Joshua... how long have you been in the childcare business? do you do this full time or just whenever???
I've actually been working with children since i was 13, I come from a family of 6 children so being the second oldest, I always got tagged with babysitting for my younger brothers and sister. Joined the military at 18, didn't do much child care then because of military training and everything. But about 2 years after I got to my first station I decided I wanted to get back into it. So I babysat on and off for a while and eventually got a job at the CDC. Took a few of psychology and development classes in collage and the CDC asked me if I'd like to teach parenting classes, I of course said yes. Did that for another two years, then got stationed in turkey, Got married had a son. Didn't do much in turkey because of the new child and pregnancy, didn't have much time for it. Now that I've come to Germany, I have a lot for free time, so I'm getting back into it. Been babysitting here for about a year, mostly to coworkers and good friends. But I'm trying to reach out further because its hard to find jobs.
Work keeps me busy so I mainly babysit on the weekends (and mornings in cases of emergency). So kinda part time, My son comes with me whenever I have him for the weekend, so he enjoys the children to play with.
Haha, so there is my story, time for me to go to bed!!
oh someone recommended me to you but the plans ended up changing huh, yeah I have a son too and I would perfer a male for a boy just because they tend to have more fun, alot of female babysitters don't do the running around and stuff with little boys and especially my 14 month old needs the energy drain LOL...i really don't care the gender as long as they don't touch my kids inappropriately ANYONE can do it and I had to grow up in a life of abuse from family members so it isn't just strangers that do that...keep that in mind guys
I dont let anyone that i dont actually KNOW watch my daughter, so yes, i would let her be watched by a male if i knew and trusted him. I would not see an ad for a babysitter, meet them once and trust them with my daughter, male or female.
Thanks for responding josh! Marie said she can't wait to hear another story and DH said he wants to go to the shooting range on Saturday, said he'd talk to you at work today bout it.
Michelle, I don't think they were attacking you for your choice, i think they were talking about the lady at the commissary.