Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Security Deposit

who's talking here?

Mojo 1
Fran 1
Momof3 1
angel2009 1
Bob 3
Emma 1
CMS 6
blackssmagic 1
MAD4EUROPE 3
Cara fanciulla 1
seriously 1
theoriginaljd 1
Cloudless 2
Brasco 1
pinkie 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Emma --- 15 years ago -

Recently I was told that German landlords, by law, must keep your rental security deposit in an interest bearing bank account for the duration of your lease, and upon moving out, give you the interest. Is this true though or is it an urban legend? Is it 'law' or just 'recommended'? I've gotten conflicting information.

I know for a fact that my landlord doesn't keep security deposits in a bank account (they told me) so i'm looking for information as to my rights when we move out soon. I don't want to make an issue of something that I really have no right to make an issue out of.

btw, i've asked Housing and have yet to receive a straight answer, let alone what to do about it. 

angel2009 --- 15 years ago -

law since 1983 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

Here is a link with the exact law, so you can wave it in his face. He is required to put it in a separate, not his private account. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Yeah, my previous landlord was even awesome enough to show us the account statement. They are supposed to always do that. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

My friend who pcsed last Sept is STILL waiting on theirs to be returned. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

So I talked to my friend who lived in Bruchmuhlbach and left last September. They left their home in good condition, some things better than how they arrived. The owner/LL said he was broke and had no money to give them. They finally went through housing, housing contacted the LL, and he told them the same thing. As a matter of fact, one of the other houses he owns is being foreclosed on. Housing said there was nothing further they could do. So now my friend, who is in the states, is pretty much SOL. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

cms, if the landlord is broke and has filed for the german equilivant of chapter 11 there probably isn't a thing that can be done. even if the landlord put the money in an interest bearing account it would be in his name and open to creditors.

i know it sucks because the law screws your friend but it's also there to try to protect the landlord from ending up on the streets or costing the government money. 

pinkie --- 15 years ago -

From what I understand, it just needs to be separate from his other money, and he must give you the current interest rate that you would have incurred while renting his house. He doesn't HAVE to have it in a separate account, i think it can be under his bed..as long as he gives you the equal amount of interest at the end, and it's somehow kept separate..

though on your link it DOES say he MUST have it in a separate account...i think.. but that lawyer is in Munich, so I also don't know if the laws are different in Bavaria. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

I feel bad for the people who moved into her house and his other rentals. They are also going to get screwed. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

pinkie makes a great point. the laws differ from state to state in germany.

according to this site:

http://www.21tsc.army.mil/Aerja/LegalAssist/Areas-Real%20Property/Lanlord.htm

it is german law which indicates the entire country, that the landlord keep the money in a seperate account. this account is supposed to protect the deposit from bankruptcy actions as well. this means by law, the couple should have been able to get their money. the only way the landlord would not have the is that the landlord spent it or didn't put it in a seperate account. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

Yep, he spent it. You would think he would be able to give them the deposit of the new people moving in, at least, but apparently he spent that, too. 

pinkie --- 15 years ago -

thanks Bob, things are always better in a language you can properly understand!

I'm so sorry for your friend, CMS. I'm assuming (hoping) that housing didn't allow a new contract on that house - after all, that's what the housing office is for...I also feel terrible for the landlord though, I guess he also doesn't want to be in that situation... 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

another thing that site mentioned that housing doesn't tell you is that you can pay your deposit in 3 monthly payments. please pass this around along with the link to the site for the benefit of new people who are looking for housing. 

blackssmagic --- 15 years ago -

Listening to so many horror stories of people PCS'ing and getting screwed over by there LL makes me wonder something. Its your last month here in Germany, what if I do not pay the LL the last months rent, let him/her keep the deposit that way no one gets screwed..

the thing is moving back to the states does anyone really think they are going to see a dime of that money, you are in another country and SOL for the most part, and housing is a joke when it comes to helping us out, as was told to CMS's friends; oops sorry there is nothing we can do...you are out over $2,000.00 for the most part 

theoriginaljd --- 15 years ago -

My LL put our deposit into an account that actually has both of our names on it. I would hope that after we are finished paying off his mortgage for him (we have been in this house for 6½ years) that we will get our deposit back. We have taken good care of his house and do all of the minor repairs/maintenance ourselves. 

MAD4EUROPE --- 15 years ago -

How are you guys getting screwed and not getting our deposit back? I mean when you and your LL are inspecting the apartment and everything is kosher...what happens next? They just never return calls or are they making up some imaginary problems so they don't have to give you your deposit. I am not being facetious here but I have not had this problem with my previous German landlords. But I also have never went through the housing office to get an apartment either....hmmmm. 

MAD4EUROPE --- 15 years ago -

Dang, I didn't even answer your question Emma...

Yes, they are supposed to keep it in an account and I have always received my deposit + interest back. Now, in the states it's a different story, someone is ALWAYS trying to rip you off to make that quick buck but I have not experienced that here. *knock on wood* 

Cara fanciulla --- 15 years ago -

My last landlord and I strolled down to the Sparkasse and opened the joint account together. But it turned out to be a ruse.. she really dragged me along to help her carry her groceries home! I miss her. 

MAD4EUROPE --- 15 years ago -

@CF: lol

I know what you mean, our first landlords were GREAT! They were like surrogate parents, absolutely wonderful! The husband died of cancer and his wife died of a heart attack. It was truly sad and even after they died, their family made sure we were taken care of. We moved out a little while later and received all our money plus interest back. 

Cloudless --- 15 years ago -

When I rented the LL died and I didn't even know until it was time to move. So the Big Shot Dentist Son 5 Foot Son shows up with the lease and says, "Your lease says you will leave the house in the same condition as when you moved in". Okay. I actually improved the place by putting up some cabinets and a fence to keep the dog in. He said, "Oh no...it was freshly painted,so you must paint all of the interior. It must be done professionally and I will continue to charge you rent until it is finished". I said, "I have Renter's Insurance, see you in court Napolean". Two days later after the lawyer contacted him, he couldn't wait to give back my deposit and explain what a wonderful tennant I had been for...get this...Ten years! I had bought the freakin' house. Renter's Insurance, priceless. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

I have always gotten our deposits back in the US, and I'm sure that our landlord here will be the fine. There are some people in every culture that will try to get one by if they can, though. Some people just suck. 

Cloudless --- 15 years ago -

Okay..then don't worry about it. You'll be fine. Trust the Germans..Trust the Germans...say it again.Trust the Germans..."They want your friendship...not your money..trust the Germans... 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

Ha! My LL is American. Okay, so he's been here for 60 years, he is still an American deep down. 

Momof3 --- 15 years ago -

Does the LL have a time frame that they are required to give you back your security deposit? 

seriously --- 14 years ago -

bumping

Does the LL have a time frame that they are required to give you back your security deposit?  

Brasco --- 14 years ago -

I have heard 6 months but my advice to anyone who is getting ready to move out of a house and they suspect they will have problems to go to the legal assistance office and get all the facts and knowledge upfront that way they can better confront/manage the move-out.

...also if the legal office needs to get involved it is best the lawyer has all the info before and your quickly able to take whatever action they need to or can make.

If you get on a plane without the money your chances are prettyslim of ever seeing it again 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground