EXCERPT: "Today's a very sad day," said Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.), the top Republican in the Senate Armed Services Committee. Citing the concerns of Marine Commandant General James Amos, who is opposed to the repeal, McCain said, "When your life's on the line, you don't want any distraction."
Okay, I'm not in the military but can you answer this for me (to all the soldiers on here)...
When you're on the battlefield, you know, getting shot at and whatnot OR if you're seriously injured and the combat medic comes to save your life, is the first thing running through your mind us their sex/love life??
And when this passes, how many soldiers do you really think are going to "come out of the closet"? I'm thinking, not too many.
@IMNSHFO: Do you really think that gay marines don't exist?
You obviously don't know a Marine. Which im a former Marine. BTW im as straight as they come. Yes I'm sure they exist. And no, I don't think they'll come out of the closet unless they are absoutely sure of the surroundings. In combat there are always situations that never get documented; turn the other cheek in so many words.
Military is doomed.Call it what you want. Im just glad I am not part of those situations where looking over shoulder in your comfort zone is no longer a safe zone.
You're right. Every gay man wants to sleep with a hateful bigot. I'm sure it's their dream. If you haven't noticed, normal gay men will try sleeping with other gay men. And yes, for most gay men, you can tell right away who's gay and who's straight. I have gay friends who will tell you straight (ironic no?) up what's what.
Women in the military are in more danger from straight men than any straight man being in danger from a gay man.
Being a marine is first a individual choice. then it's a matter of how you fit in within your peers. Unity and espirt de corps is very tight and more united then in any other branch of service. Just take a look at some of the polls that are out about combat marines take on this policy. Over 68 percent against. I'd call that pretty strong.
It is GOING to happen....soon enough it WILL be a reality. There have been gays in the military for YEARS....and folks have always looked at them and "wondered" about them...I have. I have been friends with both male and females that I KNEW beyond the shadow of doubt that were gay...it didnt bother me because I guess they were not "in your face about it". I was at the KMCC the other week and saw two women whom I KNOW are military walking around holding hands and playing nuzzling thier necks...I admit, I felt a twinge of dislike....yes I am prejeduice....sorry...it is gonna take some time for me to get use to it....cause ALL my life growing up I have been taught about..."Adam and Eve and not Adam and Steve" This IS going to be very interesting.
Just take a look at some of the polls that are out about combat marines take on this policy. Over 68 percent against.
I highly doubt they did every indiviual. And if they did, they are going to have to suck it up and be better marines who actually believe in a little word called "freedom".
huh? Don't even know where that came from! There always were and always will be gay people! Get used to it IMNSHFO! They are not freaks of nature or mentally disturbed, they are people like you and me! End of story!
Wow who knew there would be such a lively debate...I have been in the army nearly 15 years and this policy change is way overdue,you dont get the social change and cultural acceptance when people hide their bigotry behind rules, policies and lies. Now I am sure there will be incidents, as there have in the past and the same jack-a$$s who are against the change now will be the ones saying see I told you. But the truth of the matter is just like racism or sexism the problem lies with the homofobes (sp) and not gays who would like to serve. The day after the repeal will be a great day.
I think it's great. I grew up Marine Corps, have worked with both the Army and AF and am married to AF. I've know both gay men and women in all these services. It's really nothing new. Usually their coworkers know anyway and I really haven't know any that were bothered by it. I hate that some feel forced to marry the opposite sex to cover up the truth and am glad that they can now be themselves. I know my husband, who deploys on a regular basis has not been bothered by it all. It's not like they're going to start throwing themselves at you just because they can. If you're a straight male, do you throw yourself at every female you see? :P Come on...
The is not a normal subject to dicuss at a normal level. Otherwise it wouldn't have been on hold like this since 1993.
It held on for way too long, Possibly because the elephants were in power for that big chunk of time idunno. but comparativly to where our country is on gender roles, sexism, racism and almost every aspect of general personal freedoms this change is overdue.