depends on the age of the child. If it's a toddler or infant maybe. I guess you could consider it a form of neglect. i think I'd rather have a child suffer from obesity than malnutrition though.
Yes. It sucks that that is what you would have to do to get some parents to provide their children with better food and guidance, but that's how it is. There is a part of the population that will not do something, even if it is right, unless forced.
abuse? I would say that is really diminishing children that are REALLY abused.......people use the word abuse too lightly.....
it really annoys me....a child who is beaten and raped by a parent is abuse....or locked in closets and that horrific stuff you only read about and surely don't want to see
neglect maybe
not saying it is not a bad thing to do but ABUSE? no
I think it should. But I also think smoking around a child is abuse too. Both will give them shorter lives that are not their own choosing but the choice of an adult who KNOWS better. All my own opinion.
Just because there is worse definition of the word, does not diminish the other definitions because it is not as bad. Just as someone who is verbally/emotionally abused vs someone who is physically abused, doesn't mean that person who is verbally abused has it way better.
I think it should. But I also think smoking around a child is abuse too. Both will give them shorter lives that are not their own choosing but the choice of an adult who KNOWS better.
Just because there is worse definition of the word, does not diminish the other definitions because it is not as bad. Just as someone who is verbally/emotionally abused vs someone who is physically abused, doesn't mean that person who is verbally abused has it way better.
bit is over feeding a child really ABUSE? I think it is neglect, lack of education, or laziness......it is not ABUSING where verbal and mental abuse are willfully trying to hurt their child
Failure to properly provide and care for a child in your charge is either neglect or abuse. The degree of the depravity relegates the name (abuse vs. neglect). -A 100lb 7 y/o may be neglect. A 150 lb 9 y/o may be abuse. I think it should be relative to the physical damage to the child (diabetes, heart problems, etc.) and how far off the growth charts the child happens to be.
It is abuse. When you see a 10 yr old that is 115 lbs and now has kidney failure from diabetes caused by the obesity you will say abuse. That child now has to endure needles for insulin several times a day and a needle the size of a straw for dialysis 3 times a week. All because McDonalds was more convienent. This is not something that happens overnight.
The biggest problem is not what you call it, but what you do about it. What is the punishment? Would putting the parent in jail help the situation? That would likely leave the child in foster care...what if the parent was doing a good job in all other aspects? Difficult.
I responded first thinking more along the lines of placing the blame on the parents, and speaking out- calling them on the way they are neglecting to properly care for their child. Kinda like, as a society, if we voiced these opinions, then there would likely be a reduction. This has happened with smoking around children. Though some people still do it, the fact that it has become unpopular and frowned upon has stopped a lot of people. Public opinion can be strong.
I think they better also look at what they are offering for school breakfasts and lunches too which are 2 of 3 of the kids meals these days.
I am NOT saying the parents are not to blame, but if you look at it, the word abuse to me is strong. I would think that some authority should get involved, teach parents how to buy better food, etc.
The fact is that poor people eat crummier food because the USA makes 'good food' more expensive. That is not all of it, the kids need to be active, etc.
A broke parent=bad food 2x a day at school and bad food for dinner. Either that or the good food takes a long time to prepare and the babysitter won't. Possibly parent has 2 jobs or work a crappy shift so the kids have TV as a babysitter.
I am STILL not saying it is ok.....at all. Don't a lot of these kids end up coming from single parent households? I don't know, but the ones I have seen on TV did.
I think this is where we are seeing such a problem these days.
Not that there were not broke people before, but I remember TV dinners as we called them as being something 'special'==I would think that was because it was more $$ per serving to buy. Now in some cases is is less and is SURELY easier. If your 10 year old is making his own dinner, giving them a can of raviolis or a TV dinner to make is easier than telling them to make up something healthier but that takes better cooking skills.
YES, everything I said can be contradicted, overcame, but, the issue is that it isn't. Maybe restrict what KINDS of food can be purchased with food stamps?
I think the definitions of obesity need to be more clearly defined for kids, before we start looking at obesity overall as abuse.
Example: my son is 9, and 90 lbs. Looking at him, you would never know. He is solid, and not chubby like you would think. But we get letters home from the scool who do a bmi measurement and declare him obese. We take him to the doc, who says he isn't. Rinse and repeat each time a letter comes home.
But if you want do declare obesity as abuse, I really think it needs to be more than a generalized term.
Is it child abuse? No,i believe it is more ignorance.Why should we punish junk food raised parents who have never been taught,not even at school or have seen anyone set good dietary examples for them.That wouldn't be fair.
Let's take the poor aspect out of this conversation. Let's say it is a military family with obese kids. I have seen my fair share of overweight kids in the military. How should that be treated? They have access to plenty of education, healthcare, and the money for healthy food. So what do you do in those situations?
I really don't want this to turn into another poor people bashing thread.
I think the definitions of obesity need to be more clearly defined for kids, before we start looking at obesity overall as abuse.
agreed
Let's take the poor aspect out of this conversation. Let's say it is a military family with obese kids. I have seen my fair share of overweight kids in the military. How should that be treated? They have access to plenty of education, healthcare, and the money for healthy food. So what do you do in those situations?
I really don't want this to turn into another poor people bashing thread.
my apologies for it coming off as poor people bashing thread
I did not think I was bashing the people, but more bashing the fact that it costs more money and takes more time to prepare good meals.
Besides, I did say that 2x a day the SCHOOLS are feeding kids with lower incomes
BTW many military folk consider themselves poor. Their kids get free breakfasts and lunches at public schools. I have seen what the lunches are, they are not good nor nutritious.
I am not angry at you, Mojo, but I really was not poor people bashing.
HEll take a look around at all the OVER weight adults in our Military..To me it is a disgrace to the uniform. And sadly it is lots of higher ups getting away with it. PT is part of the job. As for the kids. I do think it is sad but you never know if that child had a med prob that cause them to gain. Don't be so fast to judge them or the parents. I was told last yr when I asked abotu why school lunches are so loaded with fat & Calories that they do this based on the WHOLE days worht of nurtients the child needs because for some kids this is the only meal they may get ( we were in the states)Which yes I feel for those kids but what about my child who will eat 3 good meals plus snacks and does not need a loaded lunch.. they don't care which is why we are packers.
Maybe restrict what KINDS of food can be purchased with food stamps? THAT is a GREAT suggestion. And like I said, obesity doesn't happen over night. These kids have had numerous school physicals, immunizations, sick visits and it is hard for me to believe a MD did not bring it up during the YEARS of these visits. Mojo- sounds like that school needs to be better educated. I wonder what their guidlines are? I'm betting they are not using a BMI scale. Or maybe a really outdated one. Sounds like you have a NFL player on your hands! I do agree parents should be given a chance and be educated. But, when do you draw the line? When do you say, ok, these parents have been educated so many times and the kid(s) are now facing these issues going into their tenage years. The longer these kids go without changing their lifestyle habits the harder it will be for them to adapt and make neccessary changes. I wish there was a better system. Does anyone know if Germany has a social system (not sure if that's correct lingo) in place for kids like this?
Let's take the poor aspect out of this conversation.
Lol, as part of a public forum, the public can and will state their own opinions. "Should childhood obesity be considered child abuse?".. I can see why "being poor" may have to do with this and it isn't for reasons that would be "bashing them" to talk about. Everyone knows junk food cost less than healthy food, pair that with less education and knowledge about healthier options and whatnot. Income bracket is a very valid aspect of this discussion. I wouldn't say it is their fault, but that side of the argument shouldn't be overlooked. However, it is also notable that families in higher income brackets are also guilty of allowing their children to become obese. Having a higher income does not necessarily mean they also had a better education or any education on nutrition and health, but they do have the means to buy healthier food, and should (hopefully) have a general idea of what is healthier based on the media and other outlets in today's society. I think for this reason, they should get more "bashing" than those in lower income brackets.
Very often in the not "poor" families, you may see kids that are not obese, but still have terrible diets and are in terrible physical condition. No one notices and the parents aren't concerned; their kids are fine, they're "skinny." But all the eat is sugar and soda.
Whether or not to hold parents accountable, how to define obesity, all these questions are symptomatic of the bigger problem. It is just how Americans view food and eating. We are all screwed up in this area- it is society-wide. All of that would have to change in order for there to be any real affect on children's eating and health.
their kids are fine, they're "skinny." But all the eat is sugar and soda.
my kid eats his fair share of sugar, that is for sure.........just finished up some cookies we had baked!......even more sugar......but he does balance it out with lots of veggies and fruit thankfully and is VERY active.....
I agree with Rachel. Americans have a really unhealthy relationship with food, rich or poor. I would venture to say that middle class or higher families are probably worse off in many cases, simply because they eat all the convenience food that is marketed towards busy families on the go and stuff. There isn't always a lot of time for a meal when both parents work, so those types of meals are appealing to a lot of people. But I also know that it doesn't have to be that way, that there are a lot of quick, healthy meal options out there, it just takes planning. But, too many families these days are over scheduled and running for hours.
yeah, I was just talking to *someone* about how my RICH sister in law's hubby finally hired them someone to cook for them..........but you can go to these specialty grocers on the way home if you have tons of money and buy some nice, prepared that day, good meals.......there was a place in AZ near my dad's that had good healthy stuff, and it was like carry out.......baked fish, steamed veggies, gluten free, etc etc........what was the name of it, I want to say A.J.'s and it is in a more affluent area......so if money is no object but you are in a hurry or don't cook, you do have more options--it seems at least to me, or they can have a cook, like she does now
*edited to add* her kids are SKINNY but her husband has become concerned since skinny kids CAN have high cholesterol, etc.....and they don't 'do' veggies, whole grains etc...mostly fried and prepared stuff
I think a lot of times people think they are buying something that's good for their child, because of the way it is advertised, but it just isn't. Some people just don't check the nutritions and stuff on the packages, and when the chocolate bar says "made with x% of milk and full of calcium", they think it's ok. Or fruit snacks that say "made with real juice" and so on. I understand that goes with a lack of education on food, but companies are just tricky and know how to get those that don't really know the difference of good vs bad food for their kids.
For example, I was talking to a woman recently, who has a 3 year old. She told me what a good eater she is, never complains about her breakfast, jsut always eats the whole thing: mini muffins or pop tart, and chocolate milk. Well, what kid would complain? Sheesh.
And another woman I know who was very excited that her 18 month old was eating so much: he ate five nuggets from McDonalds! It was great! He finished all of it and wanted more!
These to me are pretty common examples of how Americans feed their children, and it is FRIGHTENING.
mini muffins or pop tart, and chocolate milk. Well, what kid would complain? Sheesh.
Yep, every kid I know eats sugared cereal, toast with jelly, pop tarts, something like that for breakfast.....mine too a few days a week!
He has to eat oatmeal or grits (loves both anyhow) at least 3-4 days a week, the other days he LOVES frosted mini wheats with milk!! then there is a pop tart day......
When I look at syrup and waffles or pancakes, the cereal is better for him at least thank goodness!
I am a bad momma he gets pop tarts sometimes for sure........he would more often if I let him too