Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

History Discussion

who's talking here?

Mojo 3
Fran 4
Walt 1
Bob 9
CMS 6
MAD4EUROPE 1
JohnJay 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Bob --- 15 years ago -

i just watched a 2 part show on tv about the nuremberg trials and it got me thinking. i've done research on the trials and i've found many references to the fact that there are people who thought the trials were unjust. many felt it was just one of the "victor's spoils" type of event. there were no laws against any of the 4 charges but 10 people were hung with the quickest death taking almost 15 minutes because the drop length of the rope was shortened, on purpose.

what do you think? 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Ummmmm, I think the Nuremburg trials were mostly for show. After something as horrifying as the Halocaust, people want to put faces to those crimes, and justice to those faces. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

I haven't done alot of study on it, so I can't give a really informed opinion, but I agree with Mojo.

One of my teachers in Georgia was telling us about his grandmother, who was German. She was a young woman during the war years. She swore up and down until the end of her days that Hitler had done nothing wrong and that he was just surrounded by evil men who did bad things in his name. this was based on her meeting him as he drove through her village in an open touring car. She ran up to the car and got a kiss from him.

I think that often just and unjust are a matter of perspective. They are also viewed differently over time as social changes take place. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

And really, it's not like hitler just rolled in one day and took over; he worked at it for years. He was a charismatic speaker, he won over a lot of people, and worked hard to gain a reputation as a great man and a great leader, before the wars and the holocaust were even started. So, it makes sense that there would be a large contingent of people out there who still believed in him, and his cause. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

the idea that what they did was not illegal until the tribunal decided it was so after the fact is not a matter of opinion.

mojo has the right idea with trying to put faces to the acts. they were so desparate to "get the criminals" they picked a replacement to try instead of martian boreman because he got away and could not be brought to the trials but he was tried in absenteeism and found guilty. this means they actually had two people on trial for the same charges pertaining to boreman's position. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

I understand what you are saying, and agree. There were many at the time that disagreed with what happened, as well as many since then. 

Walt --- 15 years ago -

Bob (et al):

I didn't see the episode, but will defer to the accuracy of your post.

I'm not aware of the legitimacy of the law(s) (or lack thereof) under which these war criminals were charged. However, even if no legitimate law existed at the time, I doubt anyone could argue against the most harsh punishment. (remember, it wasn't until a few years ago that identity theft was illegalized-but the absence of a codified law still doesn't make it right/moral/ethical..)

My main issue with what your related is the actions during the executions to increase/prolong suffering. That in my opinion, if absolutely wrong-regardless of the crimes that were committed. (we (USA) did/does have laws against cruel and unusual punishment).

Seriously, I think I read somewhere that WWII accounted for over 100-million deaths worldwide..not to mention the genocide of the death camps.

So, what moral high-ground or justification is there is cause someone additional suffering? One cannot cause a person to suffer comensurately for 1 million people..or 10 million people.

So, if that is in fact true-and additional suffering and misery was caused during the executions-I would argue that regardless of the mitigating circumstances, it was wrong.

My 2 cents (2 euro-cents) 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Geneva Conventions, with the specific clauses about cruel and unusual punishment, were not put into place until 1949, AFTER the trials and in response to WWII. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

there were actually 4 geneva conventions with the third being enacted in 1929. the one you are talking about added the treatment of civilians.

in this case the geneva convention did not play a part because the accused were tried as civilians and not pows. this does not mean it was right to cause unnecessary suffering.

one of the sad things i find about the trials is the russians were doing the same if not worse things but they sat in judgement on the germans. i'm not defending what anyone did during the war but given this and other facts it's no wonder that many think this was simply a show trial. 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

Bob, it's because the Russians didn't lose the war.
Had Germany won it, their actions wouldn't have been considered illegal after law, either (not talking about a moral factor here).

If you win the war, you get to punish the ones who lost.

And let's not forget Mussolini, but I guess getting your genitals cut off with your own sword, and hung naked on a hill was more than any trial would've done to him. 

JohnJay --- 15 years ago -

Where was Julian Assange back then we could have known the real deal on the trails from the get-go.

As for the victors spoils...of course!!! Does anyone really believe anything our government says? 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

fran, the point is we were trying to present this as something as other than the victor's spoils. this is why many people feel the trial was simply a show. we condemned 11 men to death for doing what our ally did. this makes the entire trial seem more like vengeance than justice.

none of the defendants would have done any better if we wouldn't have tried them. the german people would have rounded them up and given them even more of a show trial and probably would have hanged all of them. from everything i've read, the common german people hated the nazis more than anyone else. i know it's hard for some to believe but all the suffering they had to endure during the war was because of the nazis. 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

Bob, are you familiar with Rudolf Heß?
A little off topic, but not less interesting. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

Fran, yes, I'm familiar with Hess. He was Hitler's deputy till he flew to Scotland to try to make peace with the English. Many feel he faked his mental condition at the trial. There are also those who feel he was murdered while at Spandau. 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

Do you think he was murdered? After all, with the new developments in the former Soviet Union, his release from prison became likely, and he could have told a different story about the British and who knows what else.
I'm not a conspiracy type of person, but who commits suicide after 41 years in prison, with a possibilty of getting released soon?
I thought the book his son wrote was very interesting. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

I was watching a show on eugenics. It was interesting that the US was very forward in the eugenics movement. Hitler apparently got some good information on how to improve the German people to help develope the "Super Race" from eugenics experts from the US.

The US has not always had shining moments.

My mothers family tried to escape Poland in the late 30's and were unable to emmigrate to the US because the US was not taking jewish immigrants from europe at that time. They ended up going to Canada, becoming Canadian citizens, and then coming to the US. All that trouble to become legal American immigrants. Of course, legally immigrating is a whole nother thread! 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

Interesting story on the St.Louis

The Germans were by far not the only ones who treated Jews badly. 

JohnJay --- 15 years ago -

The US has not always had shining moments.


Understatement for sure. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

That is very interesting Fran, thank you for sharing that. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

fran, i haven't really thought or done much research on the possibility that hess was murdered. it's possible but it's also possible that being completely alone in the prison, with the exception of the guards, finally go to him.

as far as hating the jews, the catholics were taught it was their duty to hate the jews because they were the christ killers. when you remember europe was controlled by the catholics for hundreds of years the hatred is understandable. even the fine people of the spanish inquisition happily took time out from murdering innocent people for not believing as they do to kill jews. england tried to deport all its jews at one point.

cms, there are worse moments in u.s. history than not letting the jews come to america. there is the is the slaughter of the american indians because they were sub human (sound familiar), the trail of tears (america's batan death march), the slavery and treatment of the blacks (because they were sub human (famaliar ring come back?), the massacre of the korean civilians (can't remember the exact place right now), forcing the japanese into internment camps at the beginning of wwii... the list goes on. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

I would disagree that those are worse moment, most of them. I would say that many of those are just as bed. That is, of course, my opinion. Had my relatives not been lucky enough to afford to go to relatives in Canada, they would most likely have died, or at least been put in a camp. As it was, not all of the family was able to go, and did not make it to see the end of the war.

Anyway, I did not say that was the worst moment, just that America had some moments that were not so great. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

cms, i do feel that outright slaughter of innocent people because they are thought to be sub human is worse than denying entrance to the u.s. in most of the cases i mentioned the people did not have the choice of a camp where they might survive. the only future they had was death. i'm not sure if you've ever heard a common saying from the old west times "the only good indian is a dead indian". americans viewed the indians about the same as the nazis and many others viewed the jews.

what happened to your family obviously leads you to believe things were worse for you and i understand that completely. being indian i feel that what was done to my people was worse because we were murdered simply because we lived on OUR land. the white man came and murdered us for our land. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

sorry for the rant. it doesn't belong in this discussion. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

I understand that completely, and my husband is a card carrying member of his tribe, as my son will be. The fact that the US denied entry to people trying to emmigrate because their imposed quotas were filled DID lead to the death of some who would have been saved if they had been allowed in. I did not mean to belittle the plight of the Native Americans, though. That saying from the old west applied to pretty much anyone who was not white at the time, too, including black people and asians. you know, anyone who was different. 

MAD4EUROPE --- 15 years ago -

@ Bob: What show were you watching? I would like to see if I could find it. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

it was a show called Nuremberg with Alec Baldwin. it was a pretty good show. it's on amazon for $9.33 right now. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground