I don't understand why it hasn't been done yet. I understand privacy, but it's not like those egocentric people who fear their genetic info might get abused have some sort of super genes that will sell like hot muffins on the DNA black market... How can you actually be against it? Shoot, I don't want the IRS to know how much money I spend on tampons every year, where's MY privacy there? Of course it's about money, but imagine all that money the government could save in the longrun. Less investigations, less court trials...
Sorry, I have no desire to have my privacy invaded because 'someday' it might be necessary to identify me.
What would be next? George Orwell would be proud of DNA registrations.
Now, having said that, if you are an honest person, and don't have any reason to hide, then being in a DNA registry should not be a problem. My problem is not with the DNA database itself, but rather what doors would be open to further privacy invasions.
Would you mind sharing what door you are afraid might open?
Do you know how many times sperm is found on murdered children or women, and for years no arrests can be made? So how is *your* urge to remain anonymous more important, if realistically, it WOULD save lives?
I'm talking about a registry that is supervised in a way that it can ONLY be used to identify criminals.
If you disagree, and your child went missing, but they would be able to tell you who kidnapped it via a database, you wouldn't want to know? Because you stick to your guns and don't want to invade people's privacy, right?
Fran -- I am going to refrain from any further comment. You asked a question. You gave your opinion. You are entitled to it. Did I say your opinion was wrong? Did I attack your opinion? Did I say anything at all that was not civil? Was I rude in any manner?
Now, ask yourself the same questions.
Your discussion title asks about being up for a debate. It looks more like you want an argument. I'm not going to participate in that.
So while the criminals are getting caught via DNA what happends to those who are innocent and the DNA was planted on them(hair cigarrete..)INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY ?
Ok, I guess I should mark all rethorical questions, to indicate that they were, rethorical.
I actually do respect people for saying they disagree, I was just wondering for what reasons?
I gave a scenario and asked a rethorical question, how is that rude? Did I say " your opinion is wrong"? I asked questions, and if you imply abything into them, thats YOUR interpretation.
While it would be good for crimes out there; the invasion of privacy is being risked out.
We already have big brother messing in our stuff more then we need too. what is next, everyone needs to be chipped to ensure that you are purchasing correct foods? Oh...you can't do that you don't have the correct tat on your hand for that one.
Why should my rights and privacy be effected. I haven't done something wrong.
Also, there is a difference between the human body and a check book.
this is one thread that I hope to bow out. It doesn't seem like a debate. I agree with Joftaa on this.
Ok, I guess I should mark all rethorical questions, to indicatete that they were, rethorical.
A rhetorical question is one that does not require a reply. You asked for replies, so there was no reason to think your question was rhetorical.
You did not come out and say my opinion was wrong, instead you made remarks such as 'sticking to my guns.' You indicated that because I did not agree with you that my opinion was invalid. That is the way I perceived it. I apologize if I was wrong about that.
If you want to have a debate, that is fine. What you were doing did not appear to be a debate.
You seem to have a thing for sperm. You've mentioned it in two different posts. You even asked What if it would only apply to sperm? Your comments suggest that the hypothetical DNA database would be for men only. That is unless you know of any women that have started producing sperm. Good luck with having a male only DNA database. Hypothetical or not.
You seem to be suggesting that women are not criminals. Your first post used the word 'everybody' for being in the database. In the same post you spoke of rapists. I have not seen too many female rapists.
You seem to have another issue on your mind other than a DNA database. It seems to be an issue about men.
By the way, my guess is $575 for tampons a year. Am I close?
Now THAT was rude, besides you contradicting yourself...
Why does one thing have to lead to another? Why do people automatically assume that it wouldn't stop with just that?
JOFTAA I wasnt even refering to anyone in particular, hence the *you* And above comment was addressed to Dakotacowgirl.
I don't have a thing for sperm, most child molesters just happen to be male, and thats the evidence they leave. And no, I was neither abused nor violated in any other way.
I understand nobody wants to carry around a GPS tracker, neither do I, but why do you assume that?
Mhh, I asked daisy, after I acknowledged she made a valid point, what she thought if it would only apply to sperm. Didn't think of that one before. We posted at the same time
BTW, Freud would be proud of you. Thanks for the psycho analysis lol, but not even close JOFTAA. Are you used to being the center of attention, that's why you take posts that aren't even directed at you as offensive? Why do you say you refrain from an "argument", but then don't? Please stop nit picking at things.
BTW, Freud would be proud of you. Thanks for the psycho analysis lol, but not even close JOFTAA.
Not analyzing. Just asking. I'm not the one who thought of the sperm only database.
How about hair folicles? How about skin? How about mouth swabs? There are many ways to go about getting DNA. Since gender can be determined with DNA, why sperm?
My point with the sperm was that it is the EVIDENCE left by a possible molester. I get that hair on a child can be from the own father who is innocent, I do, so yeah, I understand doubt about that.
I agree with daisy, hair can be planted. You lose about 100 hair a day, so of course that's a tough call. Spit, I'm not sure on that one. You did mean both left as evidence, right?
As far as sking goes, skin found underneath fingernails usually means the victim tried to defend itself. I know there's also the chance of some sort of more "active" love making that could cause that, so again not 100% sure. 95% though.
I meant left as evidence, yes. If the attacker puts his lips on a body, there will be saliva. Skin falls off of the body, as well. Sweat can also be transferred. I am no forensics expert, but I do know that sperm is only one way to find someone with DNA.
We seem to have shifted from your original question. My answer to that is still the same. Once the door is opened for one kind of database, we have started a ball rolling. If you give an inch, they will take a mile.