Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Are you allowed to do this?

who's talking here?

angel2009 6
Bob 2
CMS 1
nukatie81 1
balboa850 1
PAWtoScott 1
Cloudless 4
Smiles4u 2
dipthong 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Smiles4u --- 15 years ago -

help finding a home
are you allowed to do that and ask for 10 percent of the rent? 

angel2009 --- 15 years ago -

I doubt it lol 

angel2009 --- 15 years ago -

I am not a Realtor, but i do have bills to pay ;-) for the most part i do
this because im a spouse of a military member and i know how hard it is
being in a new Country!
So yeah, im asking a 10% of the rent amount as a Finders fee!


If she knows how hard it is and is just a goodhearted person why doesn't she do it for free OR better yet register as a business (which every company has to do) and pay taxes like the rest of us! We all (or most of us) have bills to pay. 

nukatie81 --- 15 years ago -

Hmm sounds like the management person at our old rental. We all found people to move into our houses and they started charging a finder's fee. For what, they didn't advertise or anything. All they did was the walk through. I even let the people come and look at our house a couple of times before they moved in. Sometimes I don't think they deserve these fees at all. If this lady is charging then she will probably get in trouble somehow. 

balboa850 --- 15 years ago -

Tell you what, 10% is way cheaper than 1-2 months rent for doing not a damn thing the immobiliens charge. 

angel2009 --- 15 years ago -

I think we had this conversation plenty! If you don't agree with realtor fees don't use/hire them! BUT what she is doing is not kosher I know that much. 

Cloudless --- 15 years ago -

Doesn't sound so bad actually. She's providing a service like the others on the site provide house cleaning, trash hauling, yardwork. I'm sure many of them are not paying taxes. They wouldn't even know what a VAT form is. She'll probably find out though, that it likely won't be easy money. Finding the right place, setting up utilities and all the things that come along with it. So if rent is say, EUR 1000 and she gets 100, I dare say she'll earn it. And then some immobilien will report her anyway, probably. Some people like to be helpful for free, some offer a service for a charge. She probably could have written a little better business letter though. Presentation is everything. 

dipthong --- 15 years ago -

It's usually 10% of the yearly rent. Not rent for a month. 

PAWtoScott --- 15 years ago -

It's usually 10% of the yearly rent. Not rent for a month.
So her fee is not as cheap as it seems. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

she stated she is not a realtor but she is charging a finders fee. hmmm, i'm betting this is not completely legal. she is being paid for providing a service but i'm betting she is not paying taxes on the money she is receiving. her doing this for money also means she is running a business. if she lives off base she needs to register with the germans. if she is living on base she needs to have approval from the base commander.

i see she is also acting as a translator. i'm hoping this is just for confusion in the paperwork, otherwise you could find yourself in some real problems because she probably isn't a licensed translator either and this could lead to a lot of problems concerning rental contracts.

now, having said all that...this isn't a lot different than a realtor would charge and some will ask one month's rent. it's difficult to find houses so this is like everything else on yardsales...is it worth the price???? 

angel2009 --- 15 years ago -

she didn't say she would do all what you described here Bob. If I read it right she will go through ads call and make an appointment and IF wanted she will go to the appt. with you.

And then some immobilien will report her anyway, probably.

and rightfully so! 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

i'm not sure what you mean that she doesn't do all i described. she is finding you a house/appartment, making the appointment and then going to the appointment, if you ask, to translate. this about sums up what i said. i didn't mean she was going to do a document but i would be careful of translations when it comes to rental documents. you would be better off asking the housing office the questions.

i'm not trying to say what she is doing is bad or that problems will occur. i just want to point out that people need to be sure that they get the correct information. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

Any way you look at it, she is earning money that she is not paying taxes on, and if it is 10% of the yearly tax, that can be quite a tidy little sum. 

angel2009 --- 15 years ago -

oops Bob I meant what cloudless said,, sorry! Like setting up utilities and things like that. 

Cloudless --- 15 years ago -

Well, they took the add down. But I'm just curious, why would any of you care if it was against the law or not? It didn't appear she was victimizing anyone. Just making an offer to make a few bucks. I guess it just bothers me that a lot of military people have a "Tattle Tale" mentality--easy now, don't be offended, I didn't say "everyone". Why speculate about something that is of no concern to you? Unless you are a German public defender, maybe. She probably just thought she had a good idea and could make some cash. Oh well, move along now, nothing to see here. Thanks 

Smiles4u --- 15 years ago -

Just posted it to see what everyone thought about the subject, did not mean any harm to anyone. 

Cloudless --- 15 years ago -

I know. Fair question. But then we get into what's legal or not "according to German Law"...and "German Taxes". Great Ceasar's Ghost. So now go after your house cleaner and your trash hauler, and your firewood seller? Go downtown and get deputized if it bothers you. Otherwise, don't worry about it. Just people trying to make a living. By the way, I wash cars on weekends, arrest me already. 

angel2009 --- 15 years ago -

you have your opinion cloudless...may we have ours? 

Cloudless --- 15 years ago -

Sure, Ma'dam judge..please! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground