Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Abolishing the Commissaries

who's talking here?

Mojo 1
Bob 1
Kristen 2
CMS 3
blackssmagic 2
Texan 1
Atticus Finch 3
smack4u 1
hokie 1
Falfurrias 5
EuroMaker 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Atticus Finch --- 15 years ago -

Key Committee: Whack Commissaries

Among the bills approved by the Senate Veterans Affairs Committee this week was the "Caring for Camp Lejeune Veterans Act of 2011" (S. 277), sponsored by Sen. Burr (R-NC), the senior Republican on the Committee. The bill would authorize VA health care for former military family members and veterans and certain family members stationed at Camp Lejeune between 1957 and 1987, when the water at the base is acknowledged to have been contaminated with carcinogens.

MOAA indicated its support for the bill and other pending measures in a letter to Committee Chair Sen. Patty Murray (D-WA) and Sen. Burr.

But that was before the committee voted unanimously, without notice or hearing, to fund the care by eliminating the federal subsidy for military commissaries and directing consolidation of all DoD commissaries and exchanges.

MOAA strongly opposes this sneak attack on the military benefit package.

First, the Veterans Affairs Committee has no jurisdiction over and no knowledge of DoD commissary and exchange systems, which are under the purview of the Armed Services Committee.

Second, they propose virtually dismantling the commissary system without any hearings or other effort to assess the adverse impact of such a dramatic cut to a core military benefit. There are good reasons why the Armed Services Committees, who actually understand the commissary and exchange programs, have ardently rejected similar proposals for the last four decades.

Third, they seek to poach DoD funds to pay for VA health care at a time when DoD personnel budgets already are under threat.

MOAA supports expanding VA care to cover Camp Lejeune veterans, but the Veterans Affairs Committee needs to find another way to fund it besides raiding the military commissary system.

Make no mistake, without the federal subsidy, military commissaries would eventually go out of business, as prices would have to rise, and savings to customers would be lost.

The commissary is one of DoDÂ’s most cost-effective people programs. Every dollar of the subsidy translates to nearly three dollars of benefit value to patrons (and considerably more than that for lower-grade enlisted families). Where else can the Pentagon get that kind of compensation bang for the buck? 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Where is this from? 

Atticus Finch --- 15 years ago -

Here 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

this just plays into the exchange's plans. they have been trying to get control of the commissaries for a long time. they have been able to influence prices without even having control. i could almost puke every time i hear that bull$h1t line: aafes here to serve you. 

smack4u --- 15 years ago -

Seems like someone brought up this commissary issue last year and everyone thought that was B.S. what that person was saying.

Don't try to take credit on this one AF. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

I thought the 5% surcharge was supposed to support the commisary system as a whole. I could have sworn I saw a propoganda/AFN commercial about that.

One more reason I'm glad to be returning to the US. 

Texan --- 15 years ago -

i can not wait to hit my HEB 

Atticus Finch --- 15 years ago -

Don't try to take credit on this one AF.

!elohssa em etiB 

EuroMaker --- 15 years ago -

!elohssa em etiB

!taht dnoces I 

blackssmagic --- 15 years ago -

funny you mention HEB, we would shop there every week vs driving to Lackland. To be honest they should only have tthe commissary in overseas locations. Stateside they just are not chaper plain and simple. By the time you drive to the base, pay the surcharge and tip the bagger it is cheaper to just go to your local store that is probably right around the corner. I hate the commissary with a passion and can not wait to move back to the states so that I will not have to shop at the BX/Commissay. 

EuroMaker --- 15 years ago -

I see so many people complaining about AAFES. I see fewer people complaining about the commissary.

Frankly, although AAFES is truly the devil, I have no problem with DeCA. And, when put into perspective with all of the other great things there are in Europe to experience, these small problems don't come close to making me want to go back to The U.S. Just my feelings. Your mileage will most likely differ. 

blackssmagic --- 15 years ago -

No I am saying they should only have commissaries overseas, there is NO benefit to using them stateside. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

Euromaker, I agree with what you are saying. All I was saying is that if this DOES go through, I would hate to be here for it. I'm going back to the states either way, as our tour is about over. I wouldn't leave just because of that, but it is nice that I won't have to deal with it. I hope this makes sense. 

EuroMaker --- 15 years ago -

CMS - I understand what you mean. It can be frustrating to see what you are used to, and enjoy, being picked apart one thing at a time. Especially when AAFES gets their hands on things.

AAFES is a corporate pig, desperately needing an overhaul. But, until someone has the guts to make that happen, AAFES will continue to rip off its customers.

On the other hand, as long as the customers of AAFES let themselves be ripped off, AAFES has no reason to stop the practice of doing so.

It's a vicious cycle. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

I agree... that's what I said when someone was talking about the price of dvds. As long as people are willing to pay $39 for a blueray, there is no reason for AAFES to charge less. My husband came home the other day with two new movies, so I sat down and showed him how much he could have saved on Amazon, and he could have gotten two more movies for the same price. It's silly when Amazon stuff arrives in like a week. 

Falfurrias --- 15 years ago -

No I am saying they should only have commissaries overseas, there is NO benefit to using them stateside.

I totally disagree with this statement. For a period of 5 years from the time I retired from the Military before accepting a job here, we lived just off my retirement. We would drive 100 miles round trip to the closest military base to do our grocery shopping once a month and still saved several hundred dollars on our grocery bill!

The problem I think is that most people are lazy shoppers rather than smart shoppers. The commissary by law cannot make a profit, so must sale items at cost. The 5 percent goes towards operating cost of the commissary (since the employees are paid in the GS, they are not part of the operating cost).

HEB has to make a profit to stay in existence, and the do this by charging more than cost. But to get customers in, they advertise sale items (lost-lead) that are below cost, then raise prices higher on other items to recoup. A good example is spaghetti sauce may be on sale, but the cost of the noodles that would go with it would be raised to compensate. They have to pay the store and workers (including baggers) out of the profits.

My wife was really good about shopping items at HEB that were on sale, but getting all the other items from the commissary. Plus, non food items in Texas are taxed at more than 6%, so you have to factor that in to the cost.

We saved a ton shopping this way, but even if we just used the commissary, our overall bill would still be lower than shopping everything at HEB.

Also, you do not have to use the baggers at the commissary. You can bag your own grocery, you just have to tell them. During that time, the only time we used a bagger, was if he/she was a young kid (we saw it as encouraging the young to work :)). 

EuroMaker --- 15 years ago -

The commissary can't make a profit? Really? If this is the case, why am I finding prices in our commissary that are equal to, or higher than the prices I find on the identical items in our grocery store in Florida? I'm not talking about a few items, some of the time, either. I am talking about a lot of items being equal to or more expensive at the commissary than at our neighborhood grocery store at home. I did some price comparison during my last trip to Florida because I was curious to see what my bill was like here vs. there.

There is very little, if any, savings at the commissary for a lot of items.

Don't get me wrong. I do agree that the commissary has a lot of excellent prices. Some way lower than back home. But, the total of what is being purchased is what needs to be considered, not just the prices on a few items.

Are the items here being marked up to make up for transportation, etc? I figured that would be part of the 5% surcharge. 

EuroMaker --- 15 years ago -

I suppose I found my own answer:
http://www.commissaries.com/documents/contact_deca/faqs/no_profit.cfm

Although commissaries collectively realize sales of about $5 billion per year, there is no profit generated on these sales.

By law, commissaries are required to sell goods at prices that are set at a level to recover the cost of goods, with no profit built into these prices. There are also very stringent legal controls on the ways that DeCA can use taxpayer monies that Congress provides to operate commissaries.

Because commissaries are prohibited by law from making profit on goods sold, and because of the stringent controls on use of funds provided for commissary operation, commissaries cannot use a lot of merchandising practices that commercial stores use routinely.

For instance, commissaries cannot "double" (or otherwise increase) the face value of coupons, commissaries cannot sell goods below cost to create a low price "image," commissaries cannot pay a "rebate" to patrons who return bags for reuse, or who use non-disposable cloth bags, and commissaries cannot donate money or products to an individual or organization, however worthy.


So, the prices can be higher than in The U.S. due to the expense of getting the food here. I doubt anyone here could do the job for less.

As I had said in a previous post, I have no problem with DeCA. It is AAFES that is the devil. 

Falfurrias --- 15 years ago -

As I had said in a previous post, I have no problem with DeCA. It is AAFES that is the devil.

AAFES is a different animal from the commissary, but I don't think they deserve all the bad raps they get.

They receive no government subsidy, so must operate strictly from what they make. Any monies they make above what it cost to operate are passed to MWR.

They also must pay to have their goods transported overseas, pay all the cost of operating here, include salaries of all employees (including host nation employees and their taxes/health benefits and such). They also operate in a lot of isolated and remote locations around the world to include areas of hostility. I'm willing to bet most of those operations are not money makers for them and the cost is has to be absorbed from other operations.

Personally, I think they could do a much better job with inventory selection.

In some cases, and depending on shipping cost, I am able to find items I want via the internet cheaper. I have the patients to waits for it - not a quality that seems to be very prevalent today! :) 

Falfurrias --- 15 years ago -

As I had said in a previous post, I have no problem with DeCA. It is AAFES that is the devil.

AAFES is a different animal from the commissary, but I don't think they deserve all the bad raps they get.

They receive no government subsidy, so must operate strictly from what they make. Any monies they make above what it cost to operate are passed to MWR.

They also must pay to have their goods transported overseas, pay all the cost of operating here, include salaries of all employees (including host nation employees and their taxes/health benefits and such). They also operate in a lot of isolated and remote locations around the world to include areas of hostility. I'm willing to bet most of those operations are not money makers for them and the cost has to be absorbed from other operations.

Personally, I think they could do a much better job with inventory selection.

In some cases, and depending on shipping cost, I am able to find items I want via the internet cheaper. I have the patients to waits for it - not a quality that seems to be very prevalent in others today! :) 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

I have the patients to waits for it - not a quality that seems to be very prevalent in others today! :)

and that would be how they make money

sometimes, I just don't get it at all

by the time it gets here via internet I probably won't need it, heck, maybe I don't need it anyhow at all.......see, I talk myself out of stuff pretty easily 

EuroMaker --- 15 years ago -

I'd love to see the balance sheet for AAFES.

"Any monies they make above what it cost to operate are passed to MWR. "

These operating costs include huge salaries, benefits, and incentives for executives of AAFES. Anyone who thinks that the people working for AAFES aren't making boat loads of money is being naive.

AAFES salaries 

Falfurrias --- 15 years ago -

$45K ain't crap for being an executive.

Hell, according to that website, Walmart executives get an average of 65K. I know one Walmart Store Manager in Corpus that makes 80K plus a year. 

Falfurrias --- 15 years ago -

by the time it gets here via internet I probably won't need it, heck, maybe I don't need it anyhow at all.......see, I talk myself out of stuff pretty easily

Don't even get me started on what is a "need" or a "want"! LoL. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

Don't even get me started on what is a "need" or a "want"! LoL.


zactly........if I have forgotten about it an hour later I probably did not need it

it is all about marketing and how we can have our minds bent into thinking we NEED sh*t.........if it were not AAFES getting the bux the first day the newest thing came out it would be someone else stateside 

hokie --- 15 years ago -

I think part the major part or point of the beast "AAFES" is being missed here. Some 15-17 years all the exchanges were suppose to merge as a single entity. That's why they came out with the Military Star credit card system.
Then problem development within the different exchanges with the major point being the share division of the profits to the respective services.
AAFES being the major exchange felt that they should be the head of the pyramid. So the Marine Corps Exchange system pulled out. Then the Navy system felt if the Marine Corps is pulling out so are they.
So end the idea.
Now AAFES comes up with this new BS...
The X store.
And X marks the spot.
Again AAFES at work driving to drive the train for the whole issue and to bring the commissary into the mix and the whole system into KAOS.
Stay tuned. 

EuroMaker --- 15 years ago -

$45K ain't crap for being an executive.


That is just the average salary. Did you look at the salaries below that figure?

$60k for an IT person. $60k for logistics.

And, I'm guessing you did not take benefits into consideration. The benefits are worth a small fortune themselves.

I hardly think the AAFES execs are under paid. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground