Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Unlocking smartphones is illegal

who's talking here?

Nicksdad 2
Nomen Nescio 1
Thumper 2
dipthong 7
Germerican 1
Shoxen Kopf 2
giorgio 1
Anagramless 1
whatsup 5
a3766916uu 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

whatsup --- 13 years ago -

i've seen more ads about unlocking phones or selling unlocked phones. this is now illegal, since last year. if you own the phone you will not be able to prove you didn't unlock it so the bottom line is don't buy the phone. i know, you think it's stupid but it's still the law. unlocking the phone is different than jail breaking which is still legal. make sure you know the difference to stay out of trouble. 

dipthong --- 13 years ago -

This will not last long. There are already very strong lobbies working on this.

Besides, most cell companies, including AT&T, T-Mobile, Vodafone, Deutsche Telekom, etc. will unlock your phone once your contract is satisfied.

You can also get your phone unlocked if you are traveling overseas and need to use your phone outside of the company's coverage area.

There are many legal ways to unlock a phone. 

Thumper --- 13 years ago -

The DMCA are the group responsible for this ridiculous law. I believe it came into effect 26 January 2013.

Whatsup is correct, it is illegal to unlock a phone, this has nothing to do with contractual obligations, the ones that are more in favor for this law to stay in effect are the phone manufacturers such as Apple and Motorola (who recently began proceedings with court actions against someone in the US). If a cell phone is locked to a specific network, you cannot use it elsewhere, thus forcing you to buy a new handset.
Although basis of the argument against this law is the consumer has paid for the handset upon expiration of the contract, therefore should be free to do as they please with it.
As with most things, it's all about the $.
The chance of anyone actually being successful or even beginning court action on "Joe Public" would in my opinion be quite unlikely, however be aware that the maximum penalty can be 5 years in prison and/or $500,000 fine per incident! 

Nicksdad --- 13 years ago -

Of course, the DMCA ruling on unlocking phones only applies in the US. Why worry about it on this board? 

dipthong --- 13 years ago -

Whatsup is correct, it is illegal to unlock a phone, this has nothing to do with contractual obligations,

Please explain why it is so easy to get a phone unlocked by the carrier once the phone is out of contract.

Here is one article that says differently.

Further, I don't think we'll hear much about anyone being in any legal hot water for unlocking their phone.

More recently (within 20 hours):
http://howto.cnet.com/8301-11310_39-57576116-285/how-to-use-an-at-t-iphone-on-t-mobiles-no-contract-network/ 

Thumper --- 13 years ago -

I don't think so either, nor do I particularly care as it won't be me, I was merely offering advice.

http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/02/the-law-against-unlocking-cellphones-is-anti-consumer-anti-business-and-anti-common-sense/272894/

https://www.eff.org/is-it-illegal-to-unlock-a-phone

Hope this is of some help. 

whatsup --- 13 years ago -

this is one of the fastest ways to get a discussion going on this board, tell people they shouldn't do something. ya gotta love the way people really believe it's ok to do something just because they want to. 

Nicksdad --- 13 years ago -

DMCA's been around quite a while, I wonder how many of our congresscritters or judges got their pockets lined by US cell providers to get this interpretation of DMCA passed into law? 

dipthong --- 13 years ago -

ya gotta love the way people really believe it's ok to do something just because they want to.

Who said it is OK? 

whatsup --- 13 years ago -

dipthong: i made that post after talking with some of the people i work with. 

Nomen Nescio --- 13 years ago -

Who said it is OK?

Duh, you?

Every one of your posts has said you do not agree with this law (with good links I must add)

and fwiw i agree with you


3... 2... 1... 

dipthong --- 13 years ago -

Saying the law is stupid, and disagreeing with the law, is completely different than saying it is OK.

I am pretty sure most people would be in agreement with this being a stupid law. This is why I think it will be short lived. 

whatsup --- 13 years ago -

i don't understand the feeling that the law is stupid. you get a phone at well below the normal retail price. you get that price because you sign a contract with a specific carrier which are basically monthly payments on the phone. if you unlock the phone and manage to get out of the monthly contract then you are basically defaulting on the loan. if you want an unlocked phone you can buy one but it will cost you a lot more money. the unlocked iphone 5 sells for about $706 the ones that are locked for AT&T for example are around $300, now do you see the reason for the law? 

dipthong --- 13 years ago -

Keep something in mind. When this law was written, AT&T simply would not unlock a phone. Period. It was the public outcry that forced them to start doing so. They only do it after the contract is fulfilled. I have no problem with this, at all. I have no problem with fulfilling an obligation.

Also, if you don't fulfill your contract, you pay an early termination fee. That fee, in part, pays for the phone that you got at a subsidized price. So, in the end, you are paying for the phone. Once you pay the penalty, there is no reason to be held hostage to the cell carrier.

Once a phone is paid for, either by fulfilling the contract, or by canceling early and paying the penalty, it should not be a problem to unlock the phone.

Telling people that they cannot make changes to their own property is pure bullshiit. As long as the changes don't allow the device to illegally gain use of a service that is normally paid for, it is nobodies business.

Again, I am not saying it is OK to unlock a phone in order to circumvent a contract.

When I came to Germany, I had a T-Mobile locked phone still under contract. I told T-Mobile that I was leaving the country and they allowed me to unlock my phone for use outside of their service area. That is the right thing to do. T-Mobile waived the early termination fee because I only had two months left on the contract, and I had been with the company for over 12 years.

Let's take a look at another scenario. Suppose I get a phone with T-Mobile in Germany. I pay a penny for the phone and sign a three year contract. If, for any reason I do not fulfill this contract, I am going to have to pay a penalty. If I unlock the phone, and decide to use the phone with another carrier, that is my business, as long as I meet my obligation to T-Mobile. The law, as it is written, is stupid.

Also, what if I am an AT&T customer, and I am going on vacation out of the country. Should I have to buy a new phone in the country I am visiting in order to be able to use the phone while abroad? That is just stupid. What will I do with the phone when my vacation is over? Throw it away because it cannot be used stateside? Or, do I spend extra to buy an unlocked phone to begin with? If someone is traveling, and under contract, the option should be offered to pay off the subsidized phone so it can be unlocked. As it is, the cell companies have us by the short hairs, and it is ridiculous.

I don't know if you are aware of this, but T-Mobile U.S.A. is now branding themselves as the "Un-Carrier." They have done away with subsidized phones, completely. They will sell you a phone at full price with a small down payment, and then allow you to pay for the phone on a monthly basis until it is paid in full. They have also done away with contracts and lowered their rates. I wrote about this in another thread, but there is now an unlimited data plan with no caps for $20 a month. That includes 4G LTE. T-Mobile also bought MetroPCS, which is going to be a huge improvement for existing customers due to the number of extra towers available.


More info: I forgot to mention before that T-Mobile tried to pull a fast one on me. When I returned stateside, T-Mobile wanted me to sign a 2 year contract in order to have service. They were not providing me any equipment, at all. I had my own phones to use. I asked the T-Mobile rep why I would lock myself into a contract when I was not being provided anything more than the cell service I was paying for on a monthly basis. There was no answer from the rep. I ended up getting service without a contract. These companies love to lock you into a contract so they can threaten you with huge penalties if you decide their service sucks and want to go elsewhere. 

whatsup --- 13 years ago -

"Also, what if I am an AT&T customer, and I am going on vacation out of the country."

oh the trials of modern life. i wonder what people did before we had cell phones to take on vacation. personally, my cell phone is the last thing i worry about when i go on vacation. i lived for about 40 years without one and the one i have now sits at home most of the time. 

dipthong --- 13 years ago -

oh the trials of modern life. i wonder what people did before we had cell phones to take on vacation. personally, my cell phone is the last thing i worry about when i go on vacation. i lived for about 40 years without one and the one i have now sits at home most of the time.

I know exactly what people did before cell phones. I'm seriously considering getting rid of mine. I don't use it when I am driving, and I hate the constant interruptions when I am away from home doing errands or meeting with friends, etc. I find that most anything that someone tells me via my cell, can wait until later. I am not a doctor, nor do I play one on TV, so that loaf of bread will have to wait until someone else goes out. 

Shoxen Kopf --- 13 years ago -

The pollizi were doing a check out nar the 6. They were asking to see iPhones and checking to see if you unlocked it. A few long hair hippy types were being handcuffed and frisked. 

a3766916uu --- 13 years ago -

It's not illegal to unlock ur phone here in Germany! 

giorgio --- 13 years ago -

The German Polizei is not allowed to check your private phone to see if it is unlocked or not (privacy protection). They can only check your phone if you where arrested for committing a major crime. 

Anagramless --- 13 years ago -

Reason #679 I am so glad to be leaving soon!! 

dipthong --- 13 years ago -

Reason #679 I am so glad to be leaving soon!!

Say what? You want the gubmint telling you that you can't unlock your phone? 

Shoxen Kopf --- 13 years ago -

Was just in CONUS at a bar and saw someone with jailbreaked phone. I called 911 and to my surprise, they sent the entire swat team. 

Germerican --- 13 years ago -

So what if it's illegal? Are the cops gonna co e kick down my door? Are there random traffic stops where they check your phone. I'm commenting on this thread on a jail broken and unlocked phone, woohoo!!!! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground