Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

New car seat recommendation

who's talking here?

Mojo 6
Rachel 1
Heidimomof3 5
Heather 1
Kristen 6
CMS 4
Amy 1
Motherof2 3
a1483471uu 1
nukatie81 1
NYgal 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

NYgal --- 15 years ago -

car seats 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

lol... I have a friend who isn't 4'9. She's not going to be happy to hear she has to ride in a booster seat. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Yeah at some point this has got to stop. Every year the requirements get more silly. My kid is ten and almost as big as me, I am not making the poor kid ride in a booster, and where would I even find one for a kid his size? 

Motherof2 --- 15 years ago -

I agree.. It's getting a little crazy. 

a1483471uu --- 15 years ago -

Dixon's three daughters, ages 6, 5 and 12 months, have all had extended stints in the rear-facing position. Her middle child, Mara, was rear-facing until age 3 and her youngest, Naomi, will be too. Meanwhile, eldest daughter Amber is in a 5-point harness seat and will be in a booster seat until she's at least 4 feet 10 inches, says Dixon.

"I'm 4 feet 10 and I don't feel comfortable when I sit in the backseat because of the way the strap hits my neck." says Dixon. "Until [Amber] is at least my height, I will keep her in a booster."


What kind of giant car does this woman have? I have a 4'11" 5th grader and the seatbelts in the rear of my van are actually too small for her. She has to ride in the middle in order to get a good seatbelt fit. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

Eventually someone has to use some common sense. At least these are "guidelines" and not law. 

Amy --- 15 years ago -

I was actually called a moron on my friends facebook page because I said that my almost 5 year old, and my 17 month old were both turned forward facing at age 1. Too each parent, their own!!! Personally, I think they need to leave it alone...next thing you know they will be recommending we put our kids in full body armor and helmets before we drive anywhere with them! 

Motherof2 --- 15 years ago -

Amy I was talked to the same way.. It's ridiculous the way some parents act. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Well I kept my son rearfacing past a year, but I am all for keeping the little ones turned around. If there is an impact, their spines are more protected in a rear-facing position. However, I don't generally offer that kind of advice to a friend unless they ask. People are quick to assume it's me judging them or something.

However, they keep raising the age and weight standards for older kids. Soon, we'll be driving in adult boosters. My son is bigger than a couple of adults I know, for christs sake. 

Heather --- 15 years ago -

NM 

Heidimomof3 --- 15 years ago -

The thing is this is about science. Okay you may think it is ridiculous but did you know that the number one killer of kids ages 1-14 is car wrecks? They kill more kids than murders! But you would try and keep them safe from a murder right?

Did you know in Sweden they rear-face to age 5 and have been since the 50's and they have maybe 1 kid die a year in car wrecks?

In America 4 kids die and 4000 are injured every day in wrecks where a properly used restraint could have prevented the death or injury. Children break their necks from forward facing too soon. Some survive it but they are the lucky ones and go through a lifetime of pain. The survivors are put back rear-facing even at age 2 b/c the parents see how much safer it is.

I love when I hear people say well I am 25 but only 4'10" so that means I need a booster?
It doesn't work that way. There is a HUGE difference between the bone development of a 10 yr old and that of a 25 yr old. At 25 you could handle the force of a seatbelt slamming into your soft organs at 200mph. At 10 you cannot and this can lead to loss of liver, spleen, punctures to lungs and even spinal damage leaving your 10 yr old dead or paralyzed.

So you think it is overprotective to protect them from the thing that kills and injures more children than anything else? I don't.

I personally choose to keep them as safe as possible if it means something as simple as keeping their seat facing the back until age 3.5 (which I do) and keeping them in a booster until age 10 or 12 (which I will do).

I am a car seat technician and have done extensive research including seeing the damage done to these children and pictures of their mangled bodies b/c their parents didn't want to be so over protective. I assure you there is nothing overprotective about wanting to keep your child safe and alive. 

Heidimomof3 --- 15 years ago -

Now that being said I would NEVER judge another parent for not choosing to do what I do. Amy I saw that conversation and actually replied back. I was really annoyed with that chick for what she said. Not cool.

I say the least you can do is reasearch it. If after reading the studies you still choose to follow the bare minumums then that is your decision.

Just don't break the law..... 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

Did you know in Sweden they rear-face to age 5 and have been since the 50's and they have maybe 1 kid die a year in car wrecks?

where do the kids put their legs? Just a question, not being a pain in the butt 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

and keeping them in a booster until age 10 or 12 (which I will do)


it is 4 foot 11 inches or age 12, whichever comes first......I think some kids are that tall at 10 but my 10 year old is not yet....he is 4'10" 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

But there is also the 5-step test, or somesuch.

How they sit, how the belt hits them, things that show that the child can physically sit in a safe way without the help of a booster.

That is why small adults are fine but children are not.

However, it gets frustrating when you are doing what is required based on current guidelines, and then it changes. Again and again and again. And the seat you just got is now "Not recommended", and yeah you turned the child around but now you should turn him back. Just too much. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

And Kristen, they usually just sit cross legged. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

for 5 or 6 hr trips? seems like it would end up making the child deformed or ruin their back........

I am so glad my kiddo is finished with that stage, it is confusing enough 

Heidimomof3 --- 15 years ago -

I know the laws in Germany. ;)

My son was rear-facing until age 3.5. He sat with his legs criss-crossed, over the back of the seat, off to the side or however he felt like putting them. He was much much more comfortable rear-facing then he is forward facing. He hates how his legs dangle and complains that they hurt. This isn't an issue rear-facing and children are much much more flexible.

An interesting fact. The number one injury to a forward facing child in a wreck is broken legs.

They will not be deformed or have ruined backs I assure you. They are more likely to suffer these issues from forward facing.

The thing is if people take the time to educate themselves properly on car seat safety then they will already know what is safest and the guidlines will alway be the same. Rear-facing will always be safest and the American Academy of Pediatrics has been saying this for over 20 years. We know children need to be in boosters until age 10-12 and again the AAP has been saying this for over 20 years.

So properly educating parents is the first step to making kids safer. ;) 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

He hates how his legs dangle and complains that they hurt

heck this happens to ME in airplane seats=feet don't touch COMPLETELY ergo flat so lower back ends up hurting......I end up using my carry on as a 'stool'

our kiddo is in a booster still (age 10) and depending on the car this is the case with us also--he sits in the center so that he can put his feet on the hump or his legs go numb but I cannot imagine him facing back at 10--I know that is not what is being proposed but can you imagine?

but at age 5 he would have been all squished up, 3.5 probably fine....... 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

We know children need to be in boosters until age 10-12 and again the AAP has been saying this for over 20 years.

I wonder why some states in the USA allow it -- seems silly since that would surely raise insurance claims and insurance is so high 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

Shoot... I still see kids not in seats in the states, or even buckled in. lol, my husband put the window lock on while we were in heavy traffic in Houston because I was going to say something to the idiot next to me.

My son was not comfortable facing the rear, and seems to be alot happier now that he is front facing. I can't imagine leaving him rear facing until almsot 4 years old. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

These are the guidelines when deciding if a child is ready to be out of the seat (beyond height/weight).

Five step test:

1. Lap belt fits low on the hips, touching the thighs, not the belly.

2. Shoulder belt crosses chest firmly without touching neck or coming off shoulder.

3. Bottom sits all the way at the back of the seat, where it bends, and doesn't slouch forward

4. Knees bend at the edge of the vehicle seat or beyond, and not before, and feet rest flat on the floor

5. Child can maintain this upright forward position 100% of the time without slumping or slouching, even when asleep. 

Heidimomof3 --- 15 years ago -

I know it is hard to imagie. I used to think the same thing. I quickly realized it really was not that big of a deal and adults think more into then the kids do. LOL. 

Motherof2 --- 15 years ago -

He sat with his legs criss-crossed, over the back of the seat, off to the side or however he felt like putting them.

That seems just as unsafe to me as front facing. What if you get hit from behind. His legs are going to get bent up and break just as easily as being front facing..

Either way, a serious accident is going to cause damage.. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

The Swedish stats don't lie. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

Did you know in Sweden they rear-face to age 5 and have been since the 50's and they have maybe 1 kid die a year in car wrecks?

Heidi, I'd be interested in seeing where you found this information? All I can find is that they wait until 3 or 4 and that if the US did the same, deaths could be reduced by 50%. Using those figures, there would only be 2 deaths per year in the US now.

I'm not disagreeing per se, but think maybe you exagerate a little? I'd be interested in seeing your reference. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

Five step test:

1. Lap belt fits low on the hips, touching the thighs, not the belly.

2. Shoulder belt crosses chest firmly without touching neck or coming off shoulder.

3. Bottom sits all the way at the back of the seat, where it bends, and doesn't slouch forward

4. Knees bend at the edge of the vehicle seat or beyond, and not before, and feet rest flat on the floor

5. Child can maintain this upright forward position 100% of the time without slumping or slouching, even when asleep.


I failed. I want my booster back darn it!

LOL, sorry, had to add some humor here. I really do fail at least two of those though. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

FYI, Sweden has this "Vision Zero" thing they've been doing for awhile now- redesigning their roads and whatnot to cut way down on fatal car accidents (unrelated to car seats). That is part of the reason their numbers are so low. Their goal is zero deaths from accidents by 2020. Pretty lofty ideal.

There are many factors to consider when you read a statistic. 

Heidimomof3 --- 15 years ago -

I will have to find the link, shoot google it. Google rear facing car seat in a rear facing wreck. A fellow car seat nerd friend was rear ended at a high speed and her daughter was rear facing and walked away! It is still much safer rear facing even in a rear end collision.

www.carseat.se has some wonderful info on rear facing! A fellow car seat nerd from Sweden created this site! His children were rear facing to age 5 and many others rear face to age 4-6.

It is not just about cutting down on deaths, but injuries as well!

I know the highways and stuff in Sweden are different and the driving is different but that doesn't change the way the body reacts in an accident and they do still happen there. 

nukatie81 --- 15 years ago -

I think for most kids it would be uncomfortable. My youngest was already too big to be rear facing for a long time. That was our deciding factor to switch him to front facing. My daughter went to a regular booster seat when she was 4 or 5, the kind that just sit on the seat. Those don't bother me because you can easily take those out and put them in any car...but I can't wait until my son is out of the toddler seat. He's already figured out how to unbuckle in one of his seats in one of our cars. Thank goodness he hasn't figured it out in the other car...yet. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground